←
☧ Aaronaeus ☧21,569 posts
☧ Aaronaeus ☧ avatar

☧ Aaronaeus ☧

@Aaronaeus

✝️ Jesus is LORD 🇻🇦 Catholic Convert 🛐 Husband & Father 📖 Bible Study Leader 🇺🇸 Conservative 🏈 Vikings Fan

◷ Joined July 2019▧ 5,103 Photos and videos
☧ Aaronaeus ☧ avatar
☧ Aaronaeus ☧@Aaronaeus·Nov 18

🧵I’ve watched @JimmyAkin3000’s latest video, The Secret Origin of Sola Scriptura (Catholics Named It), twice now, and I’m still astounded. It reminds me of George Orwell’s 1984, where history is continually rewritten to conform to the present narrative. Apparently, Sola Scriptura has ALWAYS been the defining principle of the Protestant Reformation. Or has it?🧵

Post attachment
☧ Aaronaeus ☧ avatar
☧ Aaronaeus ☧@Aaronaeus·Nov 18

I’m not claiming Protestants are deliberately falsifying documents. But projecting modern Protestant terminology and theological frameworks backward onto the Reformation creates a misleading picture of history. Orwell called it “rectification.” Jimmy Akin calls us back to the historical evidence. If Sola Scriptura is so foundational, shouldn’t we at least get its history right? Watch the full episode: youtu.be/NG4rZWehlqo?is=so3g…

☧ Aaronaeus ☧ avatar
☧ Aaronaeus ☧@Aaronaeus·Nov 18

And THAT brings us back to Orwell’s 1984. At the Ministry of Truth, historical records were “rectified” to make the past agree with the present. Today, Sola Scriptura is presented as though it had ALWAYS been the Reformers’ great slogan and formal principle. Historical revisionism, anyone?

☧ Aaronaeus ☧ avatar
☧ Aaronaeus ☧@Aaronaeus·Nov 18

Here’s the real kicker. Some of the earliest identifiable uses of Sola Scriptura as the NAME of a doctrine came from CATHOLIC critics of Protestantism in the early 1600s. The Reformers certainly advocated Scripture’s unique authority. But the familiar slogans and historical narrative developed much later.

☧ Aaronaeus ☧ avatar
☧ Aaronaeus ☧@Aaronaeus·Nov 18

It gets even more interesting. The designation of Sola Scriptura as the Reformation’s “formal principle” originated in 19th-century Protestant theology. And the famous “Five Solas” weren’t grouped together until the 20th century. Centuries AFTER Luther!

☧ Aaronaeus ☧ avatar
☧ Aaronaeus ☧@Aaronaeus·Nov 18

Let’s start with Martin Luther. According to research cited by Akin, Luther used these Latin expressions approximately: Sola Fide: 1,200 times. Sola Gratia: 200 times. Sola Scriptura: 20 times. Yet we’re told Sola Scriptura was the great rallying cry of the Reformation? Some rallying cry!

Post attachment
☧ Aaronaeus ☧ avatar
☧ Aaronaeus ☧@Aaronaeus·Nov 18

Now consider the Protestant Reformation. We’re repeatedly told that Sola Scriptura was: 1) The Reformers’ slogan. 2) Their rallying cry. 3) Their formal principle. 4) One of the original Five Solas. But as Jimmy Akin demonstrates, the historical evidence tells a VERY different story.

☧ Aaronaeus ☧ avatar
☧ Aaronaeus ☧@Aaronaeus·Nov 18

In Orwell’s 1984, Winston Smith works at the Ministry of Truth, where his job is to “rectify” historical records. When Oceania changes enemies, history is rewritten to make it appear that Oceania has ALWAYS been at war with its current enemy. The past must conform to the present.

Post attachment
☧ Aaronaeus ☧ avatar
⟳ ☧ Aaronaeus ☧ retweeted
☧ Aaronaeus ☧@Aaronaeus·Nov 17

“Whoever does not love remains in death. … Dear children, let us love not in word or speech but in deed and truth.” — 1 John 3:14c, 18

Post attachment
☧ Aaronaeus ☧ avatar
☧ Aaronaeus ☧@Aaronaeus·Nov 17

This is the best take on the Trent Horn splitting away from Catholic Answers.

It's probably best that whatever happened between Trent and Catholic Answers stay private (as long as there was no impropriety). If publicized, whatever led to the split would likely damage both parties' reputations, scandalize the faithful, provide ammunition for heretics, etc

MrCasey avatar
⟳ ☧ Aaronaeus ☧ retweeted
MrCasey@MrCasey62·Nov 16

Bergsma: “Protestants think Sacraments are things WE do. No, sacraments are things God does TO US. In baptism the Holy Spirit acts ON US. In the Eucharist Jesus comes TO ME. In Confession Jesus ABSOLVES ME. It’s like throwing yourself in front of a bus—the bus does all the work.”

1:45
Jimmy Akin avatar
⟳ ☧ Aaronaeus ☧ retweeted
Jimmy Akin@JimmyAkin3000·Nov 16

"Sola scriptura" is supposed to be (1) a slogan invented by the Reformers and (2) used as their rallying cry. (3) They regarded it as their formal principle, and (4) it was just one of the five sola-slogans they had. But all of that is . . . WRONG! Jimmy Akin reveals what really happened. youtube.com/watch?v=NG4rZWeh…