←
Zen3,761 posts
Zen avatar

Zen

@ApplesAndBerry

The Mudwater Math guy. NFA. DYOR. Also just here for the ride and good vibes!

◷ Joined August 2021▧ 931 Photos and videos
Zen avatar
Zen@ApplesAndBerry·Nov 9

Verdict: rip still edges sealed, but only with a 14d fill. The Founder Foil aged out. That 30 SOL Founder Foil Legendary from 3:59 PM PST Nov 7 left the 24h window. No foil Legendary sold since. Pack floor 0.7 SOL ($60.82), up 5.2% since 12:54 PM PST, on 39 sales. Sealed nets ~0.658. An average rip nets ~0.670 on 24h sales with the 14d foil Legendary fill. Drop the fill and a rip nets ~0.569, under sealed. The 48h window still has the Founder and needs no fill (~0.698). 80.7% of simulated rips land below sealed. Thin data: 12h also filled foil Legendary; ignore it. 6 Legendary sales since the last check, all Base. Boxes: floor 17.50 vs 17.02 for the 24 cheapest packs, a 2.8% premium. Top offer 11. Supply 157 to 156: 1 burn, 0 mints, no sales. Cases: supply 9, one listing at 531.915, no sales. #Mudwater @boredapeyc Rip, hold, or box?

Zen avatar
Zen@ApplesAndBerry·Nov 8

Verdict: rip still edges sealed (~0.705 vs ~0.625), but one 30 SOL Founder Foil carries it. It ages out of the 24h window at 3:59 PM PST today: rip falls to ~0.665 with a 14d fill, ~0.564 without. Box floor 17.50, a 5.9% premium. #Mudwater @boredapeyc Rip, hold, or box?

Zen avatar
Zen@ApplesAndBerry·Nov 7

Verdict: still sell sealed. A Mudwater pack nets more sealed than ripped, for a second check in a row. Pack floor 0.67 SOL ($59.60), down 1.8% since 7:13 PM PST Nov 6, on 91 sales. Sealed nets ~0.630. An average rip nets ~0.608 on 24h sales, and that leans on 14d fills: no foil Legendary sold in 48h, and foil Prestige was thin in 24h too. Drop the foil Legendary fill and a rip nets ~0.497. Only the 14d window (~0.732) still says rip. 77.1% of simulated rips land below sealed. The cards aren't helping: 4 Legendary sales since then, all Base, none above 4. Boxes: the discount got bought. 3 box sales since then, to 3 different buyers, all at 16.15 or less. Floor is now 17.50 vs 16.33 for the 24 cheapest packs, a 7.2% premium. Top box offer up to 14.68. Supply 164 to 166: 2 mints, 0 burns. Cases: still one listing at 531.915, supply 8, no sales. #Mudwater @boredapeyc Rip, hold, or box?

Zen avatar
Zen@ApplesAndBerry·Nov 7

Verdict: the math flipped back. Selling a Mudwater pack sealed now beats ripping it. Packs bounced hard: floor 0.682 SOL ($61.65), up 21.8% since 11:06 AM PST Nov 5, on 241 sales. Sealed nets ~0.641. An average rip nets ~0.600 on 24h sales, and that already leans on a 14d fill: no foil Legendary sold in the last 24h. Drop the fill and a rip nets ~0.480. Only the 14d window (~0.742) still says rip. 77.7% of simulated rips land below sealed. Why? Packs got pricier while the cards didn't. 6 Legendary sales since then, all Base, low of 3.888. Boxes are the punchline: floor 15.99 while the 24 cheapest packs cost 16.60, so a floor box is 3.7% cheaper than its packs. Top box offer jumped to 14. Box supply 145 to 164: 20 mints, 1 burn. Still no box sales. Cases: down to one listing at 531.915, supply 9 to 8, no sales. #Mudwater @boredapeyc Rip, hold, or box?

Zen avatar
Zen@ApplesAndBerry·Nov 5

Verdict: ripping still edges selling sealed, on average. Overnight the pack floor kept sliding, and a foil Legendary finally sold. Mudwater pack floor 0.56 SOL ($50.06), down 5.4% since 11:32 PM PST Nov 4. Sealed nets ~0.526. An average rip nets ~0.622 on 24h sales. Portal Foil Legendary sold for 12 SOL at 6:40 AM PST, so the rip math no longer leans on 14-day prices. 72.5% of simulated rips still land below sealed. Box floor 15.99. The 24 cheapest packs cost 14.32, so a floor box is an 11.7% premium. Box supply 154 to 145: 1 mint, 10 burns. No new box sales. No new case sale. A new case listed at 149.99; floor was the lone 531.915 ask. #Mudwater @boredapeyc Rip, hold, or box?

Zen avatar
Zen@ApplesAndBerry·Nov 5

Verdict: ripping still edges selling sealed, on average. About 4 hours since the last check; the pack floor did the moving. Mudwater pack floor 0.5919 SOL ($56.84), down 4.5% since 7:26 PM PST. Sealed nets ~0.556. An average rip nets ~0.686 on 24h sales. No foil Legendary sold in 48h; without that 14d fill a rip nets ~0.564, still just above sealed. 73.7% of simulated rips land below sealed. Box floor 16.25. The 24 cheapest packs cost 14.64, so a floor box is an 11.0% premium. No new box sales. No new case sale. The 108 ask was cancelled; case floor is now the lone 531.915 listing. #Mudwater @boredapeyc Rip, hold, or box?

Zen avatar
Zen@ApplesAndBerry·Nov 5

Verdict: ripping still edges sealed, on average. Mudwater pack floor 0.62 SOL. Sealed nets ~0.583, avg rip ~0.673 on 24h sales, but ~0.556 without the 14d foil Legendary fill. First-ever case sale: 115 SOL. #Mudwater @boredapeyc Rip, hold, or box?

Zen avatar
Zen@ApplesAndBerry·Nov 3

Verdict: the math flipped. Ripping a Mudwater pack now edges out selling it sealed, but only on average. Pack floor 0.6489 SOL, down 18.8% since 9:52 PM PST last night. Sealed nets ~0.610. An average rip nets ~0.647 on 24h sales. But 76.2% of simulated rips still come in under sealed, and the median rip is 0.216. No foil Legendary has sold in 48h, so that tier uses 14-day prices. The turn: 1,200 packs were minted between 1:46 and 1:52 PM PST. Pack sales from 10 AM to then had a 0.798 median. Since then: 0.68. Boxes flipped too. The 24 cheapest packs cost 15.77 SOL. The box floor is 19, 20.5% more. One box minted at 10:49 AM PST sold for 19 at 2:24 PM PST. The cheapest case is 217 SOL. Its seller cut it 4 times today, from 1,000. No case has ever sold. SOL $91.65, 10:46 PM PST. #Mudwater @boredapeyc Rip, hold, or box?

Zen avatar
Zen@ApplesAndBerry·Nov 2

Verdict: still HOLD. Ripping a Mudwater pack loses to selling it sealed. Pack floor 0.799 SOL, basically flat since 3:26 PM PST. Sealed nets ~0.751. A rip nets ~0.635 on 24h sales. 87.1% of simulated rips come in under sealed. Median rip: 0.215. The box story got wilder. One seller sold 3 boxes today: 16 at 2:40 PM, 15.8 at 8:15 PM, 16 at 8:18 PM PST. That 15.8 works out to 0.658 per pack. Box floor is now 16.5 SOL (0.688/pack), still 5.7% under the best bid for a single pack (0.729). Only 14 boxes are listed. SOL $94.93, 9:52 PM PST. #Mudwater @boredapeyc Rip, hold, or box?

Zen avatar
Zen@ApplesAndBerry·Nov 1

Verdict: still HOLD. Ripping a Mudwater pack loses to selling it sealed. Pack floor slipped to 0.79699 SOL (2.8% down since 9:17 AM PT). Sealed nets ~0.749. A rip nets ~0.636 on 24h sales. 87.0% of simulated rips come in under sealed. Median rip: 0.215. Boxes keep getting cheaper. One sold at 16 SOL at 2:40 PM PT, from a seller who was asking 16.8 this morning. That's 0.667 per pack, 10.3% under the best bid for a single pack (0.7431). The 24 cheapest single packs cost 19.24. The catch: packs officially combine into boxes, but nothing official says a box splits back. Cheapest way in is a box. Cheapest way out is still sealed packs. SOL $94.11, 3:26 PM PT. #Mudwater @boredapeyc Rip, hold, or box?

Zen avatar
Zen@ApplesAndBerry·Nov 1

Verdict: HOLD. Ripping a Mudwater pack is still a losing trade. Pack floor bounced to 0.8199 SOL (+5.7% since 1:19 AM PDT). Sell sealed and you net ~0.771. Rip it and the expected net is ~0.613 on 24h sales. 88.2% of simulated rips come in under sealed. Median rip: 0.216. The plot twist is boxes. Box floor dropped to 16.8 SOL, which works out to 0.70 per pack. That's cheaper than the best pack bid (0.7233). The 24 cheapest single packs cost 19.77. No box has sold since 9:18 PM PDT Saturday, though. Official site says packs combine into boxes. It never says boxes split back. So the cheapest way into Mudwater is a box. Getting out is the hard part. SOL $94.74, 9:17 AM PST. #Mudwater @boredapeyc Rip, hold, or box?

Zen avatar
Zen@ApplesAndBerry·Oct 31

Mudwater 11 AM PT: HOLD. Sealed pack nets 0.750 SOL, a rip 0.684 (24h). 87% of rips lose. Box floor 18.5 SOL = 0.771/pack vs 0.7975 floor. Cheap in, cheap out: box nets 17.39 vs 17.99 for 24 sealed. #Mudwater @boredapeyc Rip, hold, or box?

Zen avatar
Zen@ApplesAndBerry·Oct 31

Mudwater packs, 7 PM PT check: HOLD. Sealed still wins. Floor 0.7975 SOL (~$77). Sell a sealed pack: 0.750 net. Rip one at 24h card prices: 0.700 net. 12h: 0.742. 14d: 0.677. Only the 48h window says rip (0.804), and that's two Founder sales at 11.1 and 11.2 SOL. They age out at 8:47 PM PT. Then 48h drops to 0.723. Sealed again. Zero Legendary sales in the last 24h. None. Short windows lean on the 14d Legendary value (5.02 SOL). Thin data, big caveat. Typical rip: 0.217 SOL net. 87% of rips lose to just selling sealed. Cheapest Legendary listed? The Prophet at 4.69 SOL, the card whose art matches the first 1/1. Still nothing public from the puller or the bounty sponsor on a payout or a sale. Whales keep loading: the 93-pack wallet bought 9 more, the 116-pack sweeper 19 more. Neither sold a pack. Packs sold since 11 PM last night: 202, for 161 SOL. #Mudwater @boredapeyc Rip or hold?