National conservationist. Australian. Catholic. Various affiliations but views here are my own. Here to share my views with the like-minded & the fair-minded.
I get why people say Australians never voted for mass immigration - both major parties never state before each election that they will import several hundred thousand people from Asia, Africa & the Middle East over the next 3 years.
But they always do. And we keep electing them.
11 elections since the start of 1996.
7 won by the LNP, 4 by the ALP.
The trend was often gradual but it was always there. We could see it happening but so many of us internalised the idea that it’d be racist to object. And so most of us kept voting for the two major parties.
“Your ancestors were immigrants.”
When my ancestors got off the boat, they set foot in a country with the same monarch, the same flag, the same language, the same laws & the same culture as the country where they got on the boat.
My ancestors did not move to a foreign country.
Mine were British too, my lineage traces back to ancient kings, I'm an immigrant who moved from Britain to a British Commonwealth nation.
Your ancestors were immigrants.
That 30% in the map doesnt mean "30% brown people"
Reversing mass immigration is feasible logistically. Covid proves that.
The constraints are political.
First, you actually have to get power. But even then - as the Trump Administration shows - you face elite obstruction & significant voter opposition.
It requires will & skill.
Christopher Caldwell told me Britain cannot reverse its demographic change: "It will never again be the same... you need to just take the country that you actually have,"
I put it to him that the Boriswave has no democratic legitimacy. There is no reason why the 4.5 million who came in under Johnson have to stay permanently.
If it can be done, it can be undone 👇
If Spender’s staffers don’t want to mislead voters, they should make sure their boss has a better understanding of the talking points.
It’s not the average skilled migrant that contributes $557k over a lifetime. It’s the average primary holder of an employer-sponsored visa.
If.
For ALL permanent migrants, the lifetime contribution is only $41k.
Even if you just take all skilled permanent migrants (primary & secondary), it's only $198k. That's not a huge amount over a 30 year career & is boosted by the fact that we don't educate most of these people.
NSW Labor are obviously very worried about how One Nation will do in the March state election.
These attempts to discredit any criticism of mass immigration are getting more desperate & less persuasive.
If anything, I suspect they will strengthen One Nation's support.
NSW Labor Minister Rose Jackson: “The Great Replacement Theory is one of those crazy tinfoil hat conspiracy theories from the dark edges of the internet that says there is a grand plan to actively replace white people with people from other cultures in our country.”
Perhaps Rose should take this up with SA Labor Premier Peter Malinauskas who recently delivered a speech which made the case for swapping out the entire population of Australia with migrants because native born Australians were just too much of a fiscal burden.
''Here's the ripping beauty of skilled migrants: they arrive job-ready at relatively low cost. A couple of years ago, federal Treasury estimated that the average Australian-born resident — Aussies born here — has a lifetime net cost to public budgets of $85,000. Whereas average skilled migrants deliver a net $198,000 benefit to public budgets over their lifetime in this country.
Skilled visa recipients arrive in their prime working age, immediately able to get to work and pay tax, where a child born in Australia relies on public investment in education and training for decades before they reach the workforce.''
Perhaps Rose should also take this up with Greens politicians like Mehreen Faruqi who actively embrace radical “Great Replacement” style rhetoric from a left wing celebratory perspective.
For example, Mehreen Faruqi argued that the Lord’s Prayer should be scrapped from Australian Parliament because Australia’s demographics had changed as a result of mass migration.
“This country is changing, our community is changing and our parliament is changing. More than half of us were born overseas or have a parent born overseas and a quarter of us have a non-European background.
Let’s stop pretending that we are a white Christian monocultural society. We are not. We never were. We must shed the shackles of colonialism. Racism, the oath to the British monarch and the reading of the Lord's Prayer to start our day have no place in here.”
The Prime Minister’s official rhetoric on the subject of nationhood and belonging equally embraces a view of radical cultural change.
Albanese and Penny Wong have repeatedly said over the past year that only Aboriginal Australians have a deep historical connection to this land - everybody else is a migrant. It was in this context that Albanese recently likened Welcome to Country ceremonies to knocking on somebody else’s home and asking to enter - a statement that seemed to imply a radical redefinition of Australian sovereignty.
Over and over again, millions of white Australians hear top politicians in this country hint that they find white Australian culture cringe and embarrassing and dull and boring.
South Australia Labor Premier Peter Malinauskas was actually very explicit in this when he openly said that Australia would be bland and dull without recent waves of multicultural migration.
So millions of Australians feel like their political leaders don’t like them.
They repeatedly hear a message that they are temporary guests in the country, even if they have ten generations of family history here - Labor Premier Jacinta Allan called Australia a “nation of foreigners.”
They also repeatedly hear politicians downplay their economic contributions next to the contributions of recent migrants, and l repeatedly hear that their culture was bland and dull and had to be “enriched” by recent waves of mass migration and multiculturalism to be worth anything.
Against this backdrop of constant left wing attempts to radically redefine the culture of this country, Australia has also experienced rapid demographic change, with the European descended share of the population dropping from about 90% in 2000 to roughly 68% now. On the current migration trajectory, European Australians would likely become a minority within 20 to 25 years.
Isn’t that pretty radical? What makes Labor politicians push so hard to radically change Australian society?
These people have some nerve talking about “the expectation of a shared common identity”.
They support endless mass immigration, even though our population is already 32% foreign-born.
One Nation’s language on migration doesn’t just inflame the debate. It undermines the Australia we’ve built.
''Parnell McGuinness warns that a multicultural bargain with the expectation of a shared common identity is under strain, with a growing mistrust of the benefits of migration by new arrivals and Australians born here.''
theaustralian.com.au/comment…
One Nation’s policy just before the 2028 election will, I suspect, largely depend on their assessment of how much appetite there is for immigration restriction among voters.
The more the Overton Window gets pushed in the right direction, the better the policy position will be.
One Nation seems to be updating its website.
Right now, the Policy section of the website does not show its immigration policy.
That will presumably soon be updated to reflect the position announced here: a 750k cut over 3 years followed by a NOM cap at 130k.
ONE NATION TO SLASH IMMIGRATION BY 750,000
One Nation will reset Australia’s immigration system and slash the number of temporary visa holders and unlawful non-citizens in the country by more than 750,000 over three years. The major plan will restore Australian living standards, ease pressure on housing and essential services and bring population growth back to a sustainable rate.
One Nation leader Senator Pauline Hanson said Australians have had enough of mass migration and have been heard loud and clear.
“I know Australians are doing it tough. Families are competing with hundreds of people for rental accommodation. Patients are stuck in ambulances because there are not enough hospital beds. Young Australians are being locked out of home ownership while wages and infrastructure fail to keep up,” Senator Hanson said.
“The Labor-Liberal political cartel has sacrificed Australian living standards to serve vested interests demanding continued mass migration. Under Labor, the number of temporary visa holders has surged from 2 million in 2022 to roughly 3 million in 2026.
“A larger economy on paper means nothing if Australians are poorer per person and cannot afford a home, find a hospital bed or get ahead. A larger economic pie doesn’t mean anything if individual Australians’ slice of it is getting smaller.
“One Nation’s plan will return the temporary migrant population to around 2017 levels and the international student population to 2015 levels. Over the three years net overseas migration will be net-negative. Following this, One Nation’s net overseas migration ceiling of 130,000 per year would remain in place.
“We will crack down on illegal migrant employment, cutting off illicit income and encouraging departures. Illegal migrants will be given three-months to leave Australia. Those who depart will be allowed to apply for a visa in the future. Those who remain unlawfully after this period will be subject to immigration enforcement and a lifetime ban from re-entering Australia.
“Tinkering around the edges will not fix the damage. This is about giving Australians breathing space by drastically cutting the stock of temporary migrants, restoring control and making sure migration serves Australia
“Vested interests and elite economists will shriek at the prospect of these cuts. But Canada has shown you can cut migrant numbers, take pressure off rents and still grow the economy.
“Universities will still be able to enrol more than 100,000 international students per year. Universities that provide accommodation for their international students will get priority for these places. Our new high-value postgraduate study visa will also help attract the world’s brightest minds in science, engineering and medical research, giving Australia the talent we need to compete and returning universities to their proper role as research institutions rather than visa factories.
“The temporary skilled migration program will remain available and be driven by employer demand. One Nation will maintain the existing seasonal worker programs, such as PALM and the working holiday maker program. Employers will still be able to sponsor skilled migrants, but temporary skilled migration will no longer operate as a sham family migration pathway.
“One Nation’s previously announced policy to pause new migration from countries the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade rates ‘do not travel’ because of terrorism or other extreme security risks will continue to apply. The use of taxpayer-funded legal aid for visa appeals will also stop.
“We will take back control of who comes here and how many we accept, train more Australians, restore living standards and put the safety and security of Australians first.”
In the PBO model, quite rightly, per capita GDP depends on productivity growth, not population growth.
Our lazy economic policymakers import people to juice total GDP. That doesn't improve living standards.
The size of your slice - not the size of the cake - is what matters.
This will be a very frequent attack line against One Nation:
‘Independent analysis shows lower immigration will shrink the economy.’
Australian voters need to look past the talking point and understand clearly what the economic model that underpins that analysis actually shows about the impact of immigration.
Article | spectator.com.au/2026/07/how…
If we set NOM at minus 400k per year for the next 10 years & reduce our population to just below 26m, we would certainly have a lower total GDP.
Mass immigration advocates would say that is a disastrous recession.
But the PBO model shows our per capita GDP would be no lower.
Don’t let them tell you Australia needs mass immigration “because the economy”.
Higher. Migration. Does. Not. Increase. Per. Capita. G. D. P.
Don’t take my word for it. Go to the PBO website.
pbo.gov.au/publications-and-…
Plug in any NOM you like.
You'll get ≈$156k in 2036-37.
Diversity doesn’t just mean different food & different festivals & different accents.
Diversity means very different attitudes, expectations, behaviours, aspirations & values.
Diversity means there are many men living in Australia who refuse to shake a woman’s hand.