←
David Ubilava7,986 posts
David Ubilava avatar

David Ubilava

@DavidUbilava

Associate Professor of Economics at the University of Sydney. Co-Editor-in-Chief of Food Policy.

◷ Joined March 2010▧ 373 Photos and videos
David Ubilava avatar
David Ubilava@DavidUbilava·Oct 27

I don't like AI-generated reports: 1. they are useless insofar as they do not add value beyond what the authors could achieve without the reviewer's participation in the process. 2. we can no longer call it a peer-review process. 3. it just seems unfair to the authors.

David Ubilava avatar
David Ubilava@DavidUbilava·Oct 25

Ideas is probably top of the list. Overseeing the process is probably another. And then, in economics at least, there is a natural life-cycle of a paper that involves disseminating and presenting work at seminars and conferences. Works better with only a handful of papers.

Genuine question for my economist friends: What are the current bottlenecks to writing more research papers, faster? I know AI doesn’t make an RCT go faster, and my understanding is that AI can’t be used to analyze data within an RDC or similar restricted servers. But it seems like AI should be making much quicker work of other data analysis and writing. So, why isn’t every economist I know churning out 10 times as many papers? Are robustness check demands increasing to match AI capabilities? Or does everyone need to re-prep all their courses now, making teaching a bigger burden? I’m not trying to be an a**hole. (You’re all doing great! I know how exhausting academia is!) I’m just very curious what the bottlenecks on research are in this new era, and whether/how resources could help relax those constraints.

David Ubilava avatar
David Ubilava@DavidUbilava·Oct 15

Meanwhile in Australia, people of all ages, all genders, in any setting: "Cheers mate."

I’m thrown off by young people saying “I appreciate you” instead of “thank you.” (Latest ex: guy in front of me at Chipotle to the guy who made his burrito. I felt like such a common Gen Xer with my regular old “thanks!”) Is there a story here? What’s with this linguistic shift?

David Ubilava avatar
David Ubilava@DavidUbilava·Oct 13

The call is for editors to make, while referee reports are there for editors to inform their decisions and for authors to improve their papers (regardless of the decision). It truly is as simple as that, and I don't understand why people (editors) complicate the process.

Editors: stop hiding behind referees to defend rejections. Own the call, made with the help of referees. And misrepresenting the referee’s confidential comments to the editor in your letter? Even worse. Referees read those letters—they know what they actually wrote.

David Ubilava avatar
David Ubilava@DavidUbilava·Oct 3

fwiw, co-author probably was pre-selected as an alternate reviewer, so the rejection triggered the invite.

Update: rejected the request, explained the situation to the editor. Coauthor received the same request shortly after.

David Ubilava avatar
David Ubilava@DavidUbilava·Sep 30

This. 💯!

Very frustrating to me as an editor that other editors say they are rejecting a paper because of a review. Reviewers' job is strictly advice. It's incumbent on the editor to affirmatively agree or disagree with that advice and make a decision.

David Ubilava avatar
David Ubilava@DavidUbilava·Sep 19

I see commentary about El Nino potentially causing food price inflation in Australia (also USA, sometimes also Europe), and I just don't think this to be the case. An odd food item, maybe, but generally no, not in high income countries. Feel free to check previous El Nino-s.

David Ubilava avatar
David Ubilava@DavidUbilava·Sep 15

This El Nino can impact lives and livelihoods in many parts of the world in many different ways. But I am going to go out on a limb here and claim that Brits are going to be just fine. theguardian.com/environment/…

David Ubilava avatar
David Ubilava@DavidUbilava·Sep 5

If your abstract goes: We study the effect of X, Y and Z on P, Q, R and S, using methods A, B, C and D, and thus make 5 important contributions to the literature... Then you need to re-write the abstract and, likely, also the paper.

David Ubilava avatar
David Ubilava@DavidUbilava·Aug 21

Here is a clear and indisputable evidence of AInflation. Daron's citation count followed a linear trend... until it didn't.

Post attachment
David Ubilava avatar
David Ubilava@DavidUbilava·Aug 15

You do realise that the culprit in this anecdote is the editor, right?

Disagree. An interesting thing happened recently. My collaborators and I were locked in an unproductive and back-and-forth with a referee who kept repeating the same mistake even after we explained thoroughly and rejected our paper. After we appealed, the editor ran the paper through chatgpt and shared its feedback with us, to give us a chance to improve it before resubmission. Unlike the referee, chatgpt uncovered actual errors in the paper. This was genuinely useful feedback which helped us improve the paper! I would take a real-time chat with an llm over a months-long back-and-forth with a reviewer 2!

David Ubilava avatar
David Ubilava@DavidUbilava·Aug 14

If she plays her cards right, one day, she may graduate from being Jeff Bezos ex-wife MacKenzie Scott and be just Mackenzie Scott. Speaking of Amazon, looks like Mackenzie Scott's ex-husband Jeff Bezos is doing just fine.

Post attachment
David Ubilava avatar
David Ubilava@DavidUbilava·Aug 2

At @_Food_Policy , we have seen a stark increase in submissions. This year is trending about 60% above last year, which was well above the pre-AI era. The pressure on editors and reviewers is real, with no clear solution in sight (though, I am sure we will adapt in due course).

Post attachment
David Ubilava avatar
David Ubilava@DavidUbilava·Jul 29

The top 3 ag econ journals, in my view, are Agricultural Economics, Food Policy, and the AJAE. Featured below are the editors of these journals. They also happen to have spent countless nights in the same room preparing for prelims nearly two decades ago. What a cohort!

Post attachment