I'm an independent hobbyist investigator and commentator with an “unlaw” focus. I’m not really interested in law, legal theory, etc. Methodologically, I’m a microbiologist who studies law-related things. I measure court processes and activities, and track pseudolaw phenomena.
I engage in data-driven research using science-based investigation and analysis. Little is known on how Canadian courts truly operate. My studies quantify Canadian appellate litigation, including the controversial SRL phenomenon. I also investigate anti-authority false-law pseudolaw phenomena, Canadian pseudolaw groups and their beliefs, and how pseudolaw is embedded in the junkheap of information sociologists call the “cultic milieu”.
I used to be an Alberta Court of King's Bench staff lawyer, the “Complex Litigant Management Counsel”, who assisted management of problem litigants and litigation. Any of my often cranky statements and publications are my own opinion and perspective, and not that of my former workplace, its personnel, and judges.
Most of my published research is archived on ResearchGate, if you are curious (researchgate.net/profile/Don…).
Oh yeah, and I’m an unrepentant weirdo. It kind of leaks through, sometimes.
(Fursona art courtesy of brightkarma - furaffinity.net/view/5808345…).
Recent overview of pseudolaw in the UK, including discussion of both older forms and recent money-for-nothing guru Ian Clifford Stamp.
Definitely worth a look. There's even estimates of active council (municipal) tax pseudolaw evasion.
theguardian.com/news/2026/no…
Got referenced in Australian news reporting:
news.com.au/national/victori…
I think Harry's concerns are overstated but understandable. What I suspect will happen is someone in the Registry will become very familiar with pseudolaw crackpottery and be the gatekeeper.
Or such a person already exists. No point in the Courts broadcasting that fact.
*fiendish cackle*
There's advantages to having a low profile.
Courts in the Australian State of Victoria have clearly had their fill of pseudolaw arguments & litigants. A Practice Note issued September 14, 2026 entirely blocks 8 common pseudolaw concepts.
You can't even file a document that exhibits these motifs.
Total nuke up front.
This block is part of a larger "Practice Note for Self-Represented Litigants", a set of binding directions for those who use the Victoria Supreme Court trial, appeal, and costs divisions. The document has 8 pages of directions which range from instructions to show up to court hearings on time, copy other parties in your correspondence to the court, do not submit evidence in emails.
Ever wonder what it’s like to be a front-line staffer in a court? Here’s a clue, paragraph 6.4:
You must act respectfully and honestly in all dealings with the Court and the other parties, including in documents, emails, phone calls and in Court. You must not shout, swear, threaten or be rude. If you communicate with the Court in a disrespectful, aggressive, abusive or threatening way, Court staff may end the communication or not respond to it. Abusive or threatening behaviour may be reported to police.
So this document is a mix of common sense, what ought to be obvious, and cautions like:
Social media is not a reliable source of legal information and advice. ... Relying on false information about the law from websites or social media will make it more likely that you will lose your case and be ordered to pay the other side’s legal costs.
And, of course, large language model AIs are not a reliable source for legal information.
But back to the pseudolaw stuff. Paragraph 8.11 states:
The Annexure lists some common arguments and submissions that are not real legal arguments, which courts have considered and rejected. Registry staff can reject a document submitted for filing if it relies on pseudo-legal arguments, including those referred to in the Annexure.
See the attached photos for the eight prohibited arguments. What you’d expect, with Strawman Theory heading the list. I bet this captures well over 3/4 of pseudolaw attempted filings.
The Victoria document rejection mechanism is the most aggressive up-front management and interdiction of pseudolaw documents I’ve seen in any jurisdiction. Any of these eight items – and potentially others, look at how the preamble paragraph indicates the eight items are just examples (“including”) of pseudolegal arguments – is a basis for Registry staff to reject. There’s no appeal process. There’s no argument. Registry staff are free to reject.
Get. Out.
And here’s a twist I would not have expected. In Alberta the Court of King’s Bench uses something analogous to this, a “Master Order” that requires court clerks reject for filing documents that include “Formal Defects”, such as naming structures used in Strawman Theory. The Master Order, for example, prohibits filing of documents with names in dash-colon format (Firstname-Middlename: Lastname) or where names appear both in all uppercase and mixed case. Those are unique weirdness that traces to Strawman Theory.
But the Victoria Courts have gone further. They’ve authorized their Registry staff to interpret documents being filed and nuking on that basis.
I don’t think that would be even legal in Canada, at least for filings in criminal proceedings.
Very, very interesting.
The full practice note can be downloaded here:
supremecourt.vic.gov.au/area…
So damned aggro! I LIKE it!
(Thanks to the user who tipped me off on this development!)
There's so much interesting new scholarship in the pseudolaw world. Here Lobbert explores the deep question of why someone would mimic being part of a fictitious state.
Why? Partially all states are fictions. But deeper, we need anchors.
Highly recommended.
journals.uchicago.edu/doi/pd…
The CBC's 5th Estate news program has released a video on pseudolaw "Sovereign Citizens" who have defrauded the Canadian government using Strawman Theory related techniques, possibly up to $300 million:
youtube.com/watch?v=07u-4qiG…
I was contacted by the CBC for this program. I do not appear because I refuse to participate in any video or permit photographs of myself.
I'm kinda weird that way.
I write frequently about pseudolaw - but pseudolaw also involves "real law". And sometimes non-pseudolaw types make pseudolaw claims.
Which brings us to Rally Canada v Etty Farms. This is a decision of the Alberta Land and Property Rights Tribunal. What's that? Well, it's pretty typical that the person who owns the land above minerals is different from who owns those minerals, or the right to extract minerals.
This is a point of friction. Land owners like farmers or ranchers who own land may find companies like petrochemical firms have the right to pump out oil or gas from underneath their land. The surface rights owners have a right to compensation for mineral extraction on their part of the land - the underground rights depend on a kind of trespass on surface rights.
When there's a disagreement on the amount of that compensation, that goes to the ABLPRT, which is a very busy tribunal.
Here the scenario is:
-Rally is extracting something, probably natural gas, from under Etty Farms.
-Rally and Etty agree to payments of $4,000 per year for surface access.
-There's some confusion following the death of the owner of Etty Farms. That leads to some wonderfully polite exchanges between the two parties.
-It becomes apparent that a Rally employee unilaterally reduced payment to $2,900. Eventually that gets to the ABLPRT to determine what should have been paid over a couple years.
And the ABLPRT cites Meads v Meads and another Alberta pseudolaw case for the rule that you can't foist a contract on someone else. Contracts require agreement:
In contract, silence does not mean consent or agreement.
So there you go. Big corpo tries a classic pseudolaw stunt. Gets told no.
This isn't the first time I've seen pseudolaw judgments providing basic legal rules in other contexts. Kinda neat.
Full judgment is here:
Rally Canada Resources Ltd v. Etty Farms Ltd, 2026 ABLPRT 617 - canlii.ca/t/knm7k
Most pseudolaws involve two competing legal systems, where one (imaginary) legal system provides secret advantages.
An older Canadian pseudolaw variation has Indigenous or Aboriginal law as superior to ordinary law.
And now in Canada, that may be true. Incrementally.
The typical version is the one taught by gurus like Glenn “Spirit Warrior” Bogue, that if you can cram yourself into an “Indigenous” or “Aboriginal” box, you are only subject to that kind of law and administration. You might have your disputes heard in a special Tribal or First Nation court, and then enforced in ordinary Canadian courts. Canadian law is inactive or excluded, depending on Indigenous (self)-identity
Of course, it’s not true - yet - that someone can slap an Indigenous licence plate on a “personal conveyance” in Canada, and now you don’t need to follow traffic legislation or pay your speeding tickets.
But the underlying concept, that there is another legal system in Canada that draws off Indigenous heritage and rules, that is becoming real. The process started when the Supreme Court of Canada in a decision titled Reference re An Act respecting First Nations, Inuit and Métis children, youth and families, 2024 SCC 5 concluded that three separate legal systems are recognized and involved in child welfare:
(1) the conventional Canadian legislation and court-made rules (common law)
(2) international treaty law
(3) Indigenous law.
The Court describes these three legal systems as “braiding together”. What does that mean? No idea. What is Indigenous law? How can I learn about that? Read the rules and so on? No idea.
It might even be a cultural secret.
But what this means is when pseudolaw gurus say there is a separate Indigneous-oriented/sourced legal system and rules in Canada, they are now correct. Courts after the Reference judgment at least when it comes to child welfare probably could get into real trouble if someone marched in, declared a child is Indigenous, and then tried to enforce Tribal Law or something like that.
Which is actually what happened here (MD v Alberta (Director of Child and Family Services), 2024 ABKB 565 - canlii.ca/t/k70fw), but the Alberta Court of King’s Bench wasn’t especially sympathetic. If you know that court you're probably not terribly surprised.
Well, things have progressed. A new SCC decision, R v Cope, 2026 SCC 32 (canlii.ca/t/knm9q) has returned to the “braiding” concept. This time the “braiding” was between an ordinary Canadian criminal court evaluating an assault between an intimate couple where the male injured the female. Both were Indigenous.
There’s a bunch of stuff about whether the sentencing court should prioritize the part of the Criminal Code that says Indigenous offenders should not receive custodial sentences, and another part that seems to say the opposite, that where complainants (victims) are indigenous women then that warrants “denunciation and deterrence.” Which applies? Both do, of course! They are “distinct threads woven into a common fabric”.
I have no idea what that means. Sounds pretty though, doesn’t it?
But then there’s the “braiding” of Indigenous and Canadian law. The offender was Indigenous and was the subject of a “sentencing circle” process by Indigenous individuals. Indigenous legal principles led to the recommendation that the offender receive no further jail time. Off you go! That was not possible under Canadian legislation, so the sentencing judge didn’t do that.
But at the SCC there was much discussion about sentencing circles as sources of law. The long story short is that these are Important. And beyond that, I don't really understand how you would apply a sentencing circle sentence, aside from that “braiding” thing. In this new regime Canadian criminal sentencing braids together sentencing circle outcomes and the law that applies to everybody else.
But this time there’s a split. With the Reference decision, all nine judges were on board with “braiding”. This time only five of the justices go with the “braiding” thing: Canadian and Indigenous criminal laws are somehow on a level-ish playing field.
Now four of the SCC justices (Chief Justice Wagner, Justices Côté, Rowe and Jamal) react quite badly to the “braiding”. They observe “the braiding analogy” means that the sentencing judge is being limited by the outcome at the sentencing circle. That means this Indigenous law thing, whatever it is, is muscling into the exclusive territory of the Crown and Court to conduct criminal proceedings and sanction criminal offenders.
Which means, again, gurus like Glenn Bogue are at least partially correct. There is a separate legal system (or systems, it’ll arguably be “First Nations” based, of which there are hundreds) with peer-like and neighbor status to the law I learned about in law school and working inside a court. How’s this going to work? No idea whatsoever. It'll be "contextual" and "offender-specific" though, I'm pretty sure of that.
I’m so very, very glad I’m retired.
But, if you’re a sentencing judge, and some guy who says he’s the Chief of a First Nation you’ve never heard of, and he has the decision of the Common Law Court Sentencing Circle for the offender under trial? Well, that judge probably is going to have a very long day.
So I fully expect to encounter “sentencing circles for hire” sooner than later.
And this is probably just the start of the “braiding” process.
Excerpt from Outlawed by Harry Hobbs and Stephen Young discussing the notorious Meads v Meads judgment I've never heard anything about:
insidestory.org.au/judge-roo…
Yes, I forwarded the link to John so he can have a chuckle.
Where I live a lawyer or ex-lawyer is prohibited from serving in juries. I kinda regret that.
But in Australia you just show up! Cool!
Yes, this is a pseudolaw thing.
I'll say this: the Common Law Court of the Sovereign Peoples Assembly of Western Australia has beaten out any Canadian court I've attended on one key point: they supply branded water bottles! (wacommonlaw.au/court/)
Pretty aggressive sentences, too. This judgment (wacommonlaw.au/court-verdict…) imposed 150 year, and $300 million (gold bullion) penalties on a bunch of psychiatrists.
I also like how the judgment clarifies the exchange rates for gold and worthless fiat currency at the judgment date. It's these little details that encourage institutional trust.
Too bad this isn't a Canadian outfit. It'd give me an excuse to write about the CLC SPAWA and in a legal constitutional sense evaluate what would be the consequences of such a judgment. Yes, it's probably not enforceable. There would likely not be any criminal prohibition breached in Canada by the Court, though its Sheriffs could be in trouble.
But what I find intriguing in a goofy law formalities/procedure sense is what about the "No Appeal" clause. At least in Canada that would not work. But explaining why would be fun.
Oh well.
Nicola & David Suppa reversed the taxation process. They took ordinary Canada Revenue Agency money deposit forms, scribbled on them, declared those were a “Coupon of Money” & demanded the CRA pay them $4,494.530.03.
The CRA didn’t pay. The Suppas sued.
Didn't work.
A recent decision of Justice Duchesne of the Federal Court of Canada tells and illustrates the tale! He calls what the Suppas did "defacing" CRA documents:
in order to create fictitious “negotiable instruments” to make millions of dollars payable to them by the CRA based on a tortuous reading of legislation supplemented by dictionary definitions of various terms. The statement of claim falls within the ambit of OPCA litigation, fails to disclose a reasonable cause of action, and is plainly and obviously doomed to fail.
The pseudolegal theory behind the Suppas’ claim is a bastardized interpretation of the Bills of Exchange Act and Financial Administration Act purportedly transforms an IOU into a final payment. That is a pretty common Canadian “money for nothing” pseudolaw gambit. The Suppas version is what I would politely call “unsophisticated”.
The Suppas then used a series of notices, including a “Notice of Dishonour of Non-Acceptance” and “Notice of Dishonour” that purport to create a binding outcome against the CRA by non-response and non-acceptance. This is commonly referred to as a “Three/Five Letters” strategy.
The judgment attaches some of these documents, both the “defaced” receipts and the Three/Five Letters. They’re kind of small and fuzzy the resolution isn’t the greatest, but if you want to review them and have a good giggle, there you are! See the “Schedule” at the end of the judgment.
One such document is simply a payment receipt re-labelled as “Money order”, with:
PAY TO THE ORDER OF
NICK SUPPA
WITHOUT RECOURSE
By: [signature Nick Suppa]
NICK SUPPA, VICE PRESIDENT
What’s kind of fun the exact language and “defacing” changes evolve from document to document, which shows the Suppas were experimenting and feeling around looking for that magic language that would get them tasty tasty free money.
Justice Duchesne described the process this way:
The thread running through the alleged “registered negotiable instruments” is that the Plaintiffs have taken a GST/HST tax owing remittance voucher or a similar form of document, written in manuscript on the face of the voucher that the document is a money order or other type of document payable to the either of the Plaintiffs, signed the document “without recourse” and then endorsed the remittance slip with the words “accepted for payment” or “accepted for deposit”, or “for value”, again, “without recourse”. The stamped signatures on the documents are signed by the either of the Plaintiffs as Agents for themselves as a “Principal”. A demand letter replete with OPCA language and demands that the CRA pay them the amount they inscribed on the voucher by defacing it based on their own unsound interpretation of BEA and the FAA, along with various dictionary definitions, then follow. ...
A very accurate summary. Though he’s polite when it comes to calling this scheme garbage:
The documents relied upon by the Plaintiffs to substantiate their claims in this proceeding purport to unilaterally impose a payment obligation on the CRA when the underlying documents said to substantiate the alleged debts, or payments by the Plaintiffs or either of them to CRA, have no basis in law and are plainly fictions.
Naturally the Suppas’ lawsuit to enforce their magic documents was identified immediately, challenged, and tossed. The Suppas were ordered to pay $2,000 for wasting everyone's time.
It must be getting a little discouraging for pseudolaw types to have their arguments slapped down like this. The Federal Court of Canada is a very businesslike and efficient place. Abusive litigation is targeted aggressively. As this decision illustrates, both the government lawyers and the court know their stuff.
Full decision and silly pictures are here:
Suppa v Canada (Attorney General), 2026 FC 1191- canlii.ca/t/knc62
I made a short effort to learn more about the Suppas. Didn’t find anything interesting.
New Zealand has its first broad survey of pseudolaw caselaw in MA thesis by William Biss:
hdl.handle.net/10523/52479
Biss identifies & surveys 267 NZ court judgments that involve pseudolaw, plotting a progressive increase over the past decade.
Notably, half involve a NZ Maori-specific/linked conceptual base that Biss describes as a novel local adaptation of pseudolaws' more common general structure.
Biss also uses interviews and law enforcement reports to evaluate the NZ pseudolaw ecosystem, including:
-the role of the COVID-19 pandemic in the propagation of these ideas
-the source populations for these claims (lower income/economic status)
-the absence of leading guru figures, or rather the proliferation of numerous micro-gurus with small to negligible follower bases
-employment of Indigenous arguments that are incoherent to the developed law in NZ
-the limited record of violence from pseudolaw adherent populations, but deep personal disassociation state and social norms
-that Australian and NZ pseudolaw are following different patterns, at least partially attributable to the different (not)-legal reasoning in the two jurisdictions
There's good stuff here written by an investigator who has been musing about both what is going on nationally, and in other jurisdictions.
Looking forward to more digging by the author and other NZ investigators.
Continuing to read this master's thesis on pseudolaw in New Zealand.
The author suggests "paper terrorism" should be replaced with "procedural terrorism".
I really like that.
Reading a new grad thesis on pseudolaw where the author made an observation I'd never thought of.
The plight of a witness in a criminal proceeding facing a defendant who is deploying pseudolaw, making all kinds of crazy and threatening challenges.
That would be frightening. Intimidating. If the Crown/state prosecutor hadn't prepared the witness, or the judge doesn't intervene, that could be a deeply disturbing experience.
Not sure how you would deal with that. I've seen state witnesses, like police, experience that kind of attack, but they understand enough law to know this isn't relevant. Plus they've probably been witnesses many, many times in the past. For them the court is a foreign but familiar space.
But what if you were just a layperson, particularly a victim of a violent pseudolaw-using criminal?
I don't know if there's a good answer, at least in Canada. In Canada, criminal accused and their lawyers have pretty much carte blanche on how they run their defence. A judge would have to think very hard before intervening in questioning from a self-represented accused.
What an interesting and unpleasant puzzle.
Happy Meads v Meads day! 14 years!
From the CanLII website & my notes, the decision has been cited in 536 court judgments worldwide.
Not bad for a trial-level decision that, purportedly, is nothing but obiter.
Here's a link: canlii.ca/t/fsvjq (It's long...)
And even persistence has an endpoint. One of Canada's largest and certainly most sophisticated pseudolaw "Detaxer" schemes was the Paradigm Education Group, that operated in the early 2000s.
Its key promoters, a husband and wife team, made roughly $1.4 million. They were found guilty of counselling fraud and incarcerated.
Then the CRA came calling, and used the findings of the criminal proceeding as the foundation to seek unpaid taxes on that income. The PEG promoters at the Tax Court of Canada deployed the same arguments they'd sold to customers. They lost. This is 2025.
They ran those arguments up to the Supreme Court of Canada which today refused to hear their appeal. The promoters never really adapted their arguments much, so it was face into brick wall, over and over.
For 20 years.