←
Pallab Ghosh5,381 posts
Pallab Ghosh avatar

Pallab Ghosh

@BBCPallab

Science Correspondent for BBC News. Also on @pallabg.bsky.social

◷ Joined July 2011▧ 349 Photos and videos
Manchester News MEN avatar
⟳ Pallab Ghosh retweeted
Manchester News MEN@MENnewsdesk·Jul 27

Jodrell Bank future under threat as Manchester Evening News launches campaign to save iconic space telescope manchestereveningnews.co.uk/…

Pallab Ghosh avatar
Pallab Ghosh@BBCPallab·Jul 28

If I received £2.8 million this year and in 2028 I received nothing, even though my costs had not increased, what is your perspective on whether that is a cut from my perspective, @ersatzben? 😊

Yesterday I had £100 to spend on widgets that cost £10 each. Today I still have £100 to spend, but the cost is now £20 each so I can only afford half the number of widgets. Whether this a 50% “cut” depends entirely on your perspective.

Pallab Ghosh avatar
Pallab Ghosh@BBCPallab·Jul 27

Here’s the piece. bbc.co.uk/news/articles/czr0…

Of course, we could ask STFC council if blue skies research is being cut or not. They would say 'a major shift of funding from curiosity-driven research to priority areas and targeted programmes' as @BBCPallab reported on this previously.

Pallab Ghosh avatar
Pallab Ghosh@BBCPallab·Jul 27

Here’s the latest on the axing of funds by @UKRI_News for the Jodrell Bank Observatory.

6:39
Pallab Ghosh avatar
Pallab Ghosh@BBCPallab·Jul 27

Hey @stianwestlake. You may not have seen but my article says quite high up that UKRI received its highest ever science budget and there has been a generous increase. I think it’s legitimate to say some areas have been cut. To say otherwise comes across as a little Orwellian.😉

To be clear about what’s happening here: The budget of @STFC_Matters, which funds astronomy, particle physics and large research facilities *hasn’t* been cut: it’s staying the same in nominal terms - which is a good settlement given how constrained public finances are. But… the costs of doing this sort of science have risen significantly: in particular, staff costs (wage growth, NI), energy costs (big science = big leccy bill) and FX costs (our subscription fees to CERN are payable in Swiss Francs - rates have not been kind recently). All this means the same amount of money buys less science. STFC did what I’d do in the circumstances: looked at their funding and made very tough prioritisation decisions. By all means argue with the prioritisation, if you have the expertise to do so (though STFC have not done this without considerable thought). Or make the case for spending more on science altogether (though that’s a hard sell right now). But either way, important to recognise there are trade-offs.

Pallab Ghosh avatar
Pallab Ghosh@BBCPallab·Jul 27

Sad news. The UK's iconic Jodrell Bank telescope faces the axe because of cuts. It seems odd because the government has given the record increased for Science spending but @ukri_news has said it can’t continue to fund it because costs have escalated. bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c5y6…