←
The Liberating Scot55,165 posts
The Liberating Scot avatar

The Liberating Scot

@Broonpot

Retired UK civil servant; Scottish Independence supporter. Liberation.scot independenceforum.scot yesunited.scot Liberate.scot

◷ Joined September 2011▧ 1,507 Photos and videos
Lloyd Quinan avatar
⟳ The Liberating Scot retweeted
Lloyd Quinan@QuinanLloyd·6h

CMAL interference is the major cause of the ferry debacle.

“We do not believe that building ferries there is the right thing to do.” Delays and a lack of value for money of the vessels being built by Ferguson Marine has led to CMAL CE, Kevin Hobbs, telling us that the yard should not be awarded the contract for four new vessels.

1:07
Yanis Varoufakis avatar
⟳ The Liberating Scot retweeted
Yanis Varoufakis@yanisvaroufakis·15h

Something happened in the EU yesterday. Next to insignificant in geopolitical terms. But morally, politically it was something that must be celebrated. What was it? The half-crazed Kaja Kalas was defenestrated by the EU Council. In a week replete with awful news, it is something we can smile about. The former Estonian PM Kalas, Kalas is currently the EU’s so-called High Representative for Foreign Affairs & Security. Her appointment was utter proof that the EU had lost its marbles: they had appointed someone who, not long before she was handed the keys to the EU’s foreign and security portfolio, had – in all seriousness – advocated for Russia’s break-up. Sending Ms Kalas to the UN, or anywhere for that matter, to negotiate peace and security is akin to sending an arsonist to negotiate with the fire brigade. So, what happened now to change the EU Council’s mind? To get them to realise that Kalas is a liability even by their own lowly standards? Apparently, she arrived at Friday's European Council meeting demanding that she reresents Europe in the US-Russia-Ukraine negotiations. They looked at her with eyes filled with horror and did what the EU does: they appointed SEVEN people to represent the EU. Yes, 7 Dwarfs! Can you imagine that? Asking Trump, Putin and Zelensky that they sit around the table with 7 EU minions? And so the EU ship sails on toward its gradual oblivion. Until last Friday we had a half-crazed pretend EU foreign minister. Now we have the 7 Dwarfs. Carry on folks. euronews.com/2026/11/17/afte…

Mark Hirst avatar
⟳ The Liberating Scot retweeted
Mark Hirst@Documark·8h

These are the five changes needed: 1. Stop sending tens of billions of taxpayer £s to Ukrainian demi-fascists. 2. Nationalise the entire energy sector. 3. Jail the Executives of those companies and their shareholders and seize their assets. 4. Jail the senior mangement team of OFGEM. 5. Enact a law that enshrines the right of ever person in the land to have a roof over their head, heating and food to sustain themselves.

Mark Hirst avatar
⟳ The Liberating Scot retweeted
Mark Hirst@Documark·8h

There are approximately 29 million households in the UK that are now expected to each see an energy rise of £443 on average a year. Had the UK Regime not, instead, decided to spend over £35 billion to the demi-fascists of Ukraine that money could have reduced annual energy prices for all households by £1,329... But the population of the UK is not the priority for the wealthy political classes. Instead they choose war and the generous financial kickbacks that come from it whilst the people here shiver in the cold. OFGEM meantime, the supposed regulator of the energy companies, is instead their handmaiden. The entire sector needs nationalised, their Executives and shareholders jailed along with the head of OFGEM.

George Henderson avatar
⟳ The Liberating Scot retweeted
George Henderson@georgeh71065174·9h

The only massive roadblock to INDY is NOW the SNP,Theyre not the Party we joined to get INDY,Theyre a pathetic imitation of INDY Party,How pathetic?What INDY Leader SHUTS down Party debate on a ROUTE TO INDY & believes WM has Sovereignty over Scotland,INDY voters need to wake up

A short thread: 1/.. We are informed that the SNP's Mike Russell, when challenged over the lack of progress in Scotland's battle for recovered sovereignty and statehood, replied "You don't know what we're up against". Well, you only have to look at this quote from John Swinney to know what we're up against. /..2

Post attachment
Ailsa McLellan avatar
⟳ The Liberating Scot retweeted
Ailsa McLellan@AilsaMcL·13h

It's good news for your foreign shareholders, less good news for Scotland's coastal environment, or the communities in the global south you are taking fish from to feed a sad pink factory farmed #salmon that no one needs. #FoodColonialism #ScotlandsShame

Ewan Kennedy new account, lost my MacUalraig one avatar
⟳ The Liberating Scot retweeted
Ewan Kennedy new account, lost my MacUalraig one@KennedyEwan·15h

I've been getting a fair amount of criticism for not understanding what my friend @rblackqc has written and said on the status of Scotland in the UK. I'm sharing a couple of posts from Facebook, to show that I have in fact been paying attention. First at the 2025 SSRG Conference.

Post attachment
Mark Hirst avatar
⟳ The Liberating Scot retweeted
Mark Hirst@Documark·15h

Putin routinely takes questions from Western media and regularly holds marathon press conferences taking questions on any subject. European and UK leaders do not tollerate that level of scrutiny, ever. They choose pre-submitted questions from favoured media organisations. That is how your propaganda operates.

The Liberating Scot avatar
The Liberating Scot@Broonpot·13h

🧵A thread with a very pertinent question which may only be answered over the course of time when we see how effective, or not, the Land Commision is in managing change and improvement.

Earlier this year, Scottish Ministers announced their intention to reduce the number of Commissioners on the Scottish Land Commission following the resignation of one of them - Dr Calum MacLeod 1/5

Fraser Morton avatar
⟳ The Liberating Scot retweeted
Fraser Morton@frasermorton07·Nov 17

Who are these experts? What powers do they have? Who gave them these powers? Who are they working for? To whom are they accountable? And how can we get rid of them?

Sony Thăng avatar
⟳ The Liberating Scot retweeted
Sony Thăng@nxt888·Nov 17

I want you to sit with a single contradiction. The United States has 4% of the world's population. It has nearly half of the world's civilian-owned guns. It has more people in prison than any country on earth. In absolute numbers. Not per capita. More than China. More than Russia. More than the entire European Union combined. It spends more on its military than the next six countries combined. And its life expectancy ranks 47th in the world. This is not a glitch. This is not mismanagement. This is not a country that meant to do better and fell short. This is a country that has made its choices. And the choices have names, and the names have donors, and the donors have returns on investment. And the people paying the price keep being told they live in "the freest nation on earth." And enough of them believe it to keep the whole thing running.

Hermann Kelly IFP avatar
⟳ The Liberating Scot retweeted
Hermann Kelly IFP@hermannkelly·Nov 17

Outside the European Council building in Brussels, I express my disgust at EU sanctions - without any charges, or a trial or a court, and how the EU financially cripples an Irish citizen, Chay Bowes and prevents him travelling within the EU. This is extra judicial thuggery worthy of bad men in balaclavas not just EU Bureaucrats. Another reason to detest the EU - it's relentless attack on Free Speech. @@@@@ Put it all together, and this violates at least half a dozen of what the EU keeps saying are the fundamental values and principles it supposedly fights for: 1) Separation of powers: here we have government ministers - members of the executive branch of their countries - acting as prosecutor, judge and jury 2) Presumption of innocence (Article 48 of the EU’s own Charter of Fundamental Rights): they’re punished without guilt ever being established, and without being given a chance to plead their case before the decision 3) Right to a fair trial (Article 47): there was no trial at all, let alone a fair one 4) Freedom of expression and of the media (Article 11): they were sanctioned - explicitly so - for what they said and published. For instance, in these latest sanctions, Chay Bowes was sanctioned for, among other things, the speech crime of "participat[ing] in the spreading of anti-Western and anti-Ukraine disinformation at the UN Security Council" 8. Sanctioned in part for a speech at the UN, a forum that exists precisely so that clashing views on international matters can be heard, quite the message to send from the EU... 5) Freedom of movement (Article 45): they're under a travel ban 6) Right to work and to property (Articles 15 and 17): their assets are frozen and nobody may employ or pay them.

5:49
Lloyd Quinan avatar
⟳ The Liberating Scot retweeted
Lloyd Quinan@QuinanLloyd·23h

Please read and repost, a great contribution.

By building presence inside C-24 processes, the Human Rights Council, and related forums, it seeks the same conversion of domestic blockage into external cost that Scotland-UN achieved in the 1990s only this time with the explicit goal of unlocking full self-determination rather than a further concession designed, in George Robertson’s phrase, to “kill nationalism stone dead.” In short, the comparison is tightest when read as adaptation rather than rupture. Both campaigns demonstrate that when Westminster treats a clear Scottish democratic claim as non-negotiable, sustained internationalisation of the issue has historically forced movement. The contemporary version simply applies the proven method to a stronger legal and political roadblock, using the decolonisation criteria that the earlier human-rights framing could not reach once devolution had been granted and then contained. The fact that support for independence has remained robust for more than two decades after 1999 is, for campaigners, proof that the underlying democratic claim was never extinguished. Why a Multi-Track Strategy Is Now Required The 2022 UK Supreme Court ruling that the Scottish Parliament cannot legislate for an independence referendum because the matter is reserved has confirmed what many independence supporters long argued: Westminster retains an effective veto over the exercise of popular sovereignty. Domestic party politics and Holyrood majorities, however large, cannot by themselves unlock a democratic choice when the UK state refuses to grant it. Modern civic organisations therefore treat international law and decolonisation frameworks as an essential parallel track, not a fringe distraction. Groups such as Salvo and Liberation Scotland contend that Scotland’s historical constitutional status, grounded in the Treaty of Union and the Claim of Right, supports a claim under international law. They argue that the Treaty was never fully or validly implemented (owing to internal contradictions around the Crown and to the circumstances of its conclusion), that Scotland was in effect annexed rather than voluntarily united, and that it therefore meets the UN criteria for a Non-Self-Governing Territory: a geographically distinct territory inhabited by a distinct people that lacks a full measure of self-government. Recognition as such would, in their view, place the right of self-determination beyond Westminster’s unilateral control. This is not presented as a shortcut that bypasses the need for a Scottish majority. Campaigners are clear that independence still requires the sustained democratic will of the Scottish people. What international engagement aims to do is pressure for the removal of the legal and political roadblock that currently allows the UK government to deny a vote indefinitely, even in the face of repeated electoral mandates and consistent polling majorities for independence. Civic mobilisation, legal challenges, cultural work, and electoral politics are treated as complementary rather than competing. Major constitutional changes rarely occur without friction or without dedicated groups pushing the boundaries of accepted politics before the mainstream follows. The 1979–1999 experience is cited as precedent: international and civic pressure helped create the conditions in which domestic politics could deliver results. In short, pro-independence analysis views the relationship between popular sovereignty, domestic activism, and international law as continuous rather than episodic. The same combination of forces that compelled the restoration of a Scottish Parliament is now required to complete the process of self-determination once devolution’s containment strategy has demonstrably failed. The Supreme Court’s confirmation of the Westminster veto simply makes the multi-track approach more, not less, urgent.

The Liberating Scot avatar
The Liberating Scot@Broonpot·15h

"Once we properly understand that it’s our shared goals that bind us & not our beliefs then we are on our way home!"👇 Freedom come all ye

You do not need to think what I think. Nor do I need to share your beliefs. What makes us allies is that we intend a shared outcome. Our country as our own. We may well disagree 80% But that’s not the significant point. We likely can find where we agree 20% We can agree that whether we call ourselves liberationists freedom fighters or independence supporters is not as important as long as we intend to devise the opportunity for our people to express self determination & to declare our right to claim & govern our own country entirely free from the controls & anti democratic exertions of another country. Once we properly understand that it’s our shared goals that bind us & not our beliefs then we are on our way home! For your beliefs & mine can shift this way & that over time but our intent to live in the Scotland we know can be free of the tyranny of antidemocratic governance by another country is part of an unbreakable irresistible force that’s hundreds of years and millions of Scots in the making.

LustraSkye avatar
⟳ The Liberating Scot retweeted
LustraSkye@LustraSkye·20h

You do not need to think what I think. Nor do I need to share your beliefs. What makes us allies is that we intend a shared outcome. Our country as our own. We may well disagree 80% But that’s not the significant point. We likely can find where we agree 20% We can agree that whether we call ourselves liberationists freedom fighters or independence supporters is not as important as long as we intend to devise the opportunity for our people to express self determination & to declare our right to claim & govern our own country entirely free from the controls & anti democratic exertions of another country. Once we properly understand that it’s our shared goals that bind us & not our beliefs then we are on our way home! For your beliefs & mine can shift this way & that over time but our intent to live in the Scotland we know can be free of the tyranny of antidemocratic governance by another country is part of an unbreakable irresistible force that’s hundreds of years and millions of Scots in the making.