←
AlexEnglish_Psych234 posts
AlexEnglish_Psych avatar

AlexEnglish_Psych

@AlexEngPsych

Cultural Psychologist, China Scholar & World Traveler

◷ Joined February 2022▧ 6 Photos and videos
Yo𝕏ano avatar
⟳ AlexEnglish_Psych retweeted
Yo𝕏ano@SeanKy_·Sep 15

文化比較の「集団主義」が、どちらかというと向社会性みたいな定義だったので、「義理」に近い responsibilism というのを定義して測りなおしてみた、という研究 ・温かい感情や楽しさは要求しない。あくまで「行動としての義務・役割・責任」に焦点を当てる ・親しい関係と疎遠な関係を明確に区別する(親には尽くすが、見知らぬ他人には義務を感じない) ・「グループに属している」だけでは不十分で、具体的で親密な関係性(親、信頼できる同僚など)が重要

🚨 It's finally out! 🚨 This is the big one. 100 cultures, 12,000 people, 108 researchers. Why people (and our most-used surveys) get collectivism wrong and how to fix it. Join me for a fun thread! 🧵 @NatureHumBehav nature.com/articles/s41562-0…

Post attachment
Thomas Talhelm avatar
⟳ AlexEnglish_Psych retweeted
Thomas Talhelm@ThomasTalhelm·Sep 16

I appreciate the kind words! You’re spot on when you say “responsible to whom?” One thing that set me on this path was seeing all the survey questions that used the word “others.” “To me, pleasure is spending time with others.” The “who” is important!

Dominik Lukes avatar
⟳ AlexEnglish_Psych retweeted
Dominik Lukes@techczech·Sep 16

Haven't read the paper but the tweet storm about it makes perfect and aligns with the explanation I have adopted. Collectivism-individualism scale for measuring cultures does not make sense because (among others) people in collectivist cultures often find it difficult to collaborate with strangers. How people are expected to be responsible to whom is what makes the difference. Hope this get traction in the field @ThomasTalhelm.

The paper is open access at Nature Human Behaviour. It's time to retire the old surveys! 📣 @NaturePortfolio nature.com/articles/s41562-0…

Post attachment
Thomas Talhelm avatar
⟳ AlexEnglish_Psych retweeted
Thomas Talhelm@ThomasTalhelm·Sep 15

You nailed the summary! More concise than my version. 👏 And when you disambiguate, you can find social class (left graph) and political (right graph) differences that earlier measures mostly miss.

Post attachment
Paul Hundred, GED avatar
⟳ AlexEnglish_Psych retweeted
Paul Hundred, GED@paul_hundred·Sep 15

When they disambiguated between collectivism as feel-good altruistic sentiment and nuts-and-bolts responsibilities, this is the map they got for the latter

Over many years and 12,000 participants later, here it is! Responsibilism scores across 100 cultures. Huge differences! Over a standard deviation (d > 1)

Post attachment
AlexEnglish_Psych avatar
AlexEnglish_Psych@AlexEngPsych·Sep 15

A new paper led @ThomasTalhelm @wei_liuqing separates two conflated ideas of collectivism: general prosociality and close-relationship responsibilities. Responsibilism Scale" focuses on behavioral duties to specific people. nature.com/articles/s41562-0…

Thomas Talhelm avatar
⟳ AlexEnglish_Psych retweeted
Thomas Talhelm@ThomasTalhelm·Sep 15

People offered explanations. Maybe it's response styles. People in some cultures just agree more with everything. And that messes up the comparison.

Post attachment
Thomas Talhelm avatar
⟳ AlexEnglish_Psych retweeted
Thomas Talhelm@ThomasTalhelm·Sep 15

These explanations have evidence behind them, but I think they miss the bigger problem. The problem was in our heads all along. What do people think collectivism is?

Thomas Talhelm avatar
⟳ AlexEnglish_Psych retweeted
Thomas Talhelm@ThomasTalhelm·Sep 15

One fun way to answer this is to do a simple Google image search and see what pops up.

Post attachment
Thomas Talhelm avatar
⟳ AlexEnglish_Psych retweeted
Thomas Talhelm@ThomasTalhelm·Sep 15

A lot of those images reflect what I call "warm fuzzy" collectivism. I mean, look at those toothy smiles!

Post attachment
Thomas Talhelm avatar
⟳ AlexEnglish_Psych retweeted
Thomas Talhelm@ThomasTalhelm·Sep 15

You can see warm fuzzy intuitions in survey items researchers were using.

Post attachmentPost attachment
Thomas Talhelm avatar
⟳ AlexEnglish_Psych retweeted
Thomas Talhelm@ThomasTalhelm·Sep 15

When researchers give these survey questions to people around the world, it's WESTERNERS who agree more with the warm fuzzies.

Post attachment