←
David Macdonald1,683 posts
David Macdonald avatar

David Macdonald

@DavidMacCdn

Senior Economist, Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives @CCPA For the lawyers: Opinions expressed on twitter are my own. RTs are not endorsements.

◷ Joined March 2011▧ 317 Photos and videos
David Macdonald avatar
David Macdonald@DavidMacCdn·28 Oct 2025

Budget are about choices. We don't have to choose these cuts, we can choose to invest in Canadian priorities instead. Today our Alternative Federal Budget includes 100s of costed programs we should be choosing: policyalternatives.ca/news-r… 7/x

David Macdonald avatar
David Macdonald@DavidMacCdn·28 Oct 2025

So what's at risk? We've compiled over 120 programs that are going to sunset in the next three years. Many climate change programs, women fleeing violence, airline complaints resolution, student jobs programs are at risk 5/x

David Macdonald avatar
David Macdonald@DavidMacCdn·28 Oct 2025

One of the ways depts will get to their 15% cut target will be to just sit on their hands and let programs sunset. It will be an accident of timing of what will be lost 4/x

David Macdonald avatar
David Macdonald@DavidMacCdn·28 Oct 2025

Many fed programs aren't permanent, they have to be renewed every few years. Over the next 3yrs, almost no programs will be renewed due to the 15% cuts. This "sunsetting" affects some depts more than others. 2/x

David Macdonald avatar
David Macdonald@DavidMacCdn·28 Oct 2025

Budgets are meant to be good news docs. This one will downplay all that will be lost with 15% cuts in most depts. We've scoured dept docs to identify programs likely to be "sunset" and the 52 depts likely to use this strategy @ccpa 🧵👇👇👇

David Macdonald avatar
David Macdonald@DavidMacCdn·21 Aug 2025

Now that fees are falling fast, the real challenge is space creation. Without strong public planning, for-profits will keep expanding in the easiest places—not where kids actually live. We need more proactive planning to hit the targets and do it with non-profit spaces. (8/10)

David Macdonald avatar
David Macdonald@DavidMacCdn·21 Aug 2025

The program was supposed to grow public and non-profit child care. Instead, it’s become a cash cow for private operators who dominate the growth: • 57% of new spaces since 2022 are for-profit • Only 30% are non-profit or public (6/10)

David Macdonald avatar
David Macdonald@DavidMacCdn·21 Aug 2025

But the real issue isn’t just how many spaces are created—it’s whether parents can find one. The fed benchmark is 5.9 spaces per 10 kids. Only Quebec and PEI are already there. Many provinces won’t hit it, even if they hit their space creation targets (which many won’t). (5/10)

David Macdonald avatar
David Macdonald@DavidMacCdn·21 Aug 2025

That being said, child care deserts—blocks with almost no nearby child care spaces—are shrinking, but still widespread. BC, Alb, Sask, NL, Ontario have all rapidly reduced the number of kids living in child care deserts 4/10

David Macdonald avatar
David Macdonald@DavidMacCdn·21 Aug 2025

Overachievers who are above their space creation targets: NB, BC & PEI Already have decent coverage: Quebec and PEI Strugglers: MB & SK: only a fraction of their goals Progress is uneven—and often behind. (3/10)

David Macdonald avatar
David Macdonald@DavidMacCdn·21 Aug 2025

The fed’s goal isn’t just $10-a-day fees by 2026—it’s also 210K new full-time child care spaces by April 2025. So far, provinces are short 57,030 spaces. Some prov are on target or ahead. Others are far behind. (2/10)