←
Andrew Sissons14,531 posts
Andrew Sissons avatar

Andrew Sissons

@ACJSissons

Deputy Director for Sustainable Future @nesta_uk. Cover a mix of climate, economics, energy, heating. Ex civil servant, chief economist. Personal account.

◷ Joined October 2010▧ 1,748 Photos and videos
Andrew Sissons avatar
Andrew Sissons@ACJSissons·24 Oct 2023

Very excited to publish this: an essay from @antonhowes on energy transitions of the past, with an intro by me. It gives a great insight into how economies can create energy abundance, how it changes lives and how it can be squandered nesta.org.uk/feature/what-th…

Andrew Sissons avatar
Andrew Sissons@ACJSissons·2 Aug 2024

I know this is all contentious, but having one of your biggest airports surrounded by car-choked countryside, having one of your more successful cities constrained to stay fairly small…seems worth fixing to me

Andrew Sissons avatar
Andrew Sissons@ACJSissons·2 Aug 2024

But there are also bad reasons it is difficult. The Green Belt is one formidable, entirely man-made barrier. The other is that Bristol airport - and almost all of this scheme - is in North Somerset, not Bristol. Which makes everything much more fraught.

Post attachmentPost attachment
Andrew Sissons avatar
Andrew Sissons@ACJSissons·2 Aug 2024

Build a tram to the airport. Build a few thousand homes at every stop. Use the proceeds to help pay for the tram. I know there are good reasons it might be difficult. But afaik a feasible route has been identified (I think to the other side of the reservoirs from my silly line)

Post attachment
Andrew Sissons avatar
Andrew Sissons@ACJSissons·2 Aug 2024

Bristol Airport is the 8th busiest in the UK, but has no train or tram link. The parking situation there is mad - the whole area is a giant car park. The Bristol area also needs a lot more homes. If only there was a way to ease both pressures at once… bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c886…

Andrew Sissons avatar
Andrew Sissons@ACJSissons·29 Jul 2024

Here’s the original piece btw And a clarification: Baumol doesn’t just apply to public services, but to any with low productivity growth. “Public services” - like health & education - can be private sector, but still tend to have low productivity growth acjsissons.medium.com/the-ba…

Andrew Sissons avatar
Andrew Sissons@ACJSissons·29 Jul 2024

So I think rather than treating taxes as a necessary evil, we should pitch them as a route to get people more of what they want. While focusing relentlessly on public sector productivity, of course. It turns out to be one of the logical conclusions of Baumol for me…

Andrew Sissons avatar
Andrew Sissons@ACJSissons·29 Jul 2024

I’ve written about this more airily in the past. When you ask “what would make life better?” in rich economies, I think most of the answers involve more public sector or collective action (health, environment, transport etc.). So probably higher taxes. acjsissons.medium.com/what-w…

Post attachment
Andrew Sissons avatar
Andrew Sissons@ACJSissons·29 Jul 2024

Baumol’s “cost disease” only works if demand for lower productivity services is income elastic (we want more as we get richer) and price inelastic (we only want a bit less as prices rise). Vollrath piece here makes this point if you don’t believe me: growthecon.com/feed/2017/05/…

Post attachment
Andrew Sissons avatar
Andrew Sissons@ACJSissons·29 Jul 2024

That means productivity in public services is important (notwithstanding measurement issues). But it’s also an important point in its own right. If people want more of these services as they get richer, we should give them more of these services. Even if that means higher taxes.

Andrew Sissons avatar
Andrew Sissons@ACJSissons·29 Jul 2024

One of the responses to my piece on the Baumol effect was: it means spending more on public services, and therefore higher taxes over time. I think that’s broadly right, but: as our incomes rise, we seem to want more of the types of services often provided by the state

This tweet is unavailable

Richard Jones avatar
⟳ Andrew Sissons retweeted
Richard Jones@RichardALJones·22 Jul 2024

A good post making a really important point: Baumol's so-called "cost disease" is not a disease at all, but the all-important mechanism by which the benefits of necessarily uneven rates of productivity growth in different sectors are spread across the whole economy.

Final plug for my new personal blog. The Baumol effect is one of the most powerful forces in the economy,raising wages for everyone. And yet it is normally described as a “cost disease”, wrongly imo. I think we should embrace the Baumol effect more acjsissons.medium.com/the-ba…