←
Dan Scolnic1,363 posts
Dan Scolnic avatar

Dan Scolnic

@DScol

I'm a dad; I’m a professor doing cosmology at Duke U. and I have some opinions about basketball.

◷ Joined May 2009▧ 208 Photos and videos
Dan Scolnic avatar
Dan Scolnic@DScol·Sep 29

While this doesn't mean carbon-rich AGB stars can't be useful distance indicators, it now seems not safe to assume they are C-rich AGB stars in spirals like in the LMC. Before treating them as a standard candle to calibrate SN Ia, need to establish that we're actually measuring the same physical population across the distance ladder. From these papers, variability, water bands and metallicity measurements should help.

Dan Scolnic avatar
Dan Scolnic@DScol·Sep 29

How come? It looks like pulsating O-rich AGB stars in metal rich spirals like M101 or the MW appear to produce substantially more silicate dust than their LMC counterparts, reddening them into the “carbon-star” color region. So the same broadband color cut can select different physical populations in different environments.

Dan Scolnic avatar
Dan Scolnic@DScol·Sep 29

A second paper uses SPHEREx spectroscopy plus JWST/HST. In the LMC, traditional JAGB color selections are essentially all carbon stars. But apply the same selections to M101 and 33–68% are oxygen-rich. arxiv.org/abs/2609.30551

Dan Scolnic avatar
Dan Scolnic@DScol·Sep 29

The CHASE survey went straight to spectroscopy. Of 54 Milky Way stars selected in the standard JAGB box, only 13 were carbon-rich: 76 ± 6% were oxygen-rich. Even near the JAGB luminosity peak, the contamination was 71%. arxiv.org/abs/2609.25412

Dan Scolnic avatar
Dan Scolnic@DScol·Sep 29

Two new papers this last week about important challenge for the JAGB distance indicator: stars selected by usual “J-region” color cuts are not necessarily the carbon-rich AGB stars we thought they were. And two very different approaches are finding the same thing.

Dan Scolnic avatar
Dan Scolnic@DScol·Aug 30

Awesome getting to spend day with the infinitely curious @McConaughey as well as so many from @NASARoman team and @DukePhysics. What an incredible day and great video Matthew!

Big congrats to Dan Scolnic and the Roman Space Telescope Team on the successful launch this AM. Looking forward to what you show us about ourselves.

0:37
Dillon Brout avatar
⟳ Dan Scolnic retweeted
Dillon Brout@DillonBrout·Aug 10

1/ With NASA's Roman Space Telescope launch 🚀 in T-20 days and our official team jerseys in hand, this is the perfect timing to congratulate my PhD student, @rujutapurohit, on her first-first author paper 🎉 Paper: arxiv.org/abs/2607.08886 Roman Hype:

NASA@NASAJul 29

LIVE: In one month, @NASARoman will lift off to help us study some of the greatest mysteries in the universe! Tune in as NASA experts give an overview of the mission and its status. x.com/i/broadcasts/1qxvvvQRL…

Dan Scolnic avatar
Dan Scolnic@DScol·Aug 7

So the dramatic gain in precision comes from assuming the reconstructed peculiar velocities are known with very little uncertainty. Would be good to propagate the full M25 ensemble, not just its mean corrections, including covariance, residual small-scale velocity dispersion, and selection.

Dan Scolnic avatar
Dan Scolnic@DScol·Aug 7

The paper then concludes that this suggests the Hubble tension may arise from an unidentified systematic in the distance ladder rather than new physics. Conclusion is roughly: six spatially correlated masers + a velocity model whose uncertainty has been dramatically compressed → a ~2σ difference with H0DN → evidence that the cross-checked distance ladder has an unidentified systematic? .

Dan Scolnic avatar
Dan Scolnic@DScol·Aug 7

The original MCP analysis, using the 2M++ peculiar-velocity model, gave H0 = 71.8 ± 2.7. Switching to M25 lowers the central value to ~69.7 +/- 2.6, not such a dramatic change. But allowing σv to vanish drives H0 lower and crucially the uncertainty down to ±0.9 km/s/Mpc, roughly 3× more precise than the original megamaser determination.

Dan Scolnic avatar
Dan Scolnic@DScol·Aug 7

Leaving out those posteriors and external information leaves little leverage on σv, and its driven toward ~0 km/s, which just can't be. The weights of the masers change dramatically, so that even nearby NGC 4258 itself, just outside the Local Group at ~7.6 Mpc away where peculiar velocity is usually considered a large fraction of the Hubble flow, is claimed to measure H0 very precisely.

Dan Scolnic avatar
Dan Scolnic@DScol·Aug 7

M25 doesn’t just give one peculiar velocity per galaxy. It uses constrained realizations to provide uncertainty and covariance in the reconstructed velocity field, which should be propagated into maser analysis. Instead, the paper uses only the central values and replaces all the rest of the information with a single independent velocity dispersion, σv, inferred from just these 6 masers.

Dan Scolnic avatar
Dan Scolnic@DScol·Aug 7

New H0 paper arxiv.org/abs/2608.06247 which applies sophisticated Manticore (M25) peculiar-velocity reconstruction to the 6 megamaser galaxies from the MCP (P20). Important idea, but leaves out what makes M25 powerful.

Dan Scolnic avatar
Dan Scolnic@DScol·Mar 27

Had a group goodbye dinner for @space_veggie before they go off and become fancy NASA Goddard scientist. Lauren is leading our supernova photometry pipeline for @NASARoman and will continue this work at Goddard.

Post attachment