←
David Labaree5,537 posts
David Labaree avatar

David Labaree

@DLabaree

Emeritus Stanford professor. History & sociology of US education. Latest book is The Emergent Genius of American Higher Ed. Blog at davidlabaree.com.

◷ Joined November 2016▧ 1,638 Photos and videos
David Labaree avatar
David Labaree@DLabaree·Nov 17

The Sociology of Education Association is organizing its 2027 annual meeting around the theme Contested Goals, Uncertain Futures: Revisiting the Purpose and Practice of Education. It draws on my paper, Public Goods, Private Goods: The American Struggle over Educational Goals. "At the turn of the 21st century, historian and sociologist of education David Labaree observed that schools “occupy an awkward position at the intersection between what we hope society will become and what we think it really is, between political ideals and economic realities.”1 This tension, he argued, is central to understanding the distinct and contradictory goals that have been imposed on American schools and how the social mobility goal of education—which views education as a private good for individual gain—came to dominate more democratic purposes and public good paradigms of education." sociologyofeducation.org/wp-…

David Labaree avatar
David Labaree@DLabaree·Nov 16

My new blog post is a commentary on a classic essay by Charles Tilly, “War Making and State Making as Organized Crime.” Given the state of the second Trump administration, there has never been a better to time revisit this analysis.  We now have a crime boss in charge of the country.  This discussion is reprinted in my new book, Essays on History, Writing, and Schooling. His essay is a riff on an aphorism he developed earlier: the state makes war and war makes the state.  There’s a lot of insight imbedded in this statement.  The key for me is that the people who turned feudal kingdoms into states in early modern Europe were not trying to construct the apparatus of a full-fledged state — with centralized power, stable sources of funding, structures for transmitting rule throughout the realm, a monopoly on violence, and a strong military.  Instead, they were just trying to wage war effectively in a highly competitive environment in which the advantage went to the actor who could best mount and sustain large-scale military engagements. The issue was not just who had the latest military technology but who had the political and economic resources to produce that technology and put it, plus a lot of manpower, into the field for extended periods of time.  In order to accomplish this goal, they needed to develop a structure of governance that emerged into something approaching a modern state.  State building was a side effect of war making. davidlabaree.com

Post attachmentPost attachment
David Labaree avatar
David Labaree@DLabaree·Nov 16

My new blog post is a commentary on a classic essay by Charles Tilly, “War Making and State Making as Organized Crime.” Given the state of the second Trump administration, there has never been a better to time revisit this analysis.  We now have a crime boss in charge of the country.  This discussion is reprinted in my new book, Essays on History, Writing, and Schooling. His essay is a riff on an aphorism he developed earlier: the state makes war and war makes the state.  There’s a lot of insight imbedded in this statement.  The key for me is that the people who turned feudal kingdoms into states in early modern Europe were not trying to construct the apparatus of a full-fledged state — with centralized power, stable sources of funding, structures for transmitting rule throughout the realm, a monopoly on violence, and a strong military.  Instead, they were just trying to wage war effectively in a highly competitive environment in which the advantage went to the actor who could best mount and sustain large-scale military engagements. The issue was not just who had the latest military technology but who had the political and economic resources to produce that technology and put it, plus a lot of manpower, into the field for extended periods of time.  In order to accomplish this goal, they needed to develop a structure of governance that emerged into something approaching a modern state.  State building was a side effect of war making. davidlabaree.com

Post attachmentPost attachment
Amazing Maps avatar
⟳ David Labaree retweeted
Amazing Maps@amazingmap·Nov 13

England became a single kingdom in 927, when Æthelstan took York from its Viking rulers.

Post attachment
Bjorn Lomborg avatar
⟳ David Labaree retweeted
Bjorn Lomborg@BjornLomborg·Nov 13

Happy Doomsday! A 1960 Science paper showed that if population kept growing as for the past 2,000 years, it would hit infinity today, Friday Nov 13, 2026 Reality: 8.3 billion, growth down from 2.2% to 0.8% a year Don't trust simplistic doom extrapolations, then or now

Post attachment
David Labaree avatar
David Labaree@DLabaree·Nov 13

Suppose you are a stand-up comic who performs regularly for small nightclubs. Almost none of your audience engages with your material. Half are surreptitiously looking at their phones, others have ear buds in. There’s always a couple of audience members who sit up front and laugh on the regular, and sometimes you’ll get a flicker of a smile out of a few others. In your mind, that counts as “not bombing.” You try to keep it fresh and topical, but hey, it’s still a comedy show. If the audience didn’t come wanting laughs, why are they there? Now do this night after night for 35 years. This is what it is like to teach students at the average college. substack.com/@hilariusbookbi…

David Labaree avatar
David Labaree@DLabaree·Nov 13

The Healthcare System Great line: "I have a bone to pick with whoever is in charge of health care. My main complaint at the moment concerns my eye drops, one of a variety of prescription medications I take to compensate for the fact that, as I age, my body is deteriorating like a corn dog in a hot dumpster." davebarry.substack.com/p/the…