←
Liron Shapira35,861 posts
Liron Shapira avatar

Liron Shapira

@liron

Host of Doom Debates — disagreements that must be resolved before the world ends.

◷ Joined July 2008▧ 3,652 Photos and videos
Liron Shapira avatar
Liron Shapira@liron·20h

NEW: @Aligned_SI's Plan To Get P(Doom) Below 0.01% Dr. Craig Kaplan's is the founder of Superintelligence.com, an extremely valuable domain for the newly-rebranded field of “super intelligence”. Craig has been building intelligent systems since the 1980s. He did his PhD research at Carnegie Mellon with Nobel laureate Herbert Simon, one of the founders of AI, and he built PredictWallStreet, a collective-intelligence platform that powered more than $2 billion in stock trades before it was acquired. He takes AI extinction risk seriously. His P(Doom) is 10%. But unlike me, he thinks he knows how to fix it. He plans to put “personal superintelligence” into the hands of millions which he believes will lower P(Doom) below 1%. These are part of a larger plan to create “superintelligent networks” which lower P(Doom) below 0.01%. Craig says a network like that is safer because the AIs can check each other’s work faster than humans can think. Craig and I clash on whether intelligence makes an AI more thoughtful, whether a superintelligence will want to grab the stars, and whether peaceful “stoner” AIs can survive next to a “Caesar” AI that wants to conquer the universe. We cover: ⬜ The three-phase plan to cut P(Doom) 1,000x ⬜ Collective intelligence vs. black-box AI ⬜ “Personalized Superintelligence” ⬜ Lessons from PredictWallStreet ⬜ Craig's mainline doom scenario ⬜ Raising ASI like a child ⬜ Orthogonality thesis ⬜ Caesar AI vs. stoner AI Craig called our debate one of his best podcast appearances because of the pushback. We didn’t reach much consensus, but it was a high-quality good faith Doom Debate. Take a look and decide who *you* agree with!

0:48
Liron Shapira avatar
Liron Shapira@liron·40m

Oikos 000

Post attachment

This is the platonic ideal of diet food: ✅ Best ratio of satiety&nutrition to calories ✅ Somewhat appetizing ✅ Taste goes with everything You can average any other food’s nutrition vector with FAGE Nonfat’s by mixing or alternating spoonfuls, sometimes even *improving* taste.

Post attachment
Liron Shapira avatar
Liron Shapira@liron·2h

Dating advice nerd here. There are a few tactical things you can do in the area of “flake defense” which more generally are part of enhancing the text-based part of the courtship. “Flake defense” consists of (1) Texting to make you seem cool / friendly / a good fit for them / worth the time meeting (2) Making the logistics smooth and "keeping the lead warm" as they say in sales It's very common for people to neglect both on the basis that setting an appointment should be all that's required. But try empathizing with the flaker… A casual date is a pretty large investment in time and effort (generally about 2x bigger cost for a woman than man), plus significant downside risks (generally about 5x higher for woman than man), plus opportunity cost of other people that they can focus their attention on (generally 2-5x higher for young woman than young man). This is why skillful flake defense often plays a pivotal role in the courtship process. (Personally, I ended up marrying someone I met on a dating app who was in the process of flaking on me, so I consider this skill to be of >$1 million value.)

I've had about the same amount of girls flaking dates as actual dates on Hinge. Several of them by unmatching me without saying a word, just a few hours before the date (and Hinge doesn't notify you).

Liron Shapira avatar
Liron Shapira@liron·5h

Make sure to catch up on Eli’s P(Doom)!

NEW: 14-year-old forecaster challenges my P(Doom)! Eli Goldfine (@realTomBayes) is an unusually thoughtful 14-year-old forecaster and podcast host who’s rapidly becoming an authoritative voice in the prediction market space. In this unique episode, Eli challenges me to defend my high-P(Doom) position with many sharp questions. He expects superintelligence by 2032, but is skeptical that the extinction risk can be meaningfully estimated. I claim you can't opt out of Bayesian epistemology. All aboard the Doom Train! 🚂 We also cover what it's like to grow up in the AGI era, and Eli's hobbies which include reading rationalist bloggers, betting on prediction markets, vibe coding with Claude, and developing a software startup for astronomers. I've debated Nobel Prize and Turing Award winners. Now I'm spawn camping to debate the top minds of the middle school graduating class. Highly recommended! Topics covered 👇 ⬜ Eli's Podcast, The Supercycle ⬜ Interviewing Robin Hanson and Sam Bankman-Fried ⬜ Eli's Betting Market Scandal at School ⬜ Will Eli Graduate High School? ⬜ Decentralized Telescope Software ⬜ Futarchy ⬜ What's Your P(Doom)™ ⬜ Pascal's Wager for Accelerationists ⬜ E/acc ⬜ Predicting ASI by 2032 ⬜ Orthogonality and Moral Realism ⬜ Can Safety Keep Pace with Capabilities? ⬜ Instrumental Convergence ⬜ The Case for Racing China ⬜ Ideological Turing Test In all seriousness, Eli is an amazing guest because in addition to miraculously having adult-level knowledge and critical thinking skills, he came in with a low ego and willingness to update his views in realtime. All of us must look at reality with fresh eyes, because what's happening with AI doesn't fit any preconceived mental model. Sometimes a teenager gets this better than most adults.

1:06
iQ Company avatar
⟳ Liron Shapira retweeted
iQ Company@iQCompanies·23h

What if the key to safer AI isn't one superintelligence, but millions keeping each other accountable? On Doom Debates, @iQCompanies CEO Craig Kaplan joins @Liron Shapira to explore how personal superintelligence could help drive p(doom) below 0.01%. youtu.be/SLD6HIdFhXw

Liron Shapira avatar
Liron Shapira@liron·Nov 17

I’m not NOT a doomer but 75% chance the current cyberattack alarm is like the time we all hyperfixated on Boeing planes having various parts breaking down.

Holly ⏸️ Elmore avatar
⟳ Liron Shapira retweeted
Holly ⏸️ Elmore@ilex_ulmus·Nov 16

Afaik I was the first person to publicly call for Nuremberg trials for AI companies, for risking all of our lives even though there hadn't been time to put laws against creating existential risk on the books when they did it. Now it seems an AI company exec agrees. I wonder how long that executive (seems like they have boardroom access) has known they are committing a crime against humanity? I wonder if they feel relieved, like they got it off their chest to admit what they are doing is bad? I wonder what further cope keeps them there. (If it was Dario Amodei or an Anthropic person I can almost guarantee they think acknowledging their crimes against humanity makes them even more of an utilitarian dilemma ubermensch 🙄) My mouth fell open when I first heard Daniel say that someone could believe that they were the Nazi in the analogy and still be committing the crime against humanity. Obviously they aren't going to stop simply bc of their own consciences-- we need to make them stop with laws, and, yes, by prosecuting the crimes they've already committed against humanity. Everyone working at a frontier AI company today deserves to go to jail. And today I learned that some of them know that.

0:43
Benjamin Todd avatar
⟳ Liron Shapira retweeted
Benjamin Todd@ben_j_todd·Nov 16

Arguments like this based on AI's lack of real world impact seem to be making a major mistake: 1. Real world daily life impact is a lagging indicator. If you wait till the world is visibly transformed, it'll be too late. 2. Real world impact is probably exponential e.g. End 2026: +1% GDP (nbd) End 2027: +3% GDP (big deal but daily life the ~same) End 2028: +9% GDP (transformative effects on many industries & geopolitics, maybe mass layoffs) End 2029: +27% GDP (self-replicating robot factories in the desert, but downtown New York etc. still looks the same) End 2030: +100% GDP (obviously sci fi future) 3. There are real world impacts! Many use AI tools for hours a day. Some roles have become 10x more productive. A decade of mathematical progress was made in months. AI solved protein folding. Self-driving cars are on the streets. [What I say in 2 isn't a forecast, but rather an illustration of how exponential effects could look over time.]

Post attachment
Garrison Lovely avatar
⟳ Liron Shapira retweeted
Garrison Lovely@GarrisonLovely·Nov 15

I had known Susan Rice was safety pilled for a while but this is still quite something

🚨URGENT WARNING! Former National Security Advisor Susan Rice says "there is nothing more urgent than stopping Al from achieving super intelligence" and causing human "EXTINCTION." The next Senate Majority Leader MUST make Al safeguards a TOP PRIORITY. Humanity cannot afford to wait!

1:22
Liron Shapira avatar
Liron Shapira@liron·Nov 15

Teaser

Post attachment

Ok I finally wrote the sequel about levers — it was actually pretty f*cking confusing and took me 20 hours 😂 Just finishing it up…

John Sherman avatar
⟳ Liron Shapira retweeted
John Sherman@ForHumanityPod·Nov 14

Thrilled and honored to speak alongside @So8res and @AmbassadorRice before the @StopTheAIRace's DC March For An AI Treaty today. What an inspirational day. We're going to ban RSI. And don't believe the false frame big tech wants to put on this: We Are The Optimists.

11:32
Liron Shapira avatar
Liron Shapira@liron·Nov 14

Context:

Liron Shapira @liron May 27 Article We need to talk about Paul Graham Paul Graham (@paulg) has been a mixed bag for me: In the field of entrepreneurship, I've long appreciated him as one of the greats. From reading his essays in high school to becoming a tech