
College rankings are broken. We're doing it the right way. Introducing: City Journal's 2026 College Rankings! collegerankings.city-journal…

Incisive commentary on urban policy, politics, and culture. Published by @ManhattanInst and edited by @BrianACity.

College rankings are broken. We're doing it the right way. Introducing: City Journal's 2026 College Rankings! collegerankings.city-journal…

Earlier this month, Russell Brand was sentenced to ten years in prison for rape and sexual assault. Nearly 20 years ago, a woman had a sexual encounter with him at his home, which she consented to early on. She later withdrew her consent. The deeper story here, @christopherrufo writes, is the shift that took place after the sexual revolution in the 1960s. "Left-wing ideologues promised to unleash a Summer of Love and argued that loosening social inhibitions around sex would lead to the liberation of women. It didn’t work out that way." city-journal.org/article/rus…

“Governments can intervene in markets, sometimes on an enormous scale, but they cannot indefinitely suppress the signal that they send. Yet the fact that the U.S. government would even try is disquieting,” @nicolegelinas writes. city-journal.org/article/uni…

Mamdani announced that he is officially disbanding the NYPD's Strategic Response Group. Here's the thing: The SRG isn't really going anywhere. What Mamdani’s announcement does is send a clear message—one sure to embolden the protest coalition and demoralize law enforcement. @Rafa_Mangual on what's really going on with the SRG: city-journal.org/article/nyp…

Does a college encourage respectful discussion and vigorous debate? Is the curriculum actually strong, or is the university coasting on a reputation that it earned a century ago? Do administrators prioritize activism over education—and even tolerate chaos and violence? Does the school prepare them to earn enough to pay back their tuition and thrive as citizens? Welcome to the City Journal College Rankings: A groundbreaking tool that provides the full picture that students, parents, and counselors have long needed. collegerankings.city-journal…

NEW: A progressive communications firm is rebranding DEI at colleges and nonprofits. A playbook from Spitfire Strategies titled "Shift Terms, Not Values," makes the case for an entirely new vocabulary due to "extremists" who have "weaponized the phrase 'diversity, equity and inclusion' and its acronym 'DEI.'" In multiple emails obtained by @JohnDSailer, the firm's executives said that the strategy needed to be kept a secret. city-journal.org/article/lef…
NEW: I’ve obtained documents showing one way college administrators and nonprofits are being trained to fight for DEI. The strategy: keep the policies but ditch the terms. As consultants from Spitfire Strategies put it: —"We need to pivot" from the term "DEI" because the "extremists" have "weaponized" the acronym. —Instead of "diversity" use "different perspectives." —Instead of "equity" use "equal opportunity for all." —Instead of "inclusion" use... this entire sentence: "Students should be safe and seen enough to ask questions, explore ideas and learn from one another." That's from the trainings and messaging toolkit created by Spitfire—a PR firm that "works exclusively on racial, economic, and climate justice." The documents, which I obtained through public records requests, show how Spitfire blames the backlash against DEI policies on "extremists" who "manipulate" language. Perhaps for this reason, they're adamant about keeping their strategy a secret. "We don’t want to give the opposition our messaging playbook," the firm's president says while sharing the playbook in an email I obtained. The group has some big-name clients. Training sessions I viewed were addended by personnel from the American Historical Association, Johns Hopkins, the National Association of Diversity Officers in Higher Education, and more. Spitfire has worked closely with the Mellon Foundation-funded Alliance for Higher Education (AHE) and American Association of Colleges and University (AAC&U). The strategy seems to have been put into practice. As I previously reported, the president of the Alliance for Higher Education (AHE) wrote in a proposal of the need for a “an unapologetic, visionary commitment to diversity, equity, and inclusion.” Now, the group's website changes that language ever-so-slightly—calling for "an unapologetic, visionary commitment to ensuring people from all walks of life are represented, belong, and thrive in our institutions." It's kind of wild to see. A few years ago, applicants for faculty jobs could be penalized for not knowing the difference between "equity" and "equality." Now, its the one's calling for "equity" policies who are blurring the language. But notably, they insist that they haven't changed their minds on anything.

NEW: I’ve obtained documents showing one way college administrators and nonprofits are being trained to fight for DEI. The strategy: keep the policies but ditch the terms. As consultants from Spitfire Strategies put it: —"We need to pivot" from the term "DEI" because the "extremists" have "weaponized" the acronym. —Instead of "diversity" use "different perspectives." —Instead of "equity" use "equal opportunity for all." —Instead of "inclusion" use... this entire sentence: "Students should be safe and seen enough to ask questions, explore ideas and learn from one another." That's from the trainings and messaging toolkit created by Spitfire—a PR firm that "works exclusively on racial, economic, and climate justice." The documents, which I obtained through public records requests, show how Spitfire blames the backlash against DEI policies on "extremists" who "manipulate" language. Perhaps for this reason, they're adamant about keeping their strategy a secret. "We don’t want to give the opposition our messaging playbook," the firm's president says while sharing the playbook in an email I obtained. The group has some big-name clients. Training sessions I viewed were addended by personnel from the American Historical Association, Johns Hopkins, the National Association of Diversity Officers in Higher Education, and more. Spitfire has worked closely with the Mellon Foundation-funded Alliance for Higher Education (AHE) and American Association of Colleges and University (AAC&U). The strategy seems to have been put into practice. As I previously reported, the president of the Alliance for Higher Education (AHE) wrote in a proposal of the need for a “an unapologetic, visionary commitment to diversity, equity, and inclusion.” Now, the group's website changes that language ever-so-slightly—calling for "an unapologetic, visionary commitment to ensuring people from all walks of life are represented, belong, and thrive in our institutions." It's kind of wild to see. A few years ago, applicants for faculty jobs could be penalized for not knowing the difference between "equity" and "equality." Now, its the one's calling for "equity" policies who are blurring the language. But notably, they insist that they haven't changed their minds on anything.

Congratulations to @reihan and @ManhattanInst on their 2026 College Rankings, a valuable reminder of the importance of reform in higher education. collegerankings.city-journal…

A former long-time employee of Renteria Vineyard Management, one of the largest vineyard management companies in Napa Valley, told City Journal reporters that RVM was aware that he was an illegal alien—and said "about 80% of all of us who worked there" were in the country illegally. When asked explicitly if RVM was aware that many employees were illegals, the source said, "Absolutely, of course. There was a lot of them." @kennethschrupp on the @JenningsShow: city-journal.org/article/gav…
BREAKING: A new @CityJournal investigation alleges that a vineyard management contractor employed undocumented workers at Napa Valley wineries tied to California Governor Gavin Newsom's financial interests. Did he know? @kennethschrupp joins Scott to break it all down.

🎯
The phrase “artistic excellence” was deleted from an early draft of the Boston Symphony Orchestra’s strategic plan. In September 2025, conductor Andris Nelsons asked that it be restored, because excellence is the “indispensable engine for everything the BSO does.” Five months later, the board voted to terminate his contract. @HMDatMI on the BSO's power struggle over diversity, ideology, and organizational control ⬇️ city-journal.org/article/cla…

Among the schools in @CityJournal's College Rankings, there is not a single one that requires an economics course before you graduate. "This is partly a consequence of who universities are hiring. They've tried to hire people increasingly in the identity studies departments. One of the challenges for these departments is they actually have very very low enrollment...You usually have 5 or 6 faculty members for 5 majors. So essentially, the faculty need something to do. And what a lot of universities have decided is 'Well, we'll give this group of faculty members something to do by requiring everybody in the university take their courses.'" Kevin Wallsten discusses City Journal's College Rankings & academic rigor on the @JenningsShow: collegerankings.city-journal…

Congrats to @UF!
City Journal's new college rankings put the University of Florida at No. 2, behind only UT Austin and ahead of the Ivies. They score schools on free speech, curriculum, and outcomes. Not on prestige. Florida can compete with anyone when it focuses on education, not branding. What would you want your state's flagship to be known for?


I'm proud to share this deeply personal piece in @CityJournal Before October 7th, I knew embarrassingly little about Israel. So I scheduled a trip. The horrific events caused the trip to be canceled. Today, I'm one of Israel's most committed defenders. Not because it's politically convenient. And certainly not because it's popular. I studied its history, came to admire its people, and watched in disbelief as Americans rationalized the horrors of October 7. But something else shaped my convictions: the character of the people on either side of this debate. As a Catholic, a father of four, and a man trying to raise children with moral courage, I refuse to let election results, internet influencers, or the pursuit of popularity dictate my principles. My children will someday look back at the people I admired and the causes I defended. I want them to know their father stood for something, even when it cost him something. I'd rather stand with people of character than stand on the winning side. How I Chose Sides on Israel city-journal.org/article/isr…

*taps sign*
“I pay money to go to this college.” Students are paying tens of thousands in tuition at the University of Michigan for this. Dr. Laura Yakas teaches “Engaging Social Justice, Diversity, and Oppression in Social Work.” In class she sings songs about how horrible America is. This is what people mean when they say universities have become ideological indoctrination camps. Parents and taxpayers are funding it. Graduates are leaving with debt and this. This woman needs to be fired!

Colleges and universities used to be a place of higher learning. Now they seem to simply be a place of perpetual protest. What happened? @CityJournal college rankings might give us a hint about what changed and why.