←
Bill Hanage @BillHanage.bsky.social26,367 posts
Bill Hanage @BillHanage.bsky.social avatar

Bill Hanage @BillHanage.bsky.social

@BillHanage

Professor of Epidemiology at Harvard T. H. Chan School of Public Health and Gooner. Tweets are personal

◷ Joined February 2009▧ 1,178 Photos and videos
Prof Jeffrey S Morris avatar
⟳ Bill Hanage @BillHanage.bsky.social retweeted
Prof Jeffrey S Morris@jsm2334·13 Dec 2024

There is a lot of talk about claims about vaccinations increasing autism in the news lately, with a focus on MMR vaccines. I hope anyone discussing these issues is aware of the existing scientific literature investigating such potential links that have been done since the (fraudulent, retracted) work of Wakefield raised concerns about this question many years ago. For example, this excellent Danish cohort study by Anders Hviid @anders_hviid and collaborators (he does great studies, BTW) published in Annals of Internal Medicine in 2019, investigating >650k children born in Denmark between 1999 and 2010, with follow up through August 2013. They compared MMR vaccinated children with MMR unvaccinated children, using time to autism as the response and adjusting for potential confounders age, sex, birth year, other childhood vaccines, sibling history of autism, and autism risk factors. They found absolutely no evidence for increased risk of autism after MMR vaccine in the Danish children, with hazard ratio of 0.93 (95% confidence interval 0.85 to 1.02) [note, HR=1 means no difference, HR<1 means vaccinated lower risk of autism, HR>1 means vaccinated higher risk of autism]. The fact that the confidence interval contained 1 means effect was not statistically significantly less than zero, so the study cannot conclude that MMR vaccines reduce the risk of autism, but there is certainly no evidence at all or even of a suggestion they increase risk. Personally, I think it is great if scientific researchers want to do additional studies looking claims like this with rigorous, well designed studies, but they should probably look at this paper and the others in the existing literature that have been done in the past 20 years to investigate this question to identify gaps in the literature that their studies can address to best use research and financial resources to address unanswered questions. I hope people don't get the impression from any rhetoric online or in the media that this question has not been extensively studied already, because it clearly has, even if the studies did not give the results some were hoping to see. proceedings.mlr.press/v238/k…

Post attachment
David Wallace-Wells avatar
⟳ Bill Hanage @BillHanage.bsky.social retweeted
David Wallace-Wells@dwallacewells·29 Nov 2024

I wish that American schools had reopened in the fall of 2020, and been smarter about doing so (making more use of pooled or rapid testing, investing much more in indoor air quality and outdoor classrooms to limit spread). (1/x)

Error #1 got a much bigger public hearing, though. Prolonged school closures in blue states are one of the most destructive policy positions of my lifetime from a util standpoint. The CW is basically to sheepishly admit they were bad but then not talk about them or cast blame.

Bill Hanage @BillHanage.bsky.social avatar
Bill Hanage @BillHanage.bsky.social@BillHanage·10 Nov 2024

And can’t really say anything about possible transmission. Would be interesting to know about symptoms among household contacts. Although these could easily have been caused by any of the many other viruses out there…

Bill Hanage @BillHanage.bsky.social avatar
Bill Hanage @BillHanage.bsky.social@BillHanage·10 Nov 2024

That’s a qualified reason to be cheerful - these infections could easily have been nastier for other people (eg older folks). As ever, the key element is onward transmission among humans, which this study did not set out to examine

Bill Hanage @BillHanage.bsky.social avatar
Bill Hanage @BillHanage.bsky.social@BillHanage·10 Nov 2024

Important study in @CDCMMWR on evidence of prior infection with H5N1 among dairy workers in MI and CO. Results suggest many more such infections have been happening, but that they’ve been mild cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/73/wr/m…

Harvard Epidemiology avatar
⟳ Bill Hanage @BillHanage.bsky.social retweeted
Harvard Epidemiology@HarvardEpi·6 Nov 2024

This November, we're spotlighting @CCDD_HSPH! Led by @mlipsitch & @BillHanage, CCDD works to improve mathematical modeling & statistical methods for infectious disease data, while engaging policymakers & educating the public. Follow us to learn about their work & initiatives!

Post attachment