A major scene that did not make it to DV's Dune was the guild navigator's audience with the emperor. What a loss!
[Addendum]
This scene attached visual images and thereby lent extra emphasis and meaning to many words spoken by Duke Leto, Paul Atreides, the missing Princess Irulan, and others. The Spacing Guild and the navigators were first spoken of before the assassination of the Duke. It did belong in the first part of any movie attempt at this award winning novel and was a major scene of the movie since as someone else says, it gives a synopsis of the story. Many classic stories give a similar foreshadowing early in the writing and sometimes they can only be seen for what they are in retrospect.
Harry Potter: Recasts are unfortunate but it's something the movies had to deal with as well
It was such a shame to hear the news that Gracie Cochrane will not be returning to play Ginny for Season 2 but there must be a good reason for this and I respect her and her family's choice. She looked like great casting but I'm sure that whoever replaces her will do a great job. Of course Ginny is a major character in the story overall which is unfortunate but the silver lining with this situation is that her role is very minimal in the first book so at least they have a sort of clean slate for Season 2 when her role will be much more significant. I'd rather they recast now than between two of the later seasons.
To be totally honest, it was always in the realms of possibility that some characters would have to be recast in the show and it made me realize that this happened in the movies more than people might think. The first two are the most significant ones but I decided to include some student characters who have been cast in the show and may have larger roles than they did in the movies and also perhaps than the books.
Albus Dumbledore:
- Played by Richard Harris in PS and CoS
- Replaced by Michael Gambon for PoA, GoF, OotP, HBP and DH2
Lord Voldemort:
- Played by Richard Bremmer in PS
- Replaced by Ralph Fiennes for GoF, OotP and DH1 & 2
Tom Riddle:
- Played by Christian Coulson in CoS
- Replaced by Frank Dillane for HBP
Lavender Brown:
- Played by two different uncredited actresses in the early films
- Replaced by Jessie Cave for HBP and DH1 & 2
Parvati Patil:
- Played by Sitara Shah in PoA
- Replaced by Shefali Chowdhury for GoF, OotP and HBP
Pansy Parkinson:
- Played by Genevieve Gaunt in PoA
- Replaced by Scarlett Byrne for HBP, DH1 & 2
Angelina Johnson:
- Played by Danielle Tabor in PS, CoS and PoA
- Replaced by Tiana Benjamin for GoF
Katie Bell:
- Played by Emily Dale in PS and CoS
- Replaced by Georgina Leonidas for HBP and DH1 & 2
Tom the Leaky Cauldron Innkeeper:
- Played by Derek Deadman in PS
- Replaced by Jim Tavaré for PoA
The Fat Lady:
- Played by Elizabeth Spriggs in PS
- Replaced by Dawn French for PoA
Griphook:
- Played by Verne Troyer in PS
- Replaced by Warwick Davis for DH1 & 2
On another note, due to legal trouble the actor who played Vincent Crabbe in the films was fired but instead of recasting Crabbe they rewrote things so Blaise Zabini would take his role for the final film. The movies also removed Colin Creevey after CoS as the actor aged out of the role and elected not to recast him but to create the new character of Nigel who essentially took on Colin’s role from GoF onwards.
I'd love for the cast of the show to be as consistent as possible but I'll be realistic that this may happen again for a multitude of reasons. Hopefully if it does happen, it involves more minor characters. I know there are other characters that were technically recast in the movies but some of them are very minor characters in the books as well and sometimes these were hardly noticeable.
If the Emperor knows how dangerous the Fremen are, why doesn’t he simply destroy the water reserves hidden in their sietches? Wouldn’t that be a much easier way to weaken them than sending Sardaukar into the desert? #Dune
Dr. Gaul erasing the 10th Games from history proves how terrified regimes are of basic human decency. Reaper didn't even have to kill anyone to become a threat, simply refusing to act like an animal on live TV was enough to break their narrative.
If you can't see the correlation between these movies and real life you're part of the problem
Don't forget Reaper who literally tore down the flags of panem to lay the other tributes to rest and pay respect to them while inside the arena
#Hungergames
The movies changing it from Madge Undersee giving her the pin to finding it at the Hob completely robbed this moment of its real weight. Madge was Maysilee’s actual niece, it wasn't random luck, it was two generations of District 12 girls passing down the exact symbol Snow hated most.
Imagine the odds of her finding the very pin Maysilee once wore, the one Tam Amber made. When Haymitch saw it on her, it felt like his sister was reaching across time, reminding him that he still had a reason to keep fighting. 💔
#HungerGames
No river, no water pouch—just Korra casually conjuring a solid ice wall out of dry city air mid-fight.
Her actual waterbending finesse clears almost everything in the original series.
One very interesting thing I noticed during Catching Fire is when Finnick tells Katniss “Every time that cannon goes off, it’s music to my ears.” I realized Finnick has known every single one of those tributes that are dying and causing that cannon to go off. Not only that but he has known them for several YEARS.
That right there shows how stuck up and self absorbed most of the victors become. Their deaths did not matter to Finnick because of how stuck up they were, also he knew the people of the Capitol idolized the victors. Just a very interesting point of view from Finnick and gives us an idea of how the many encounters Finnick had with his fellow victors went down. He probably witnessed first hand some extremely snobby moments.. especially from the victors of Districts 1 & 2. I love this!
If you can't see the correlation between these movies and real life you're part of the problem
Don't forget Reaper who literally tore down the flags of panem to lay the other tributes to rest and pay respect to them while inside the arena
#Hungergames
Katara parted an entire ocean floor solo while Sokka, Toph, and Zuko fought to keep one ship afloat, yet one episode later she got shut down by Ty Lee.
If Korra had that kind of power scaling, Avatar Twitter would call her a fraud for ten years straight.
Complete Timeline of Voldemort's Rise. The Complete History of Voldemort
Years
Horcruxes
Relevant character info outside of Voldemort’s rise
Tiny tiny amount of background: His mother’s family was the Gaunt’s who were a direct descendant of Slytherin. He was conceived through a love potion she gave to a Muggle, Tom Riddle Sr. His mother died in childbirth. His wizard family was all incestuous and weird and stuff. He grew up in an orphanage with magic he couldn’t explain and was like a sadistic bully. Alright, here we go!
In 1938 Tom Riddle is introduced to Albus Dumbledore and brought to Hogwarts. He was sorted into Slytherin, obviously, and could speak Parsletongue which should’ve been a red flag immediately. Pureblood nonsense was all the rage at these times thanks to our boy Grindelwald and the publishing of The Sacred 28, a list of Pureblood families.
1939 Riddle returns to Hogwarts for his second year. Presumably he was still being a menace over the summer, but that’s conjecture based on my opinion of him. This is also when he starts being a menace at Hogwarts, along with several of his dude bros that later become Death Eaters. Namely, what I shall refer to as “The Four Fathers,” the fathers Lestrange, Malfoy, Rosier, and Avery. No this is not any of the dudes we know - they come later.
Around 1940, Tom Riddle finds out he’s a half-blood and is like, super mad about it. He also finds out that he’s a direct heir of Slytherin somehow, who knows, and he uses this to form his entire personality. He starts calling himself “Voldemort” and so do our four fathers and his other nameless band of delinquent friends.
When Voldemort returns for his fourth year, 1941, he’s obsessed with learning more about his family’s history, and the Dark Arts. In this time he learns about the existence and means of creation of Horcruxes. Hogwarts kept Secrets of the Darkest Arts around in the library for some damn reason we may never know.
During the end of Voldemort’s fifth year, in 1943, all hell breaks loose. Voldy discovers the existence of the Chamber of Secrets and opens that bad boy up. He controls the Basilisk, some Muggle-borns get Petrified, and he kills Myrtle. He uses this murder to make his first Horcrux, which is the Diary.
Rubeus Hagrid is expelled from Hogwarts after being falsely accused of opening the CoS:
A few months later in the summer of 1943, Voldemort tracks down what remains of the Gaunts. They tell him basically that his dad sucks and it’s all his fault, so Voldemort goes and kills all the Riddle family and frames Morfin Gaunt by implanting false memories. Then he swipes his ring (which is also The Resurrection Stone somehow), and uses that to create his second Horcrux - the Gaunt Ring.
Now, after a very busy summer, Voldemort keeps the steam train that is 1943 a-rollin’ and begins his sixth year at Hogwarts. Screw studying for your NEWTs or whatever the nerds are doing, our man is a little busy planning world domination. To help with that, he taps his bff Horace Slughorn to find out if he could “theoretically” create six Horcruxes - so, four more. He ends his sixth year in 1944.
Voldemort lays low for his seventh year. He does his thing and graduates Hogwarts in 1945.
Dumbldore v Grindelwald smackdown happens in 1945:
Now, because Grindelwald left such a big gaping hole in the Pureblood Baddies league, Voldemort starts taking this opportunity to talk all that big game about Pureblood supremacy. He was always on board, but became more outspoken about it in between 1945 and 1946.
Voldy comes back to Hogwarts in 1946 to apply for the position of Defense Against the Dark Arts professor. Dippet is still Headmaster but Dumbledore pulls some strings and gets him to pump the breaks and tell Voldemort “no thanks.” Voldemort takes this time to charm The Grey Lady and find out that Ravenclaw’s Diadem is in Albania.
Show-watchers think Wights are just mindless ice zombies, and that’s why D&D ruined the ending.
In the books, Wights retain memories of who they were. That’s why they specifically targeted Lord Commander Mormont in his quarters instead of attacking random crows.
Westeros spent 6 seasons obsessed with the Iron Throne while Jon screamed that the dead were coming. They chose to do nothing because "we have bigger problems."
Doing nothing was the real villain. And knowing the dead actually remember you while they march past the Wall makes Westeros’s negligence 10x more terrifying.
The one part that got me seriously confused was when Thresh told Katniss he would spare her because she honoured Rue by singing to her, covering her body with flowers and giving her a proper burial. How did he even know what happened? Could the tributes watch live broadcasts of everyone else’s activities in the arena? And if so, why couldn’t they use that information to track down and hunt their opponents?
Why was she even shouting Cato?
And why didn't he just kill Katniss when he knew there could only be one survivor? Letting her live was literally putting his own life at risk.
I have too many, but these are the ones that live in my head forever.
1. McGonagall wakes the castle
Piertotum Locomotor. After Dumbledore is gone, after everything feels lost, she raises her wand and the statues march to defend Hogwarts. That is the moment you realize Hogwarts is not just a school. It is a home that fights back.
2. Harry’s first time in the Great Hall
The candles, the ceiling that looks like the night sky, the Sorting Hat singing. Every kid who ever felt like they did not belong watched that scene and thought, maybe there is a place for me too.
3. The Prisoner of Azkaban time turner
Hermione punching Malfoy and then the whole sequence where Harry and Hermione go back and save Buckbeak and Sirius. It is clever, it is tense, and it is the first time you see Hermione truly let loose.
4. Snape’s memories
Always. One word that rewrites seven books. You go from hating him to realizing he carried the whole story on his back the entire time. I still get chills when Lily’s patronus appears.
5. Dobby’s death
A free elf. That line broke a whole generation. He was not a hero with a wand. He was just a brave little creature who chose to love Harry, and he died for it.
6. The Battle of Hogwarts, Neville vs Nagini
Neville Longbottom, the kid everyone laughed at in year one, pulling the Sword of Gryffindor out of the Sorting Hat and killing Voldemort’s last Horcrux. That is the best character arc ever written.
7. The Mirror of Erised, in the book
Harry seeing his parents for the first time. Not as ghosts, not as memories, just standing there smiling at him. It is quiet, it is sad, and it is so human.
My all time favorite though? It is the scene in Deathly Hallows where Harry walks to his death in the forest, and he sees his parents, Sirius, Remus, and Lily walking with him. He is not afraid anymore because he is not alone. That is the whole series in one moment. Love is stronger than death.
What about you? Are you a funny scenes person, like the Weasley twins leaving Hogwarts, or a crying scenes person, like Dobby and Snape?
Dumbledore never went looking for a straight 1v1 with Voldemort because he knew it was completely pointless. First, Voldemort literally couldn't be killed while his Horcruxes were intact, and Dumbledore was already old and dying with only about a year left by the start of Half-Blood Prince—so risking his weakened life in a duel instead of hunting Horcruxes made zero sense. Even worse, if Dumbledore actually won and reduced Voldemort back to a weakened state like the night he attacked baby Harry, Voldemort wouldn't be able to kill Harry and if Harry didn't die by Voldemort's own hand, Voldemort could never truly die either.
On top of that, Dumbledore didn't even know where Voldemort was most of the time. Voldemort stayed invisible throughout Order of the Phoenix, Half-Blood Prince, and even after taking over in Deathly Hallows, preferring to operate in the dark through the Imperius Curse, torture, murder, and kidnapping rather than showing his face. Even if Dumbledore managed to track him down, Voldemort could easily set a trap or just bail just like he did at the end of Order of the Phoenix when he simply Apparated away during their only duel.
Why didn’t Dumbledore just deal with Voldemort himself instead of leaving it to a teenager and his friends?
He was the only wizard Voldemort truly feared, he had the Elder Wand for a while, and he clearly had the skill to match him. So what stopped him from ending it earlier? Was it the Horcruxes, the prophecy, or something else entirely?
Regulus Black.
He barely appears in the series, yet his story is one of the most fascinating and tragic in the entire wizarding world.
He was raised in a family obsessed with blood purity, idolised Voldemort, and willingly joined the Death Eaters. But when he discovered what Voldemort had done to Kreacher, he began questioning everything he believed in.
Eventually, he sacrificed his life trying to destroy one of Voldemort’s Horcruxes.
What makes his story particularly powerful is that Regulus didn’t have Harry’s support, Dumbledore’s guidance, or an Order of the Phoenix fighting alongside him. He made the decision to stand against Voldemort entirely on his own.
He died without anyone knowing what he had done, and Voldemort never even realised that one of his most loyal followers had betrayed him.
That’s an incredible character arc for someone who barely gets any page time.
Which minor Harry Potter character do you think is seriously underrated?
Not the big names everyone already argues about the ones who only show up for a chapter or two, get a few lines, and still somehow stick with you. Who’s your overlooked favorite?