
The data are really strong. Let’s take a look… Baseball has the highest natural variance of any major sport. In baseball, when the best team plays the worst team, the worst team wins about 32% of the time. So upsets in baseball aren’t surprising. Lesser teams beat better teams all the time in baseball. This is opposed to football and basketball where the best team beats the worst team about 96-97% of the time. So baseball *looks* balanced because it has the highest natural competitive balance of any sport. Let’s look at the number of champions from 2006 through 2025 - the last 20 seasons for each sport. Baseball has 12 different winners. Football and hockey have 13 each. Basketball has 11. So it looks like a cap doesn’t matter if you look only at the winning team. All the sports seem to have about the same number of winners regardless of if they have a cap or not. But looking ONLY at the number of different winners doesn’t tell the story of competitive balance across the whole league. You have to look at results vs payroll spending and results vs market size across the entire league in order to have a more complete picture of that. If you look at that data, the top 5 markets in MLB have won the most games over the last 20 years. The largest-market teams outperformed the smallest-market teams by 4.3 percentage points in winning percentage. Compare that to the three capped leagues where in all three the smallest-market teams actually outperformed the largest-market teams over the same period. That doesn't prove salary caps caused the difference. But it shows that the relationship between market size and winning is fundamentally different in baseball. The payroll data is even more clear. There is a completely consistent relationship between a team’s payroll spend and the number of wins. Teams with bigger payrolls, win more games over the long run. Teams that spend less, win less. Sounds intuitive because it is, but the data prove it’s true. You can buy wins in baseball. And the biggest teams do. And in a sport with the most natural variance, a couple wins is often the difference between playoffs and no playoffs - and that comes with a lot of revenue. The salary cap argument isn't that every team should win the same number of games. It's that every franchise should have a realistic opportunity to build a winner, regardless of its market size. Baseball already has more natural competitive balance than any other major American sport. Imagine what it could look like if its economic system encouraged that balance instead of working against it.
show us? because baseball has the most unique champions out of any league since 2000. with no salary cap. So show us?






























