←
Kane Murdoch35,662 posts
Kane Murdoch avatar

Kane Murdoch

@CCguerilla

Higher Ed investigator fellow, assessment security enthusiast, cheating non-enthusiast, dog father, record spinner, urban hillbilly. Views my own.

◷ Joined January 2022▧ 4,002 Photos and videos
Veselin Pizurica avatar
⟳ Kane Murdoch retweeted
Veselin Pizurica@pizuricv·10h

We are sleepwalking into a disaster. Let me share a real story from my wife, a professor at UGent. She mentors a new generation of PhD candidates. Some are producing excellent results, even improving state-of-the-art algorithms, yet struggle to explain what the original papers actually do, let alone what their own contributions add. After days of carefully reviewing a paper, she sends back comments and asks for corrections. Thirty minutes later, she receives a response that is nothing more than AI-generated text. I suspect this is not an isolated case but a symptom spreading throughout academia: a new generation of “researchers” who can produce results without understanding them, improve algorithms without grasping them, and write papers without truly knowing what they are writing about. We risk creating a generation that knows how to produce research but not how to do research.

数学家 Michael Goldman 昨天发了篇文章,标题就很狂:《我们还需要数学期刊吗?》他自己的答案是:不需要。 最狠的一句:他现在更信任 LLM 的审稿,胜过人类审稿——包括他自己审的。 他还算了笔账:法国公共科研一年花约 7800 万欧元订学术期刊,所有学科加起来,一半进了 Elsevier 的口袋。这笔钱,够给全法国十几二十万研究者人手一份 LLM 基础订阅,还能剩 2000 万。 那期刊现在到底还剩什么用?传播有 arXiv;把关他更信 AI;筛选靠同行讨论,正式见刊要等一年多。 拆到最后,期刊只剩一个用途:招聘和晋升的时候数论文。😂 所以一个一年 7800 万欧元的系统,最后的产出却是一个 KPI。

Oliver Traldi avatar
⟳ Kane Murdoch retweeted
Oliver Traldi@olivertraldi·6h

The scientific process is meant to move slowly and establish things very confidently. Anything less ends up with a lot of failed replications. But people have forgotten how to use their brains in the meantime.

Davin Heckman avatar
⟳ Kane Murdoch retweeted
Davin Heckman@DavinHeckman·7h

If you read Ellul's Propaganda, he argues that technical societies use education to make people susceptible to technical management. So in that respect, hacking kids with phones is just a more efficient path to creating dependence on externalized memory.

Dana Goldstein avatar
⟳ Kane Murdoch retweeted
Dana Goldstein@DanaGoldstein·5h

The A.I. conscientious objector movement is growing, especially on campuses. My new story on how colleges are responding, and what this means for students/faculty who are refusing to use an ever-more pervasive and powerful technology. nytimes.com/2026/11/18/us/an…

Spotting avatar
⟳ Kane Murdoch retweeted
Spotting@Spottingthespot·13h

Whoops! Turns out that the rector of @PUT_Poznan, Teofil Jesionowski actually has another retraction!👇This #papermill #fraud is closely linked to the biochar cartel and their network of frauds! These people are destroying science and academia! doi.org/10.1016/j.envres.202…

Post attachment

Major news! the rector of the @PUT_Poznan, the #fraud Teofil Jesionowski got his first retraction! Notice also Jakub Zdarta, an amateur fraud and the professional frauds Hafiz M.N. Iqbal & Muhammad Bilal! Frauds always rise to the top. doi.org/10.1016/j.colsurfb.2…

Post attachment
NomDeNonWayne avatar
⟳ Kane Murdoch retweeted
NomDeNonWayne@NonwayneWayne·22h

As someone who has co-authored on why AI detectors don't belong in higher education, I entirely agree with this essay. As the corpus gets bigger and the results more damning, the situation becomes more obvious

because you have not heeded my warnings and learned Spanish yet, The Point has republished in English my essay on Pangram, AI writing, the third world novel, and why so many humanists have chosen ignorance instead of grappling with what AI means for literature thepointmag.com/examined-lif…

Post attachment
Tyler Austin Harper avatar
⟳ Kane Murdoch retweeted
Tyler Austin Harper@Tyler_A_Harper·Nov 17

I am an extremist about AI and higher ed. I admit it happily. But the admins and Vichy faculty telling everyone to “integrate” AI, or who insist that AI “levels the playing field” and is therefore about justice, are hiding their own extreme views behind reasonable-guy-voice.

CryptOsho avatar
⟳ Kane Murdoch retweeted
CryptOsho@crypt_osho·Nov 17

AI slop is a ddos on human attention. Reading should less effort than "writing."

Post attachment
Michael Merrifield avatar
⟳ Kane Murdoch retweeted
Michael Merrifield@AstroMikeMerri·Nov 17

You’ve got to love the sound of back-pedalling at a truly Shakespearean scale.

We have paused the planned move of the Shakespeare Institute from Mason Croft in Stratford-upon-Avon to our Edgbaston campus. Here is a statement from our Principal and Vice Chancellor, Professor Adam Tickell

Post attachmentPost attachmentPost attachmentPost attachment
Andrés Pertierra avatar
⟳ Kane Murdoch retweeted
Andrés Pertierra@ASPertierra·Nov 17

Every time you see news about this remember that 1) international students de facto subsidize domestic ones 2) Trump admin policies are the key driver 3) as confidence is lost in US academia as a place to spend $$$ and get a degree, it’s hard & very slow to recover

nature@NatureNov 16

The number of international students arriving in the United States in August for the start of the academic year has fallen by 28% since 2024 go.nature.com/48hBUth

Wylie Bradford avatar
⟳ Kane Murdoch retweeted
Wylie Bradford@WylieBradford·Nov 17

I was asked to publicise a survey on what students think about AI grading and I didn't as I'm on record publicly on multiple occasions saying that anyone who does it should resign immediately on the grounds of dereliction of duty.

Pelagia avatar
⟳ Kane Murdoch retweeted
Pelagia@Ljiljana1972·Nov 16

Much easer to make in class assignments than to engage in forensics and policing. 'But they won't learn how to write?'. Those who proceed to grad school will bcs they will want to. Those with undergrad degrees will learn how to study and talk abt materials in class.

The oddest intellectual position I have encountered over the last decade is the refusal of so many to believe that the current version of Pangram is incredibly good at avoiding false positives (i.e., flagging a human-written text of some length as AI-generated). It is not terribly hard to trick Pangram into false negatives (i.e., classifying an AI-generated text of some length as human-written) with “humanizing” tools and some careful editing. But the other way around? Nearly impossible. For two weeks, I have been running experiments in many different situations for a new paper I will circulate tomorrow (and because, as an editor, I care a lot about the answer). Not in a single case did a human-written text of reasonable length score above 10% for AI generation. And, yes, many the texts I used (including mine!) are from ESL writers. Frankly, the counterarguments I have read over the last week here on X (and the papers linked to “back them up”) are childish in the extreme. If you think that false positives at Pangram are, as of November 16, 2026, a concern, you are lying to yourself.

Post attachment
Kane Murdoch avatar
Kane Murdoch@CCguerilla·Nov 17

"Why won't everyone use detectors so i don't have to change anything at all?"

this is MY CRAFT AND MY STUDENTS I'm furious — any effective tool to stop the deluge of effortlessly produced slopformation should be embraced with open arms

Aktienmessie Konservool avatar
⟳ Kane Murdoch retweeted
Aktienmessie Konservool@aktienmessie·Nov 16

Wie eine Zertifizierung funktioniert: > Firma macht seit 30 Jahren gute Arbeit > großer Kunde verlangt plötzlich ISO 9001 > Berater kommt, Tagessatz vierstellig > schreibt auf, was eh schon alle machen > heißt jetzt "Prozess" > Auditor kommt > prüft, ob es aufgeschrieben ist > nicht, ob es funktioniert > Zertifikat hängt gerahmt im Flur > nächstes Jahr Überwachungsaudit > dann ISO 27001 > dann Nachhaltigkeitsbericht > jetzt gibt es einen Qualitätsmanagementbeauftragten > einen Informationssicherheitsbeauftragten > einen Datenschutzbeauftragten > und jemanden, der die Beauftragten koordiniert Ein ganzer Wirtschaftszweig, dessen Produkt ein PDF ist, das bestätigt, dass es ein anderes PDF gibt.

Kane Murdoch avatar
Kane Murdoch@CCguerilla·Nov 17

Better than a war, hey?

if you ever feel dumb, just remember this is happening on the India-Pakistan border every day, then you won't feel as dumb

0:53
Víctor Muñoz avatar
⟳ Kane Murdoch retweeted
Víctor Muñoz@MunozLetrado·Nov 16

Acabo de pasar un texto mío por un "detector de IA" y me dice que el 60% es IA. Un texto mío hecho desde cero. Os informo que no existe ningún detector de IA fiable. Ninguno.