←
Ben Chartock550 posts
Ben Chartock avatar

Ben Chartock

@BenChartock

Assistant Professor of Economics at @BentleyU, Waltham MA • Formerly @Wharton, @FTC Bureau of Economics, and @PennLDI

◷ Joined February 2009▧ 40 Photos and videos
Ben Chartock avatar
Ben Chartock@BenChartock·2 Jan 2025

I love the flight from Boston to ASSAs. It’s like a fashion show for what kind of clothing to wear to Econ seminars….

Ben Chartock avatar
Ben Chartock@BenChartock·1 Oct 2024

I don't know what JD's ideas will do in practice. We've looked at this in specific example markets. But the best I have is use a foggy crystal ball. One thing I know for sure is that the role of economics is massively important. /end

Ben Chartock avatar
Ben Chartock@BenChartock·1 Oct 2024

The slope of the cost curves & demand! It's easy to see if there's more selection, which would look like moving around the MC curve, that deadweight loss trapezoid would change size. So back to @Avik and @Crampell, it's fundamentally an empirical question!!

Ben Chartock avatar
Ben Chartock@BenChartock·1 Oct 2024

All of the area in the trapezoid is welfare lost because of adverse selection. Sometimes this is a full unravelling of the market and other times it is partial. Other times it doesn't happen. What drives the magnitude of the selection problem?

Post attachment
Ben Chartock avatar
Ben Chartock@BenChartock·1 Oct 2024

Where the Average Cost (dotted) is above the demand (grey), the insurer can't break even. So the final, healthiest consumers don't enroll. That's the distance (in percent terms) between the two Q's on the lower right, Q-equilibrium & Q-max.

Ben Chartock avatar
Ben Chartock@BenChartock·1 Oct 2024

The Demand (grey) is universally above the Marginal Cost (black), meaning for everyone individually, it's profitable for the insurer to sell and desirable for the buyer to buy. But because the sickest select in first, the insurer prices at the average cost of who's in the market

Post attachment
Ben Chartock avatar
Ben Chartock@BenChartock·1 Oct 2024

Where's the market failure? It's only profitable for the insurer to sell insurance when Demand (grey) , or willingness-to-pay, is above average cost (dotted). Otherwise they'd lose money on the marginal enrollee. But here we have a insurance market failure!

Ben Chartock avatar
Ben Chartock@BenChartock·1 Oct 2024

Falling marginal cost pulls average cost down. Just like a new student with a lower grade in the class than the average will pull the average down. Thus, MC (black line) is always below AC (dotted).

Ben Chartock avatar
Ben Chartock@BenChartock·1 Oct 2024

If the first person costs 100, their average cost is 100 (=100/1). The second person to buy insurance is a bit less sick and costs 99. Avg. cost is 99.5 (=[100+99]/2) but marginal cost is 99 (MC<AC).

Post attachment
Ben Chartock avatar
Ben Chartock@BenChartock·1 Oct 2024

In insurance markets, we're concerned that sicker people are more likely to demand insurance and be expensive to cover. Not a moral failing, just rational expectations about health care usage. Thus, the sickest people will be the first to buy. Or those with high risk aversion.

Ben Chartock avatar
Ben Chartock@BenChartock·1 Oct 2024

Let's now define "Selection Markets". A selection market is a market where sellers care not just about how much they sell but also about whom they are selling to. nytimes.com/2016/09/25/upsho… @sangerkatz

Ben Chartock avatar
Ben Chartock@BenChartock·1 Oct 2024

Next I've highlighted the Demand Curve. This is relationship between how many people get insurance and the price. Obviously (perhaps), Demand slopes down. At higher prices, fewer people buy insurance.

Post attachment
Ben Chartock avatar
Ben Chartock@BenChartock·1 Oct 2024

Second, the horizontal axis represents the share of the market that ends up buying insurance. On the right is Q-max, where 100% of the market buys insurance. The share who buys can range from 0% to 100% of the potential market.

Post attachment
Ben Chartock avatar
Ben Chartock@BenChartock·1 Oct 2024

First: the Y-axis represents the price of an insurance contract. Higher on the vertical axis represents a higher price charged to make someone whole after a health event.

Post attachment
Ben Chartock avatar
Ben Chartock@BenChartock·1 Oct 2024

Stepping carefully into this conversation between @crampell and @Avik because it seems like economists' voices need to be heard right now. It might be good to examine the Einav-Finkelstein-Cullen model to understand the dynamics of adverse selection in insurance markets🧵

Avik Roy@Avik1 Oct 2024

(6/x) This is the basic actuarial insight that @JDVance was trying to express that @crampell claims will "unravel the U.S. health-care system." In fact, directly subsidizing those costs through reinsurance, as the GOP replacement contemplated, would strengthen U.S. health care.