
To those who would define me - a 🧵

Proud father of two wonderful children. Palliative Care Physician. I do not tolerate antisemites. Proud to be ✡️

To those who would define me - a 🧵

I have spent years defending Israel’s right to protect its people. I’ve done it on television, on campuses, and here on my social media, and I stand by all of it. That is the reason I’m posting this. On Monday night, a Palestinian woman named Fada Fheidat was shot dead at her home near Jericho. The facts are still disputed, and I lay out both the army’s account and her neighbors’ account in the video. Israel’s case to the world rests on being a country that enforces its laws. Every time a violent minority in the West Bank acts without consequences, that case gets harder to make. Israeli soldiers are put at greater risk, and Israel’s enemies are handed exactly what they want. I served there, and I know how much the army has to carry already. Israel’s friends should be the first to demand that the law be enforced. I will update this if the facts change.

With respect If you were referring to the National Post article, there were no threats against @avilewis Identifying him as someone who is a threat to the Jewish community and describing ways to deal with that threat is not the same as threatening his life Try to do better
True. The mainstream media mostly ignored this important story. (I wrote a column in the Toronto Star condemning the threats against Avi.) thestar.com/opinion/contribu…

With respect A war has casualties That does not make it a genocide The only organizations that have called the conflict genocide are those that have changed the definition It is unbecoming of an elected leader to parrot the propaganda of hate promoters Please do better
Israel’s genocide continues and Canada refuses to take action. How many Canadian-made parts were in the plane that bombed this hospital? Were Canadian explosives in that bomb? One of the last surgeons in Gaza was murdered. Canada is complicit.

With respect The chaos you are observing in Gaza is the fault of a terrorist government which ignores the needs of the people it is supposed to be protecting Putting all of the blame for everything that is wrong in Gaza at the foot of Israel is not only inaccurate, it is racist
Israel has a right to protect itself. It does not have a right to starve, oppress and terrorize an entire civilian population. The images coming out of Palestine, masses of people starving subjected to the elements living in tents, is sickening beyond belief. Israel's leaders must be held accountable.

Note to Promeus or any third party social media vettor: This is a respectful post (even says so) and given that it is response to a post that appears to have antisemitic intent, it cannot be considered confrontational or combative

With respect There is no Canadian law prohibiting Canadian Healthcare Professionals from practicing in a non-Canadian jurisdiction Are you suggesting that Canadian HCPs who have served in Hamas-run Gaza be investigated as well? Or are you singling out Jews?
Since Oct 7, 2023, a number of 🇨🇦-licensed health workers and educators have taken approved leaves of absence to serve in the Israeli military. Join me in emailing health regulatory bodies to demand proper mechanisms for inquiry, investigation, and account share.nwmd.social/s/C9WpWXTb

Interesting article in @nationalpost by @UofT visiting professor Yang Meng nationalpost.com/opinion/yan…

The recent dismissal of @UofT’s Dean of Dentistry for including antisemitic imagery in his lecture sends a message that racism will not be tolerated in academe But as I write in my latest @Substack, Universities still have a long way to go… hershlberman.substack.com/p/…

The irony: #RemembranceDay commemorates the sacrifices of the many soldiers who died so that people like @EnglerYves could freely spread their hate
Progressives shouldn’t buy or wear red poppies. Remembrance Day promotes martial patriotism and the militaristic, imperialistic, Royal Canadian Legion owns the copyright to the red poppy. yvesengler.com/2026/10/31/nd…

It is good to see that antisemitism has consequences I hope this example at the faculty of dentistry at the University of Toronto sets a strong precedent in the academic world In short, the dean who included antisemitic content in his lecture has been relieved of his duties

I was very sad to learn today of the passing of Doctor Bill Coke on Nov. 1 He was an amazing colleague when we worked together at @UHN, and he was an important mentor when I needed career advice May his memory be a blessing

With respect What is happening in our streets and in our classrooms RIGHT NOW is exactly how the Holocaust began in Germany The facade of advocating for Palestinians as an excuse for making Jews feel unwelcome and unsafe in their own country (Canada) is unacceptable
"The Middle East conflict is 10,000 km from @cityoftoronto It should be kept off our streets and out of the classrooms of Toronto." That mentality is how the holocaust happened. Never again.

A Lesson In Grief Please see my latest on Substack hershlberman.substack.com/p/…

I agree with you councillor I think @MayorOliviaChow could start by not repeating antisemitic tropes in her speeches If she can manage that, perhaps an apology to all the people of Toronto for failing the most marginalized group in her city
I would agree that a robust effort must take place to build bridges and heal wounds between @MayorOliviaChow and the Jewish community combined with a fresh approach to law and by law enforcement. The Middle East conflict is 10,000 km from @cityoftoronto. It should be kept off our streets and out of the classrooms of Toronto.

With respect Your explanation is as fabricated as the fake genocide you keep promoting What isn’t fabricated is the increasing violence that we are seeing aimed at Jews I don’t want guns in the hands of anyone but the police but if YOU keep this up that’s what we’ll get
This is a completely fabricated, frothed up issue. Antisemitism in Canada, such as it is, is a result of Israel's genocide of Palestinians and Zionists' attacks on our civil liberties here in Canada. The support for extremism and terrorism is completely among the Zionists. They are who support that.