←
Avi Mayer אבי מאיר77,512 posts
Avi Mayer אבי מאיר avatar

Avi Mayer אבי מאיר

@AviMayer

Founder, JerusalemJournal.com / Former Editor-in-Chief, The Jerusalem Post / 🇺🇸🇮🇱 / Pretty Jewish. No big whoop. / avi@avimayer.com

◷ Joined September 2008▧ 6,923 Photos and videos
Avi Mayer אבי מאיר avatar
Avi Mayer אבי מאיר@AviMayer·Jun 25

Last Thursday, I stood in the Oxford Union and delivered the closing argument in a fiery debate about Israel. Arguing against the proposition that “Israel never truly wanted peace with Palestine,” my colleagues @emilykschrader, @HenMazzig, @EinatWilf and I entered the chamber knowing that we would be facing a largely hostile audience, but determined to make our case nevertheless. By the end of the evening, we heard from several students that we had, in fact, changed their minds — a reminder that calm, substantive argument can still move people, even in the most challenging environments. This is the text of my speech. I will share the video as soon as it’s available. ___________________ Madam President, Members of the House, Ladies and gentlemen, It falls to me to bring our case, and this debate, to a close. My colleagues have ably set out the long history of Zionist and then Israeli efforts to achieve peace with the Palestinians: the compromises proposed, the territorial concessions offered, and the repeated willingness of Israeli leaders and the Israeli public to take extraordinary risks in pursuit of that goal — risks all too often paid for in Israeli blood. Our opponents, for their part, have offered a very different story. We have heard painful accounts of dispossession — and they are indeed painful, Dr. Karmi. We have heard selective readings of history and arguments that deny any genuine Jewish claim to the land that both peoples call home. We have heard contortions of logic and inversions of truth that seek to explain away every Israeli overture, every negotiation, every concession, as something other than it appeared to be. And that brings us to the real question before this House tonight. Because we are not being asked whether Israeli governments have fallen short in their efforts to bring about peace. Some have, while others — including those described earlier — have offered dramatic and far-reaching concessions to bring peace about. We are not being asked whether Israeli and Palestinian leaders have, at times, missed opportunities that might have brought peace closer. They have. We are not even being asked whether Palestinians — and Israelis — have suffered due to the absence of peace. They have. No, the motion before this House tonight is far more extreme. It posits that Israel never wanted peace with Palestine. Never. Never? Not Rabin? Not Peres? Not Barak? Not Olmert? Not the hundreds of thousands of Israelis who filled public squares in support of peace? Not the millions who voted for leaders promising territorial compromise? Not the Israeli parents of every generation who, knowing all too well the cost of war, hoped and prayed and dreamed that their children would be the first to finally know peace? Never? Ladies and gentlemen, our opponents have spent this evening asking you to believe something striking: that when Israelis spoke of and prayed for peace, they didn’t mean it. That when Zionist and Israeli leaders offered concessions for peace, they didn’t mean it. That when millions of Israelis voted for peace, they didn’t mean it, either. This is not an argument about Israeli policy. It is an argument about Israeli motives, about the Israeli soul. And the difficulty for our opponents is that they have chosen the wrong people. Because there is no value more essential to the Jewish national soul than peace. The Jewish tradition is suffused with the quest for peace. It courses through our religious texts, animates our prayers, and inspires our vision of a more perfect world. It was the prophet Isaiah who envisioned a future in which peace reigned among nations, uttering those immortal words: “And they shall beat their swords into plowshares, and their spears into pruning hooks; nation shall not lift up sword against nation, neither shall they learn war anymore.” Every single day, for two millennia, Jews have ended their daily prayers with supplications for peace. The Talmud goes so far as to say that shalom, peace, is one of God’s names, elevating it from an earthly aspiration to the realm of the divine. It is no surprise, then, that when the earliest Zionist thinkers contemplated the Jewish state they sought to create, they envisioned it at peace. Socialists and liberals, revisionists and traditionalists, they differed profoundly in their visions of the state to be. Yet across those divisions ran a remarkably consistent belief: that the Jewish national home should one day live at peace with its neighbors. That aspiration found perhaps its clearest expression in Israel’s Declaration of Independence, issued as five Arab armies advanced upon the nascent state. Even in that moment of existential peril, Israel’s founders proclaimed: “We extend our hand to all neighboring states and their peoples in an offer of peace and good neighborliness, and appeal to them to establish bonds of cooperation and mutual help with the sovereign Jewish people settled in its own land.” And indeed, for generations of Israelis, that aspiration has been not merely a line in a founding document. It has been a sought-after reality, a national ideal, and a deeply personal hope. I am a relic of the 1980s. The first word I learned on my first day of primary school in Jerusalem was shalom, peace — an experience shared by all Israelis, including those in this room, on both sides of this debate. I remember watching, wide-eyed, as Yitzhak Rabin and Yasser Arafat shook hands on the White House lawn, certain that a new era of peace was upon us. I remember standing in a massive crowd with my father and younger sister as we were swept toward the gates of the Knesset, Israel’s parliament, to pay our respects to Rabin, felled by an assassin’s bullets in his pursuit of peace. I remember the wave of Hamas suicide bombings that claimed the lives of hundreds of Israelis, including two young girls from my neighborhood — one year my junior — killed in a Jerusalem pizzeria. And I remember how, even in the midst of that surge of murderous terror, even in the wake of a prime minister’s assassination, Israelis pivoted not to the right but to the left, electing a leader who had explicitly campaigned on a platform of territorial concessions for peace and granting Ehud Barak one of the largest margins of victory in Israeli history. But Israel never wanted peace? Never? Really? Ladies and gentlemen, that claim crumbles under the weight of documented history. One can argue that peace has proven elusive. One can argue that opportunities have been missed. One can argue that terrible mistakes have been made. One can even argue that, today, after October 7, the appetite for territorial concessions in the interest of peace is vastly diminished. But to argue that Israelis never wanted peace is not a serious reading of history. It is a denial of history. Indeed, it requires us to believe that millions of people, across multiple generations, did not truly mean what they said — to one another, to their neighbors, and even to God — about one of their most heartfelt aspirations. For if every expression of peace was merely a ruse, every offer a deception, every aspiration a lie, then we are left with a familiar accusation — that what Jews said was never what Jews meant. But beneath much of what we have heard here tonight lies an even deeper, and darker, argument. It is an argument that has animated not only some of the views expressed in this chamber, but too often the positions of Palestinian leaders throughout this conflict. It is not really about peace negotiations. It is not really about diplomatic proposals. It is not really about Camp David or Oslo or Annapolis. It is about legitimacy. Because if one denies that the Jewish people have any genuine claim to this land, if one believes that Israel should never have come into being and should cease to exist today, then no Zionist or Israeli offer, no matter how sincere or expansive, can ever be enough. Peace itself becomes impossible, because one side’s very existence is regarded as an affront, an injustice, a blight to be erased. But that is not the motion before this House. You are being asked whether Israel has ever truly wanted peace with Palestine. And if millions of Israelis marched for peace, voted for peace, and were willing to take far-reaching and deeply painful risks for peace, then the answer to that question is self-evidently yes. Ladies and gentlemen, the tragedy of this conflict is not that peace has never been sought. The tragedy is that peace has been sought, and yet proven so painfully difficult to attain. The tragedy is that two peoples with deep and abiding ties to the same land have so often found themselves unable to reconcile their competing aspirations. That is a tragedy, and it is one that we should all hope and pray comes swiftly to an end, for the sake of all who live in that cherished land. But it is not evidence that peace was never desired. And it is certainly not evidence that an entire people spent generations engaged in an elaborate collective deception about one of their most deeply-held hopes — one that goes to the very depths of their national soul. For all its mistakes, for all its failures, for all the opportunities lost along the way, Israel has wanted peace. Jewish tradition says so. History says so. The lived experience of generations of Israelis says so. And I hope this House will say so as well. I urge you to reject the motion. Thank you very much.

Post attachment
Avi Mayer אבי מאיר avatar
Avi Mayer אבי מאיר@AviMayer·4h

It was wonderful to visit Montreal for the first time in support of @NGOmonitor, led by my dear friends @GeraldNGOM and @olga_deutsch. I spoke about the arc of the Israeli experience since October 7 and what gives me hope for the future of Israel and the Jewish people, as well as how organizations like NGO Monitor help journalists and policymakers keep tabs on human rights groups focused on Israel and the Palestinians. NGO Monitor plays a key role in ensuring that those groups adhere to their own missions and to the laws of the countries that fund them, exposing abuses and holding abusers accountable. It was an honor to speak in support of its critical work. And yes, of course I made the time to enjoy a Montreal bagel (or two) 🥯

Post attachmentPost attachmentPost attachmentPost attachment
Avi Mayer אבי מאיר avatar
Avi Mayer אבי מאיר@AviMayer·Nov 17

The election of a new speaker is viewed as the opening volley in an effort by the change bloc to roll back many of the legislative initiatives undertaken by the Netanyahu government, as well as setting the stage for the initiation of an alternative government.

BREAKING: Matan Kahana—a member of Gadi Eisenkot's Yashar Party—has been elected Speaker of the Knesset, replacing Amir Ohana of Netanyahu's Likud.

Avi Mayer אבי מאיר avatar
Avi Mayer אבי מאיר@AviMayer·Nov 17

Kahana, 54, is a former fighter pilot and air force officer. He briefly served as Religious Services Minister in the Bennett-Lapid government. He is religiously observant and is married to Lisa, a therapist. They have four children.

BREAKING: Matan Kahana—a member of Gadi Eisenkot's Yashar Party—has been elected Speaker of the Knesset, replacing Amir Ohana of Netanyahu's Likud.

Avi Mayer אבי מאיר avatar
Avi Mayer אבי מאיר@AviMayer·Nov 17

BREAKING: Matan Kahana—a member of Gadi Eisenkot's Yashar Party—has been elected Speaker of the Knesset, replacing Amir Ohana of Netanyahu's Likud.

Avi Mayer אבי מאיר avatar
Avi Mayer אבי מאיר@AviMayer·Nov 16

So, how’d that work out for him?

NYT: Senator Chuck Schumer said in a statement that Abdul El-Sayed, the Democratic nominee for Senate in Michigan had his unwavering support. But Schumer did not address Representative Haley Stevens’s sudden change of heart to endorse the Republican nominee, Mike Rogers. Instead, Schumer said that “Senate Democrats are united in our support for Abdul El-Sayed” and accused Republicans of “racist, Islamophobic, and over-the-top false attacks” against El-Sayed.

Post attachment
Avi Mayer אבי מאיר avatar
Avi Mayer אבי מאיר@AviMayer·Nov 16

13 days and 6 cities later… Thank you, America and Canada! 🇺🇸🇨🇦 I’ll be back sooner than you think… @ Washington Dulles International Airport (IAD)

Avi Mayer אבי מאיר avatar
Avi Mayer אבי מאיר@AviMayer·Nov 16

I am so excited for this spineless, amoral, opportunistic grifter to run and be absolutely crushed in the primary.

Reject AIPAC. Zero aid to Israel. Zero weapons to Israel. The next president must say no more foreign wars. None.

0:55
Avi Mayer אבי מאיר avatar
Avi Mayer אבי מאיר@AviMayer·Nov 16

נדב צודק.

1/בעיניי, הטור ביום שישי הוא מהחשובים שכתבתי. לפחות מבחינת הדחיפות העצומה ומצב החירום הנוכחי, שהוא לדעת מקורותיי חמור מתרחיש בו איראן השיגה נשק גרעיני. הנה הקטע הרלבנטי. ישראל במצב חירום אסטרטגי עמוק ומחריף. הניצחון הענק של הדמוקרטים בבחירות האמצע, יחד עם תפנית בדעת הקהל כלפי ישראל, יביאו עמם מהלכי חקיקה בקונגרס. זה יכול להתחיל בסנקציות בעקבות טרור יהודי בשטחים, להמשיך בניסיון לחסל את העמימות הגרעינית הישראלית ולהגיע לשיא בהגבלות על מכירת נשק – כזה שיוגדר "התקפי". בהמשך נשק בכלל. את המהלכים האלה אפשר לעכב או לדלל, אך לא למנוע לגמרי. קחו לדוגמה את הסנאטור החדש מטקסס, המטאור ג'יימס טלריקו. כאשר הוא החל את הקמפיין שלו, הוא אימץ גישה מרכזית מאוד ביחס לשאר המפלגה הדמוקרטית באשר לישראל. בכל זאת, הוא התמודד במדינה אדומה, רפובליקנית, שמרנית. ככל שהקמפיין התקדם, טלריקו הפך להיות יותר חד בביקורת על ישראל. מה הוא גילה? שלא רק שדמוקרטים סולדים מישראל ומדיניותה, אלא שהוא יכול למשוך קולות של רפובליקנים רבים באמצעות עמדה ביקורתית יותר כלפי נתניהו וממשלתו. ההתפתחויות הללו לא יסכנו רק את היתרון האיכותי של ישראל- אלא את היכולת של חיל האוויר להיות בכשירות מבצעית. חיל האוויר וצה"ל כולו נסמכים לתפקודם השוטף על אספקה שוטפת של ציוד, כלים ותחמושת אמריקנית. לא משנה כמה חלקי חילוף מחזיקה ישראל במחסניה, אם האמריקנים יפסיקו לספק אותם לחיל האוויר, בסוף – הוא יתקשה לתפקד. לכל מי שמפטפט על "לייצר בארץ" או "לקנות מהודו" – מומלץ לדבר עם ראשי להק ציוד בעבר בחיל האוויר, או מנכ"לים לשעבר של משרד הביטחון. הסכנה לביטחון הישראלי היא אמיתית, מוחשית וקרובה בהרבה מפצצה גרעינית באיראן. וזה רחב בהרבה מאספקת ציוד ונשק. מהשלום עם מצרים ועד להסכמי אברהם, מרכיב משמעותי שהביאה ישראל ליחסיה עם העולם הערבי היה הנגישות והקרבה לוושינגטון. אם ישראל הופכת ליותר ויותר מצורעת, לידידיה יש פחות תמריץ; לאויביה יש סיבה לתקווה. לישראל יש שני נכסי ביטחון אסטרטגי מהותיים: צה"ל ומערכת הביטחון, והברית עם ארה"ב. ללא הברית עם אמריקה, צה"ל ומערכת הביטחון ייחלשו משמעותית. פיזית, מילולית. ** המצב הזה דורש שינוי דחוף בהתנהלות ישראל; מהלכי חירום נרחבים. מבוססי מדיניות. ב"מדיניות" הכוונה היא שהממשלה החדשה תצטרך ליזום שורה של צעדים אמיתיים, עם משמעות אזורית. עצירה כוחנית ומהירה של הטרור היהודי בשטחים, וריסוק התשתיות שלו. זה יצטרך להיות מהיר ואגרסיבי. הצדק הזה לא רק צריך להיעשות, אלא גם להיראות – לאור הנזק העצום שנגרם לישראל. וזו רק ההתחלה, הסיפתח. יהיה צורך במהלך מדיני נרחב כלפי הפלסטינים, וב"מדיני" הכוונה היא לתהליך שלום. ישראל תצטרך להציג גישה חדשה לגמרי לרצועת עזה, בנייתה ושיקומה. החזקת השטחים בסוריה ובלבנון תצטרך להישקל היטב מול תועלות ביטחוניות ומחירים מדיניים. מדיניות הפעלת הכוח של צה"ל הייתה תחת הגדרת "מלחמה" מאז ה-7 באוקטובר. זה לא יכול להימשך כך; המחירים המדיניים עצומים. הפוליטיקאים והמטה הכללי נכנסו לפרדיגמה מראשית המלחמה, של לקיחת "אפס סיכון" מהרמה הטקטית (דמות חשודה שמתקדמת על ציר בעזה), ועד הרמה האסטרטגית (התרעות למכביר על מתקפות פתע). התוצאה: אינפלציה בפעילות התקפית. כאילו אין לזה מחיר. מי שמחפש מחיר למה שהתרחש בעזה מאז הפסקת האש – כדאי שיביט במתרחש בוושינגטון ובעולם.

Avi Mayer אבי מאיר avatar
⟳ Avi Mayer אבי מאיר retweeted
Avi Mayer אבי מאיר@AviMayer·Nov 3

U.S. military aid to Israel has always been a red herring, a convenient talking point for bad-faith actors on both extremes of the political spectrum, including some running for public office today. It accounts for 0.054% of the federal budget – less than what the U.S. government spends in a day and a half merely paying interest on the national debt. The notion that eliminating it will have any effect on American families is laughable. With one notable exception: the families of some 20,000 employees of the U.S. defense industry, where virtually all of the aid is spent. Those jobs exist in large part because of Israeli spending on U.S. military hardware and they could very well be endangered if that spending is reduced or cut. The reality is that American military aid to Israel functions largely as a subsidy for the U.S. defense industry, and while it has been an important component of Israel’s defense budget and its elimination will require Israeli military and budget planners to reevaluate their projections, Israel will adjust and will emerge freer, more independent, and more self-sufficient. I’m not sure the same can be said of those 20,000 families.