←
College Football Nerds50,061 posts
College Football Nerds avatar

College Football Nerds

@CFBNerds

We share unique insights about college football. Be the smartest fan at the tailgate.

◷ Joined May 2009▧ 3,107 Photos and videos
College Football Nerds avatar
College Football Nerds@CFBNerds·6h

I have no problem with Texas over Bama if it had gone that way. But if you’re *outraged* with Bama over Texas, you’re just being dumb. It clearly could go either way.

College Football Nerds avatar
College Football Nerds@CFBNerds·6h

When you look at the overall resumes in view of opponent quality ratings (which is a much better approach than opponent CFP rankings) the resumes are too similar for any clear argument:

Post attachment
College Football Nerds avatar
College Football Nerds@CFBNerds·6h

Alabama is 1-2 vs top-16 ranked teams Texas is 2-0 vs top-16 ranked teams If that’s all there was to it, there’s no doubt Texas would be ranked higher. It’s not. No team outside the top-10 has played within 10 points of Bama. Texas *lost* two. However you want to view it, this becomes a subjective call. And when you roll in the CFPC viewing Mississippi State as a good win and Bama being the higher rated team in almost any metric, Bama over Texas does make sense.

College Football Nerds avatar
College Football Nerds@CFBNerds·Nov 17

New CFP rankings drop tonight. Before the committee shows its hand, how would you rerank the top 25? Below: every CFP team's record vs. opponents by FEI tierour model's top 25, and the CFBNerds top 25. A few things to chew on: - Alabama and Texas lead the field with 6 wins over FEI top-40 teams. Texas is 4-0 vs. the top 15 - Utah is 10-0 and still hasn't played an FEI top-15 team - Arizona and Boise State have zero top-40 wins - LSU is 0-3 vs. the FEI top 15, but still #5 in both FEI and our model - Wake Forest is #2 in our model and #13 in the CFP, with one top-40 game all year Who's too high? Who's too low?

Post attachmentPost attachment
College Football Nerds avatar
College Football Nerds@CFBNerds·Nov 16

For those that didn't follow the stat, it's best said that he's lost 5+ games in every even year of his head coaching career except 2024 (where he lost 3 games and missed the playoffs with a top-3 roster due to dumb losses). It's an absolutely crazy pattern of hot-cold-hot-cold. When Kiffin went 11-2 and then 20-3 in 2023-2024, that was the first time he had avoided a 5 loss season in back-to-back years.* In 2025 he went 11-1. The question is if he will avoid a 5-loss season again. *Yes, he went 8-5 in 2022. I should have been more clear but I consider that worse than 8-4 for these purposes.

College Football Nerds avatar
College Football Nerds@CFBNerds·Nov 16

Resurfacing this again…. If Lane Kiffin goes 8-4, it will only be the 2nd time he’s gone 8-4 or better in back-to-back seasons in 16 years as a HC. The issue with Kiffin isn’t Texas or Bama - both elite losses - it’s that he’s randomly lost to a UK or UF his whole career.

Kiffin has never “locked in” his whole career for any length of time. In his first 12 years as a head coach, with many good rosters, Kiffin never won 9 games in back to back seasons. Every other year he lost 5+ games. 2024 was the year that broke the streak, but he had an absolutely loaded roster and went 9-3 vs a very easy schedule losing to unranked Kentucky and Florida and missed the playoffs with a preseason favorite. The transfer portal has helped Kiffin immensely because he doesn’t have to really plan out and build a program. But it also creates huge roster turnover and can lead to locker room issues which he was able to largely dodge due to where he was and who he played. Managing that at LSU is a different beast entirely. Everyone forgets that Kiffin at FAU went 5-7 sandwiched between his two 10-win seasons that got him the Ole Miss job. That was fine at FAU, but do you think LSU fans will tolerate that level of inconsistency?

College Football Nerds avatar
College Football Nerds@CFBNerds·Nov 15

For example, my opinion is the 4th down and 2 pt conversion “win probability” metrics are highly biased. Teams that went for it historically knew they’d succeed. And many metrics are based on NFL data, not college. Tons of bias. In reality I think it often loses you close games

College Football Nerds avatar
College Football Nerds@CFBNerds·Nov 15

Unpacking that further - what I mean is that Kiffin’s schemes and decisions tend to create teams that dominate games in stats and advanced metrics, but lose anyway, at a very frequent clip. One thing EPA does pick up on - his radar totals don’t come at the right times or places.

College Football Nerds avatar
College Football Nerds@CFBNerds·Nov 13

This is in the same bucket as those "hacker uses a lightbulb to steal computer data" headlines, where in reality they had to first hack the computer, then install software to rewrite the computer to send information to a smart lightbulb via bluetooth, install a special bluetooth lightbulb to use it, then set up a specially programmed camera pointed at the lightbulb. Generally speaking, these things are more proof-of-concept and are geared more to bespoke clandestine operations than tracking everyone on the planet. They already have your data because you go on the Internet.

College Football Nerds avatar
College Football Nerds@CFBNerds·Nov 13

PSA, as someone who knows a lot about this tech: Yes, this is a technology that exists. No, it's not a technology being used to track you, nor is it practical to do so. To work, you must have installed a paired app on the phone and given it always-on microphone permissions, running constantly to monitor for audio traffic. Both iOS and Google have controls to prevent this, rendering the technique impractical, so it is been almost universally abandoned as a dead end. Because of the permissions issue, no, the government isn't using audio to ping your phone. Your phone isn't listening, and has no program set to respond to it. Yes, it is possible to sneak software on your phone for tracking like this. But... If such software is on your phone, they can track the phone directly. The reason this tech is a dead end is that TVs and phones are all Internet-connected now. They can just have the app itself do the tracking, and ad sites themselves can already track you easily by logging your whole-home IP address. The above is why you talk about something and suddenly it's in your ads. If anyone in your house googles based on the conversation, it pings to your home IP, which is attached to your device, so your device starts getting ads even if you yourself never searched for it. It's not because your phone is listening to you, it's because Internet ad tracking is very good. Finally, TVs sometimes do use inaudible audio, but it is mainly limited to a known technique where any instance of "Hey Google" or "Hey Siri" playing on TV is accompanied by an extra ultrasonic signal so it doesn't trigger your AI assistants all over your house.

Grok@grokNov 13

Yes, it's true. TVs (via ads or content) can emit near-ultrasonic beacons (around 18-20 kHz, inaudible to most humans) that phone microphones detect. Apps then log the signal for cross-device ad tracking, linking what you watched to your phone profile. Used by firms like SilverPush; researched and flagged by the FTC. Google has used similar tech for Chromecast pairing. Privacy settings and mic permissions limit it.

College Football Nerds avatar
College Football Nerds@CFBNerds·Nov 12

Over an hour ago I emailed my employee for a copy of my TPS reports, and he still hasn't emailed me back. So frustrating. What do you think I should do?

College Football Nerds avatar
College Football Nerds@CFBNerds·Nov 11

This is Vegas doubling down hard on the computer metrics / power ratings of various SEC teams. They love Georgia and LSU. They don't love Ole Miss or Tennessee. The other teams are generally more similar in quality than you'd expect.

Who SHOULD be on UPSET alert?

Post attachment
College Football Nerds avatar
College Football Nerds@CFBNerds·Nov 11

I do think if Texas and Tennessee win out, they have a good argument to jump Alabama. But the telling point there is that the teams they play to let them jump Alabama (LSU and TAMU) are teams Alabama has already had to play and beaten.

College Football Nerds avatar
College Football Nerds@CFBNerds·Nov 11

I feel like I've spent the last week defending Alabama, but... 1) There is a very clear power rating order between Alabama (FPI 3, FEI 4) -> Texas (7, 6) -> Tennessee (9, 11). 2) There is a very clear SOS order between Alabama (FPI 1, FEI 1) -> Texas (11, 2) -> Tennessee (23, 27). 3) There is a very clear SOR order between Alabama (FPI 5, FEI 1) -> Texas (9, 2) -> Tennessee (12, 15). There is little doubt that Alabama should be ranked ahead of Texas. They aren't in the same ranking/rating "pool" as Tennessee, and Tennessee can't jump Texas. If you look at literally anything other than "but Tennessee beat Alabama," when comparing teams with multiple losses and tons of ranked wins, Alabama clearly should be ranked ahead of Texas and Tennessee.