
UPDATE: Following the woefully insufficient public statement issued by The New York Times last night that refused to take accountability for this astonishing failure by their own journalists and editors, and instead sought to pin the blame on the readers, I have formally reached out to the PR Team and The New York Times to once again demand a revocation of the article along with a formal apology to be issued. Here is my email: I am reaching out to implore The New York Times to reexamine the publication of an article that ran on November 16th entitled, "War May Answer Longtime Riddle of Iranian Dams Built for No Clear Reason". The overwhelming public interpretation of this article is that it was manufacturing consent for the United States military to classify Iranian water infrastructure and dams under "dual-use infrastructure". While you, on behalf of The New York Times, have issued a response, I feel that it falls woefully short given the almost unanimous backlash to the article, including from multiple experts quoted in the piece. Kaveh Madani, Danny Citrinowicz, Nima Shokri, Nik Kowsar, and Amir Aghakouchak have all issued their own public condemnations of the implied conclusion that Iranian water infrastructure can be a legal military target by the United States. Kaveh Madani went so far as to publish a 1,352-word condemnation in Forbes rebuking the implications. The immediate statements issued by almost all experts who lent their professional credibility to this article strongly suggest that they did not have a complete picture of what the article was suggesting, and that their professional reputations were inappropriately laundered to fit a predetermined conclusion. In Sanam Mahoozi's own post to X promoting the piece, she admitted that despite spending "months" on this investigation, there was no conclusive evidence to support this implied narrative. The publishing of this piece does not exist in isolation. It has been widely reported in a plethora of major media outlets that the Trump Administration is seriously considering a military escalation against Iran that would seek to target Iranian civilian and economic infrastructure. In a speech made to The Middle East Institute on October 29th, US Senator Chris Murphy explicitly stated that the Trump Administration had actively briefed certain members of Congress of such an escalation pathway that would target said infrastructure, and that this would "lead to devastating escalation and the likely destruction of our commitment to the rule of law." Whether the manufacturing of consent was intentional or not, The New York Times bears responsibility for publishing an article whose implications have been publicly repudiated by multiple experts whose credibility it relied upon. Blaming the public and characterizing its interpretation as "dangerous" does not absolve the publication of its responsibility to ensure that its reporting is accurate, appropriately contextualized, and not susceptible to this level of misinterpretation. The New York Times cannot reasonably dismiss the overwhelming backlash as a failure of public comprehension while refusing to scrutinize its own editorial judgment. This article warrants immediate retraction and a substantive public apology from The New York Times to its readership. Sincerely, Brett Erickson Managing Principal Obsidian Risk Advisors
URGENT: I call for @nytimes and @NYTimesPR to immediately retract their article entitled, "War May Answer Longtime Riddle of Iranian Dams Built for No Clear Reason" published on November 16th by Erika Solomon and Sanam Mahoozi and issue an immediate statement as to the illegality of targeting Iranian water infrastructure. In this piece, Solomon and Mahoozi are clearly attempting to manufacture consent for the categorization of Iranian dams and water infrastructure under "dual use infrastructure". This would allow for the United States to have the pretext under international law to target these sites despite the lead reporter on the piece, Sanam Mahoozi, posting the article to X yesterday stating: "Could some water projects have served to support Iran’s military buildup? No conclusive evidence—but questions worth asking." According to the X post from Mahoozi, this investigation from The New York Times took "months", but as per her own statement, resulted in zero conclusive evidence. In addition to this, almost every expert that was quoted by Mahoozi and Solomon on the piece have subsequently issued public statements rebuking the framing and conclusion of the article. This is clearly as a result of Mahoozi and Solomon not being forthcoming with these experts as to what the narrative being pushed by the article would be. Nima Shokri, Danny Citrinowicz, Nik Kowsar, and Amir Aghakouchak, four separate experts quoted in the article have all issued public statements criticizing the framing and conclusion of the piece. When an article implicitly seeks to manufacture consent for war crimes, finds no conclusive evidence, and is immediately condemned by the very experts quoted on the piece, it should be clear that it is blatantly dishonest and immoral to publish such an article. @nytimes and @NYTimesPR should immediately remove to retract the article and condemn the implied conclusion that water infrastructure in Iran falls under dual-use infrastructure.












