


Professor of Law @tamulawschool | Bio and musings @ nunn.law


Wow. For years, an official in Arkansas allegedly tampered with bar exam scores, pulling points from some test takers and giving them to others. This caused numerous failing exams to pass, and resulted in "at least one instance" where an otherwise passing exam fell below the requisite threshold. cc: @BarExamTutor

new paper came out on the accuracy of prediction markets tldr, they are very accurate

Thx @PhillipBantz for covering the extraordinary efforts of a few judges—and now the DOJ—to block a one-word addition aimed at making FRE 609 a shade less heinous. As always, your Coalition for Prior Conviction Impeachment Reform (reforming-pci.org) stands ready to fight.
Yearslong effort to change the most controversial rule of evidence hits suprise setback: law360.com/articles/2540321

I think @ProfArbel is spot on here. Hallucinations, for all their notoriety, are largely a short-term engineering problem. To my mind, the far more important question is how the legal profession and academy should evolve to work synergistically with machines that will soon be far more capable of complex analytical work than we are.
At a conference on AI & legal profession. I'm sorry folks, but you are over-indexed on hallucinations. You aren't calibrated on the magnitude of the problem and it's possible that one reason is psychological. It's comforting to think that the robots will never be as accurate & diligent as we are. *I am NOT saying that AI doesn't hallucinate or never makes mistakes; indeed, I believe that it does.

At a conference on AI & legal profession. I'm sorry folks, but you are over-indexed on hallucinations. You aren't calibrated on the magnitude of the problem and it's possible that one reason is psychological. It's comforting to think that the robots will never be as accurate & diligent as we are. *I am NOT saying that AI doesn't hallucinate or never makes mistakes; indeed, I believe that it does.

Continuing its historic momentum, Texas A&M Law achieved the highest overall bar exam pass rate among first-time examinees across all jurisdictions, along with the highest first-time pass rate in Texas on the July bar exam! hubs.li/Q04C12Tl0

An interesting bit of trivia—the Texas Business Court is actually located on the first floor of the Texas A&M School of Law. We even share a break room. But shockingly, no one yet has reacted to my go-to greeting: “Howey doing?”
Important new Texas Business Court decision: After reincorporation from Delaware to Texas, the state of incorporation at the time of filing (here Texas) governs derivative standing and demand even when the claims accrued while incorporated in Delaware. 1/ txcourts.gov/media/1463428/2…

Admittedly an unpopular opinion, but I think even Yosemite Village itself is hugely disappointing. Imagine how much more majestic the valley would be without a grocery store (and federal court!) between El Capitan and Half Dome. Minimally, it should be like Zion, with lodging outside the valley, and low footprint transit in.
A developer wants to build a short road in the park for his planned resort. Opponents say it would set a terrible precedent. on.wsj.com/4y9iyAT

This is pretty wild. Basically, during sentencing, an AI video was shown that depicts the deceased victim sharing hypothetical posthumous comments (see below). After the AI video played, the judge was visibly emotional, stating, "I love that AI, thank you." He then sentenced the defendant to a longer prison term than what the prosecution even asked for.
Arizona Court of Appeals reverses defendant's sentence for his manslaughter conviction, finding that AI victim impact statement was "a depiction of the victim and his thoughts created from the imaginings of the victim’s sister." coa1.azcourts.gov/Portals/1/…

There’s a pretty well known evidence case (Bankcard America v. Universal Bancard) where a 7th Circuit panel reverses Posner, who was sitting by designation. Part of that opinion has a FRE 408 issue, where not even harmless error review could save Posner from 3-0 reversal by his colleagues. At the same time, Posner has written some of the best opinions on evidence law in the last half century. So an interesting anecdote.
Judge Posner used to occasionally sit as a trial court judge. The record on appeal was surprising

A fantastic article that is sure to play a pivotal role in conversations about how to scrutinize AI evidence. Congrats @BellinJ!
My latest article, "Evidence Law's AI Problem and the Hearsay Solution" is now available on SSRN. Comments welcome via email! @HarvLRev papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.…

I'm excited to share my newest piece that shows how prosecutors are increasingly using criminal conspiracy laws to criminalize social movements and protests, particularly in the age of ICE, building on Steffen Seitz's excellent work, as well as responding to Andrew Ingram
New from Iowa Law Review Online is Conspiracy Paradigms: Response to Conspiracy, Really? by Laurent Sacharoff. Read this Response here: lnkd.in/gWkdr87u


Yesterday, I was reading my copy of Greenleaf on Evidence for a research project, when this 130-year-old political ad fell out from between some pages. Turns out, it's from Charles Beebe's 1896 mayoral campaign in Portland, Oregon. Beebe lost the election to Sylvester Pennoyer, of Pennoyer v. Neff fame.

Vanderbilt Law Review (@VandLRev) will be publishing my latest, “Legality Canons.” It argues for a new way to understand many of the so-called substantive canons that the Supreme Court now employs. 🔗 👇🏻