I'm launching a tech-literate, historically informed, fuck-it-let's-go Substack today, and I'm calling it The Rip Current. Here's the first post! Please subscribe, and check out theripcurrent.com to see the ethical standards I'll be observing in this new phase of life.
AI is a deeply undemocratic force in our lives. Voting is your revenge. Here’s why AI bombs at the polls, and how our collective voice is revealing its political weaknesses. theripcurrent.com/p/ai-doesn…
Jacob was a senior researcher who joined Anthropic in May. My Anthropic colleagues and I had been trying to recruit him for ~2 years, because we knew he was a strong researcher at OpenAI. Before he left, I pitched him to stay and join my team, and I was sad he decided to leave, as are many of my colleagues. 100% agree with him that AI poses serious risks to society, and I'm glad he's speaking out!
I resigned from Anthropic today. I spent the last three years doing pretraining research at both OpenAI and Anthropic. Neither company is acting responsibly. They are racing straight to self-improving superintelligence and gambling with our lives. More thoughts below.
Former Anthropic employee Jacob Coxon says the AI industry is "gambling with our lives." He tells Anderson what he finds "most scary is if AI is used to make itself more intelligent" and warns these companies are "compelled to race toward building a deadly technology."
Both sides have now made their opening pitch to an eight-person jury that's advisory only — Judge Gonzalez Rogers rules. Neither side has presented actual evidence yet. Seven weeks to go.
Whatever the jury thinks about who these platforms are "intended" for, he says the evidence will show the majority of users on both platforms are adults.
Schmidt's framing of the states' actual burden: they have to prove Instagram and Facebook were marketed to kids under 13, or that Meta knew it had underage kids on the platforms and didn't do enough.
Worth remembering here, for anyone shocked at the idea that Meta isn’t required to do any of those things: we haven’t had a definitive Federal online privacy or online safety law in this country.
On age: Schmidt listed three things Meta did that the law didn't require. No requirement to ask users' age — Meta asked anyway. No requirement to investigate age — Meta did it anyway. No requirement that users provide age at signup — Meta required it anyway.
Schmidt's framing: Meta weighed real concerns on both sides — well-being, and people's ability to express themselves. Result: they banned filters that explicitly pushed cosmetic surgery, not the category entirely.
Meta banned them to study the question, per Schmidt — a 10-month review, which he says is a far cry from how other companies would handle it. Findings: data on product impact was "negative," but research into well-being impact was "too new and not well-understood."
On the filters story from this morning: Schmidt says it's more complicated. The filters were third-party products, posted to Instagram by outside developers — not something Meta built.
That’s Schmidt’s theme (and the crux of how he’s defended pharma clients and Meta in the past) — that scientific consensus hasn’t been reached, and thus claims of harm are impossible to lay at his clients’ feet definitively.