
Congressman Acidre, we agree that restoring the execution bond was deliberate. What we question is whose interests tipped the scales. The shipping companies got their safeguard. The seafarer who won the case had to post the bond. Kung balanse ang timbangan, bakit ang marinong nanalo pa ang kailangang maglabas ng pera para makasingil? In Dycaico v. SSS, the Supreme Court struck down a rule that denied a widow her survivor’s pension simply because she married her husband after he retired. Congress did not learn. It had the same constitutional lesson before it when it singled out seafarers for a financial burden other workers did not bear. In our view, restoring the bond showed how much weight business interests carried in Congress. Whether lawmakers overlooked the equal protection clause or chose to defy it, no amount of ‘careful deliberation’ makes unequal treatment constitutional.” — Atty. Sonny Matula, President, Federation of Free Workers
The provisions of the Magna Carta for Filipino Seafarers that the Supreme Court (SC) struck down as unconstitutional were included by lawmakers to ensure balance and competitiveness in the industry, Tingog Rep. Jude Acidre said.


















