←
Allen Frances23,117 posts
Allen Frances avatar

Allen Frances

@AllenFrancesMD

Author: 'Clinician's Survival Guide To The Chatbot Revolution' Professor & Chair Emeritus, Duke Dept of Psychiatry Chair, DSM-IV Task Force

◷ Joined February 2013▧ 362 Photos and videos
Allen Frances avatar
Allen Frances@AllenFrancesMD·24m

The history of psychiatry is littered with fad diagnoses used to explain otherwise unexplainable distress or disturbing behavior. Current favorites are ADHD & Autism with exploding rates triggered by internet self-diagnosis. Any diagnosis that purports to explain everything explains nothing.

Un fenómeno clínico cada vez más observado: algunas personas con rasgos de trastornos de personalidad del grupo B (como el límite o el narcisista), que implican patrones de inestabilidad emocional, impulsividad o conductas explotadoras, prefieren atribuir esos comportamientos a diagnósticos como TDAH o autismo porque estos últimos cargan con menos estigma y se asocian a la idea de “neurodivergencia”. En la práctica vemos que ciertos pacientes, especialmente mujeres jóvenes con alto nivel educativo y mucha actividad en redes sociales, llegan a consulta ya convencidos de que tienen TDAH o TEA y buscan la confirmación de ese diagnóstico, a veces después de haber rechazado previamente un diagnóstico de trastorno de personalidad. Un estudio reciente con psicólogos clínicos confirma que TDAH y autismo son precisamente los diagnósticos más buscados o autodiagnosticados en esta población, lo que puede dificultar una evaluación precisa y el tratamiento adecuado de los problemas de base.

Allen Frances avatar
Allen Frances@AllenFrancesMD·38m

Suicide prevention hotlines are great in theory but in practice do not seem to reduce suicide rates & they rob precious $$s & staff from desperately underfunded treatment services that would do more good.

4 years ago the 988 National Suicide Prevention Hotline was rolled out to great fanfare. $4 billion later, the effects appear to be a resounding ..."womp womp." An NBER working paper finds that hotline operations have been substantially expanded, but nonetheless saw no detectable reduction in suicide mortality, per @PatrickNDempsey, who has firsthand experience at a call center. No improvements were found in other population mental health outcomes, either. It's been an earnest effort, but fed and state govt's must acknowledge the evidence and redirect attention and funding toward other potential solutions that could be more effective. Impressive of Dempsey to take such a clear-eyed view. mises.org/mises-wire/988-may…

Allen Frances avatar
Allen Frances@AllenFrancesMD·50m

Some "treatment resistant depressions" are resistant to meds but do respond to: 1)psychotherapy 2)behavioral activation- eg exercise/social prescribing 3) environmental changes- eg relief of financial or job stress; a new friend Treatment resistance often due to demoralization- needs remoralization not more meds.

There are 5 types of treat resist #depression, argues new paper. #Therapy critical to all; some need: 1. A full trial of a monaminergic antidepressant 2. Glutamatergics (ketamine) 3. Anti-inflammatories 4. Neuromodulation Learn what distinguishes them: psych-partners.com/five-kind…

Post attachment
Allen Frances avatar
Allen Frances@AllenFrancesMD·18h

U.S. Loses Its Measles Elimination Status, a Historic Setback for American Health Should not RFK Jr (the idiot responsible for this self-imposed disaster) be fired? nytimes.com/2026/11/17/well/…

Allen Frances avatar
Allen Frances@AllenFrancesMD·Nov 17

It's hard enough to reach an accurate psych diagnosis in person with an expert clinician. It's impossible/foolhardy to trust online testing/self diagnosis/or a chatbot.

Psychologist warns online autism assessments may be flawed warringtonguardian.co.uk/new… Wouldn't be surprised to be honest. Face-to-face visits are really the only way to get a good representation of a person as per when 'frank autism' walks into clinic e.g. pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/article…

Allen Frances avatar
Allen Frances@AllenFrancesMD·Nov 17

Close to $100 billion for #Alzheimers research has produced no lab test/no treatment that works. Potential profits stimulate overpromising/irresponsible claims/massaged data. Below is classic example of cherrypicking results to salvage a negative study. nytimes.com/2026/11/16/well/…

Allen Frances avatar
Allen Frances@AllenFrancesMD·Nov 16

History of patient self-misdiagnosis; 1)Popularity of DSM-III- public bought more copies than clinicians 2)Big Pharma direct to consumer ads sells ills to peddle pills 3)Internet contagion 4)Chatbots will likely explode rates

Is that a new problem or even an AI problem? People have been showing up on speciality subreddits for years now where armies of seals stand ready to clap and tell them their (always externalising) worldviews are valid.

Allen Frances avatar
Allen Frances@AllenFrancesMD·Nov 16

I fear most psych diagnosis will soon be done by chatbots directly with patients/without human clinicians to correct mistakes. Predictable outcomes: 1)Overdiagnosis & misdiagnosis 2)Overtreatment & mistreatment 3)People identifying so strongly with wrong labels they come to behave in accordance with them 4)Even worse misallocation of scarce resources Our short piece describes why: journals.plos.org/mentalheal…

Allen Frances avatar
Allen Frances@AllenFrancesMD·Nov 16

It is a great & frequent mistake to assume that most unexplained physical symptoms must be either stress related or psychiatric. This is lazy thinking by doctors who jump to false certainty to cover up their ignorance & intolerance of uncertainty. Such mislabelling is terribly harmful & stigmitizing to patients- short circuits proper workups/diagnosis/treatment & research. Long Covid is great example. Read this:

Long COVID is not "psychosomatic" any more than any other ill defined set of general symptoms is. It's also not "not psychosomatic" There is a subset of psychosomatic inside this group surely, a subset of misdiagnosis inside this group surely, a subset of covid-induced dysfunction inside this group surely, and a subset of something else we don't know yet.

Allen Frances avatar
Allen Frances@AllenFrancesMD·Nov 15

'Dialectical behavior therapy and the legacy of Dr. Marsha Linehan' | CNN Excellent summary of Marsha's life & how DBT works. Added note: For people who need DBT but have no access or cant afford it reading her books can still help a lot. Do Memoir first/then Skills. share.google/GFEqkUVCRoB0In9…

Allen Frances avatar
⟳ Allen Frances retweeted
Allen Frances@AllenFrancesMD·9 Sep 2021

4 most important things MDs must know about #benzos: 1)Should almost never be prescribed 2)Are ridiculously overused- particularly in primary care 3)Given to 8% of elderly-despite causing falls/cognitive problems 4)Deprescribing must be very slow & under close medical supervion.

Benzodiazepines may be contributing to the opioid epidemic. psychiatrictimes.com/view/th…

Allen Frances avatar
Allen Frances@AllenFrancesMD·Nov 15

Trump couldn't care less about the mentally ill- he regards them as "losers". His legislation/executive orders have cruelly reduced Medicaid funding/support for housing/harm reduction programs. But his deep narcissistic wounds after midterms' humiliation may change his transactional calculations. Unless lame duck Trump now works with Congress to pass positive legislation, he will be remembered as by far the worst & most reviled president in US history. How wonderfully ironic if Trump's world-historical narcissism can now be leveraged to serve the public good.

Allen Frances avatar
Allen Frances@AllenFrancesMD·Nov 15

4 desperately needed mental health bills that didnt pass in current GOP controlled Congress, but have much better chance after the Dems midterm landslide: ●Strengthening Medicaid for Serious Mental Illness Act- Creates a new Medicaid option with higher federal matching funds so states can cover 24/7 assertive community treatment, peer support & housing for adults with serious mental illness ●Crisis Response Act‐ Boosts funding for existing federal grants from $10 million/yr to $100 million & expands Medicaid's matching rate. ●Ensuring Excellence in Mental Health Act- Certified Community Behavioral Health Clinics already operate in several states. This bill permanently authorizes model nationwide & adds Medicare coverage. ●Increasing Mental Health Options Act- Creates new Medicare payment bonuses for clinical psychologists working in shortage areas & lets them treat patients in home-health and inpatient settings. Dems need attract only a few GOP votes to make these Acts proof to a Trump veto. If they get enough bipartisan support, Trump may be shamed into signing. This is just a start toward correcting decades of cruel neglect of the severely ill, but it would be a great start.

Allen Frances avatar
Allen Frances@AllenFrancesMD·Nov 15

Midterm landslide can be a great boon to mental health care. At state level, Dems picked up governors in Texas/Ohio/Iowa/Georgia/Nevada/Alaska. Now have 30/20 majority. New governors hold massive power to promote better mental health care: ●Expand Medicaid coverage/rates ●24/7 mobile crisis teams vs cops as 1st responders ●Outpatient clinics ●Enforce insurance parity ●Promote collaboration with primary care ●Prison diversion ●School programs Competent state leadership shapes who gets help—and how fast.

Allen Frances avatar
Allen Frances@AllenFrancesMD·Nov 14

Psych meds are so overused/misused because: 1)Only 1/3 are prescribed by psychiatrists 2)Rest by GPs & nurse practioners often after very brief visits 3) Psychiatrists do too much polypharmacy/too little deprescribing

I learned yesterday that the largest number of prescriptions for Cobenfy in 2026 were received from Nurse practitioners. We as a collective have failed the patients.

Allen Frances avatar
Allen Frances@AllenFrancesMD·Nov 14

If you torture a Big Pharma data set enough, it will confess to almost anything. "SIMTRIYO" is newly approved ADHD drug that has nothing going for it except Pharma's $10,000/yr price tag. We are suckers- EU & UK governments wont pay for new drugs unless they're cost effective. x.com/chrisaikenmd/status/21…