Dear BAAJA opponents,
Slowing or stopping new projects is a guaranteed way to give money to the entities that own and operate existing facilities.
Cartels that were formed to protect profits for the established industry invariably rely on raising barriers to entry and limiting the rate of production to something slightly less than natural demand.
If that’s your mission, so be it. But if you want a cleaner, more prosperous world for all, you’ll transition away from your reflexive “nothing new” stance.
UCS's Ed Lyman (@NucSafetyUCS) is wrong.
He claims, without evidence, that the NRC made a mistake by approving the construction permit for DOW's Long Mott project. His issue is that X-Energy's (@xenergynuclear) Xe-100 reactors don't have a traditional containment structure.
The Nuclear Regulatory Commission (@NRCgov) – staffed with thousands of reactor safety professionals and charged with protecting the public – decided that the design was safe enough to build.
He's mad that the NRC didn't kill the project by adding a consequential, unnecessary time and cost burden to the plant's construction by requiring a thick walled, steel lined, pressure tight containment.
There are several reasons why they determined the conventional structure was unnecessary .
1. Xe-100 uses a qualified TRISO design that is proven to retain fission products even at temperatures well above those that can be achieved during any credible accident scenarios.
2. Helium, which Xe-100 uses as the heat transfer fluid (reactor coolant), is inert and cannot be activated by neutrons. It is a terrible solvent – unlike hot water and steam – that cannot carry radioactive particles out of the plant in the unlikely event of fuel damage AND a leak in the coolant system.
3. Unlike the pressurized, superheated water used as a coolant in many conventional reactors, helium is always a gas and does not change phase in the event of a leak. It is never subject to the kind of immediate phase change – aka steam explosion – that was a fundamental cause of the damage at Chernobyl. The phase change from water to vapor (steam) was the driving force that led to radioactive material distribution during the 3/11/11 accident at the Fukushima Daiichi nuclear power plant.
4. Xe-100 has passive reactor safety that is designed in as a result of physics and heat transfer. If the fuel temperature increases, physics ensures that the fission reaction slows and then stops. Once fissions stop, there is still a predictable quantity of heat being released by fission product decay. But Xe-100 reactors have a low power density and plenty of surface area. At their rated thermal power output of 200 MWth, there is enough surface area to transfer all of the decay heat out of the reactor core. Heat production is always decreasing as isotopes decay, and heat transfer speeds up as temperature increases. The combination leads to a predictable maximum temperature that cannot be exceeded.
The public is being adequately protected by the NRC's decision to approve the Long Mott construction permit without requiring a conventional containment structure.
Lyman and the UCS are just doing the job that their donors tell them to do – resist all nuclear projects – even the ones that safely contribute to the nation's energy security and improve the cleanliness of the environment.
Serious question for Dr. Lyman: What other power source could possibly replace the combustion fuels DOW is currently using to supply heat and electricity to its chemical plant in Seadrift, TX?
When you add ultra low emissions as a requirement, the option list narrows even more.
Final note: We all have a vested interest in avoiding unnecessary requirements that add a heavy cost and schedule burden on nuclear projects. That is ESPECIALLY true in the case of a project that has received ~$2 B of US government (taxpayer) support.
China's Jiangsu Xuwei Nuclear Heating and Power Plant is progressing with the pouring of nuclear grade concrete for a 600 MWe High Temperature Gas Cooled Reactor (HTR-600) that will be an integral part of the 3 unit power plant.
The plan for the installation includes 2 Hualong One Pressurized Water Reactors (PWR).
The PWRs will produce massive quantities of saturated steam and send it to a steam heat exchange system.
The HTR will produce large quantities of steam at a much higher temperature that will be used to provide superheat to the saturated steam output of the PWRs.
The resulting superheated steam output – in the neighborhood of 7,500 MWth – will supply industrial loads.
Jiangsu Xuwei continues to build on China's deliberately-paced effort to develop and incorporate high temperature gas-cooled reactors using pebble bed fuel systems. That effort began in earnest sometime in the early 1990s.
HTR-600 is the planned follow on to the 200 MWe HTR-PM that began operating in 2023. It will include six 250 MWth Chinese pebble bed reactors. HTR-PM uses two of the same reactors.
The US announcement that the Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) had approved the Construction Permit for the DOW and X-Energy project to build a 4-unit power plant using Xe-100 reactors came just 3 days after China's announcement that they had begun pouring nuclear grade concrete for HTR-600.
Xe-100 reactors are high temperature, helium gas cooled reactors with circulating pebble bed fuel cores. They even produce approximately the same output - 80 MWe versus the 100 MWe from the Chinese version.
The press release about the CP issuance for the DOW/X-Energy power plant includes the following bullet:
"Proposed four-unit Xe-100 plant at Dow’s Seadrift site would be the first advanced nuclear facility to power an industrial site in the United States".
In light of the Jiangsu Xuwei power plant, that prepositional phrase "in the United States" is an important adjectival modifier.
Sources:
"China Pours First Concrete For HTGR At ‘World’s First’ Hybrid Nuclear Power Station" by David Dalton for NucNet, Nov 9, 2026
"Dow, X-Energy Proposed SMR Project Receives Historic Construction Permit for Nuclear-Powered Industrial Site." X-Energy news release Nov 9, 2026
"Solar PPA prices need 49% average increase to offset tax credit loss"
So says an Enverus Intelligence Research (EIR) press release dated Nov 10, 2026.
The same press release notes that solar PPA prices are already "substantially above their historical lows." The press release notes that current prices are "approximately 64% above their 2019 low." (So much for the often repeated claim that solar prices continue to fall after their impressive reduction during the first 20 years of the 21st century.)
I really like solar power, but I also like sharing accurate information served up by professional analysts like those at Enverus.
Cartels seeking higher prices often set production quotas.
IOW they limit supply to a level slightly below demand.
So-called Environmental groups also take action to limit production.
Do they know how much the resulting higher prices benefit their targets?
A commonly used bit of rhetoric aimed as dissing small reactor developers is to accuse them of describing a situation where micro reactors are installed "at every WalMart."
I can't recall any deck actually projecting sales based on filling a certain number of orders from the ~4,600 U.S. WalMarts, but I suppose some publicly available briefs or talks could give the impression that chain was a target market.
Dr. Jessica Lovering's (@J_Lovering) comment on the issue stimulated this response.
The scenario of distributed micro reactors that power essential loads in the event of grid disruption is an important one. I like to think of the response to a grid disruption in such a case as "rigging for reduced electrical" and the local grid design as having "vital" and "non vital" buses.
Because those reactors will often have reasonably low fuel costs and will certainly operate without any local pollution, they can be operated continuously, perhaps at varying output. They can even be designed for very quiet operation if that is a criteria. 😉They can be operational without giant blowers or noisy, smelly exhaust systems.
When there is a loss of grid supply, their fully rated output is instantly available because it is already connected and automatically responding to load changes – often using nuclear physics, not control systems. That is quite different from conventional backup generators.
As one special case, conventional nuclear plants could benefit by having small nuclear generators on site performing an expanded list of functions currently performed by emergency diesel generators. On some measures of effectiveness, a small nuclear alternative to diesels will be a significant improvement.
1. They can run continuously and generate sales revenues.
2. Their continuous operation changes certain safety analysis assumptions related to start up and transfer delays.
3. The installation can be expanded as experience is gained and prices come down.
4. Testing programs change. Proving they can start within a specified period of time is less necessary or "safety related."
5. Nearly zero probability of needing fuel deliveries during a loss of off site power.
There are probably more.
Other advantages of putting small reactors on existing nuclear plant sites are:
1. Can use the established security perimeter
2. Onsite workforce is available and expandable to cover additional nuclear generation
3. Facilities already exist for radioactive materials handling, transportation and storage.
4. Well known site with available geological and meteorology data
There are probably more.
I've been thinking and writing about advantages and use cases of smaller, simpler nuclear plants for several decades. In my current role @nucleationvc, I continue learning from others as I review an increasing number of pitch decks from both new entrants and established participants that are expanding their vision and seeking another increment of resources.
These are places that could stay connected to the grid, but have a microreactor on-site that runs 24/7, but can power essential equipment if the grid goes down. Sometimes we say "on-grid microgrids" or the ability to island your microgrid
Nuclear energy is receiving a level of attention and support that many in our industry have worked decades to achieve. We can’t take any of it for granted.
That’s why I’m looking forward to opening the plenary of the @ans_org Winter Conference & Expo in Phoenix on Monday, November 16. The theme, Going Critical: Creating a Durable Nuclear Resurgence, gets to the right question: how technology, finance, and public policy can turn today’s momentum into deployment at scale.
I’ll share what made this past year possible and what it will take to sustain it, then join a panel moderated by ANS President @Dr_Mark_Peters with @jordanbramble of @AntaresNuclear, @bobbyjgallagher of @DeployableEnrgy, @MattLoszak of @aaloatomics, and @isaiah_p_taylor of @ValarAtomics. All four companies went from concept to criticality this summer. Co-chairs @JudiGreenwald and @rayrothrock will moderate the policy and finance panels that follow.
If you’ll be in Phoenix, join us Monday morning: ans.org/meetings/wc2026/sess…
Congratulations to @xenergynuclear and @dow! 🎉 The @NRCgov has approved the construction permit for Long Mott Generating Station in Texas, the first high-temperature gas-cooled reactor approved in nearly 60 years. A big milestone for advanced nuclear and @ENERGY's cost-sharing Advanced Reactor Demonstration Program.⚛️⚡️🇺🇸
The NRC has issued a construction permit for Long Mott Generating Station, advancing the planned deployment of four X-energy Xe-100 reactors at Dow's industrial facility in Texas.
Read more: hubs.la/Q04DQfbN0
Even some of nuclear energy's biggest fans cannot figure out why investors like @nucleationvc are so interested in micro reactors. They believe the maths, as my British Commonwealth friends say, do not pencil out.
We believe that they do when the computations begin with a different set of assumptions. One can be exceptionally good at following math rules and still get a wrong answer by starting with an incorrect or incomplete set of assumptions.
Here are a few assumptions I've seen on well-crafted pitch decks that change the final results to the question - "Do micro reactors make economic sense?" We believe incorporating some or all of them into your calculations might change your attitude from dismissal to cautious interest and perhaps even acceptance.
1. Small reactors that produce power in the range of hundreds of kilowatts to tens of megawatts do not compete in the same market as extra large reactors connected to large power grids.
2. In the markets they address, some of which are much larger than many assume, the ONLY current competition is a combustion engine – either diesel or Brayton cycle – that consumes some kind of distillate fuel oil. Just in case you have not been paying attention, the current world price of distillate fuel - at the rock bottom wholesale level - is approaching $5.00/gallon. At 14 kWh/gallon, that's roughly $350/MWh. That is JUST the fuel cost.
3. Regulators have been making huge strides – often with a strong push from legislation enacted by overwhelming majorities – towards adapting rules that recognize the low consequences of events associated with small reactors.
4. Regulators are also enacting rules that recognize that reactors don't have to be tied to a single site, that identical reactors coming from the same factory do not need a completely new license review and that modern methods of risk analysis can help provide adequate assurance of public protection.
5. Micro reactors are not just scaled down large reactors. They have a completely different set of systems, structures and components. If those reactors are designed to be cost competitive, their parts lists, both safety and non safety, are far shorter than those of conventional reactors.
6. Many customers care deeply about cleanliness, CO2 emissions, independence from constant fuel deliveries, dependability and small power generation footprints. They want on-demand power in all seasons and in the worst of weather conditions.
The ways that these assumptions change the maths is challenging to express in a brief post or even a lengthy thread. But rest assured, there are a growing number of well-informed people who have done the calculations with enough detail to become excited.
Some have invested their careers. Others, like the team @nucleationvc, have invested their money and that of their limited partners.
The teams at @RadiantNuclear, @AntaresNuclear, @DeployableE, @AaloAtomics, @LastEnergy, @nano_nuclear, @CphAtomics, @ApolloAtomics, Blykalla and others are not ignorant, ill-informed or crazy. Some of them may not survive in their current form, but they are not chasing a chimera.
PS - In many decks making the case for smaller reactors, I have also seen some poor assumptions.
1. Military customers are not cost sensitive. (I spent 9 years doing military budget work. Cost is far more important than many think.)
2. Future fuel prices can be predicted by simply inflating today's prices.
3. A newly formed team without any members that have been working on new approaches for many years can catch today's leaders.
4. Small reactors can make lots of money selling medical isotopes while they are seeking entry into the power market.
Disclosure: Nucleation Capital is an investor in Radiant, Deployable Energy, Aalo, Blykalla, Copenhagen Atomics and Apollo Atomics. All of them are developing reactors with power ratings below 60 MWe. Accredited investors can join us as we continue finding new companies performing math based on well considered assumptions. Link in reply.
I just don’t see much of a market for distributed nuclear at the prices micros are likely to achieve outside of military applications. Open to being wrong but I haven’t seen math that works.
Nucleation Capital Fund 1 is a 506(c) venture fund focused on advanced nuclear. We've spent the past five years making investments in this world-changing sector. If you're interested in joining us please visit nucleationcapital.com/invest…
University of Wyoming got $645,000 of federal funding to study the option of replacing coal plants with SMRs. The feasibility study will take two years. Article link in reply.
Wyoming is a major coal shate, and thus has a large number of coal plants that will be retired at some point. Thus, there is a lot of potential for coal-to-nuclear projects.
Local coal plant communities are expressing a preference for nuclear as the replacement for coal because nuclear creates far more local jobs, that are also higher paying and longer lasting, than other coal replacement sources. Replacement reactors will also be able to reduce costs bying making use of existing, local (coal plant) infrastructure such as connection to the grid.
This quote by one of the researcher say it all:
“Repowering retiring coal-fired power plants with small modular reactors has the potential to preserve the physical and human capital of the electric power sector while strengthening power grid stability.” The coal-to-nuclear conversion leverages existing civil infrastructure or facilities and reduces the cost and complexity of building new nuclear power plants.”
In true journalistic tradition, the Wall St Journal’s Jennifer Hiller is telling readers about the human side of the battle over new transmission lines.
Spoiler: It’s pretty ugly when personalized.
Ex: How would you like to be told that you’ll hardly notice a 168 foot tall pole in your backyard and that the line will require cutting down dozens of trees in the conservation easement that your property borders.
Or - how would you like hearing about an approved line that will put a pole within 12 feet of your swimming pool? (That one turned out ok - if you don’t mind selling your home to the power company so it can be demolished.)
Gift link in replies.
Today's uranium buyers should take a few hours to see what lessons they can learn from Westinghouse's uranium experience in the 1971-1975 period.
In the late 60s and early 70s, after several years of slowly falling uranium prices, Westinghouse assumed that past trends in uranium prices adequately predicted future trends. They didn't consider the effects that their own behavior was having on the market as they continued selling and building massive new nuclear plants.
They even included a few fuel reloads with each reactor they sold, believing that the inclusion was a low cost, low risk sales incentive. Their big mistake was failing to contract for adequate volumes of uranium to fulfill their fuel promises. They planned on being able to buy whatever they needed from the spot market at the time that they needed it.
The fuel buyers had no idea that they were engaging in uncovered short sales or the risk that is associated with such a trading strategy.
By 1975, uranium prices had skyrocketed, approximately quadrupling in just a few years. Westinghouse was facing a liability totaling several billion dollars - in nominal, non inflation-adjusted 1970s dollars. It reneged on its contracts, making firm enemies of its large utility customers. They sued Westinghouse; Westinghouse sued uranium suppliers. Circle W executives spent half a decade in the resulting litigation. It wasn't resolved until the 1980s.
A Dec 1977 article in the New York Times described the lawsuit filed by utilities against Westinghouse as "one of the biggest private lawsuits ever filed."
There are entire books on the 1970s uranium saga collecting dust in publicly accessible libraries - and in at least one private library.
Consuming uranium while knowing that you need to keep consuming uranium without also contracting for replacement uranium comes very close to the same short selling strategy and carries similar risks.
When operating companies begin desperately needing new uranium to keep they multi-billion dollar assets in revenue service, they will end up paying whatever the suppliers ask them to pay.
THE BIG URANIUM ANALYSIS IS HERE!
I’ve published an extensive article featuring Mike Alkin of Sachem Cove Capital Management, breaking down the #uranium market’s structural supply challenges. We cover dwindling inventories, fading secondary supply, soaring mining costs, utility under-contracting, delayed projects, Kazakhstan’s potential strategic uranium reserve, US national security demand, Project UPRISE, and the outlook for utility contracting, uranium prices, and equities. Featuring key insights and charts from Mike’s October 2026 NEI presentation, this article examines why the market may be underestimating the scale of the coming supply gap. A must-read for uranium investors! 👇
triangle-investor.com/articl…
Statements like this are all too common.
“The New York Times has reported that the first small reactor at Clinch River could cost as much as six times the price of building a comparably sized gas-fired plant, based on a previous TVA estimate.”
They should be accompanied by something similar to the following:
“The gas plant would require an uninterrupted supply of natural gas, the cost of which starts at 4 times the cost of an equivalent quantity of nuclear fuel. In some places and at some times, the cost of fueling a natural gas plant can be 10 times - or more - than the cost of fueling a nuclear reactor. The reactor’s fuel needs to be shuffled and partially replaced every 18 - 24 months.”
IOW - comparing the capital cost of a nuclear plant with the capital cost of a gas plant is an incomplete discussion.