
The Man-Not: Race, Class, Genre, and the Dilemmas of Black Manhood by Tommy J... amazon.com/dp/1439914869/ref… via @amazon

Personal Chair of Africana Philosophy & Black Male Studies, Multi-Award winning author, Editor of Black Male Studies series on Temple University Press

The Man-Not: Race, Class, Genre, and the Dilemmas of Black Manhood by Tommy J... amazon.com/dp/1439914869/ref… via @amazon

What shapes identity? For most Black adults, their mothers have had the largest influence on what it means to be a Black man or woman.

And this is what I said mobilized the term. Not the actual cause of death like a genocide where the dehumanization of a group leds to unfathomable amounts of violence but the ability to name all violence imposed upon BW femicide even when it is equal to or less than other groups.
So Black women don’t experience misogyny misogynoir transmisogyny or lesbophobia.

So you are interested in the very argument I introduced over a decade ago a/b racism decimating gender. Threadcraft does not reject gender & Douglass maintains gender as the basis of analyzing BMS. This just rhetoric.
That’s actually a fair question. I had a student ask me something similar when he challenged hooks description of the US as a white supremacist imperialist heteropatriarchal capitalist nation. He asked for an example and I used the Black maternal health crisis. This is what I said: Black women are structurally positioned by systems of domination. The history of gynecology is inseparable from the exploitation of enslaved Black women whose bodies were constructed as inherently violable and excluded from dominant notions of womanhood. We can trace that history through medical racism and beliefs about Black pain tolerance and the dismissal of Black people’s suffering. These histories, ideologies, and institutional practices operate together to produce conditions that contribute to Black women’s premature deaths today. Black men’s bodies have also been constructed as violable and their disproportionate deaths at the hands of police can also be understood as racial and gender specific violence. Threadcraft’s thesis is about political recognition and mobilization. I don’t think she’s interested in arguing about why you should believe that these killings and murders and deaths are misogynoristic or because of structural racism. And I don’t blame her. I’m more interested in Patrice Douglass’s argument that anti Blackness exceeds gender and produces and destabilizes gendered analysis and categories while still having to contend with their effects. I’m interested in how anti-Blackness operates on different bodies and how those violences are interpreted and politically recognized. That’s why I’m using the term Black femicide not because I think Black women have a monopoly on the experience of IPH. And it frustrates me when people decide that’s what Black femicide means.

How do you know the intent of the killer? So what you do is assert IPH is the killing of Black women b/c they are women hence femicide. That police killings of BW are because they are Black & women hence femicide. You see how this goes on & on...
It’s not any killing it’s only the misogynistic/misogynoiristic or ones that are facilitated by structural racism and other oppressive social conditions. Are we reading the same thing?

Right so BM who suffer higher IPH, child mortality, homicide, etc. is not sex specific or gender based even if it is higher than their female counterpart. I have read Threadcraft & find the claim unconvincing as she supposes BW are the primary victims of private deaths.
All men experience a higher incidence of homicide. By that logic, because men experience higher homicide rates than women, there would be no reason to study femicide or the particular circumstances under which women experience gender-related killings. And again as I said Black Femicide is not a 1-1 of femicide. So yes, I think we should address the premature death Black women face even if it Black men’s experience a higher incidence of homicide which should also be studied and addressed. And again Black femicide is more than intimate partner homicide. It’s also police murders. It’s also maternal death. I would read Shateema Thread craft. muse.jhu.edu/article/849906/… semanticscholar.org/paper/Bl… scholar.google.com/scholar?h… scholar.google.com/scholar?h… scholar.google.com/scholar?h…

And that would be ridiculous. SO you would claim that even if other groups experience order of magnitude differences in homicide...BW r victims of femicide by matter of definition even when they are less likely to be victims of homicide compared to other groups
Yes. They do. They show the disproportionate burden that Black women experience IPH. Femicide ≠ Black femicide Black Femicide is about the way BW experience homicide. They’ve never needed to experience it more than men or exclusively to understand the distinct qualities of Black women’s premature death in childbirth, IPH, police violence etc. I would suggest reading Shateema Threadcraft on the topic.

Lastly this is the moral panic arguments BMS scholars refer to. There is an assertion that a phenomenon exists. We disprove the claim & point out which datasets are used then ppl say the phenomenon that depends on the data exists despite no authors analyzing the data claiming so.

Second not a single author makes the claim that this is femicide. Why you ask? Because to make this claim you would need to compare BW to BM mortality rates. IPH is too prevalent among both groups to do this so they compare to white women.

So historically IPH has been disproportionate for both Black men and women. My research appearing in my forthcoming book documents this. amhis.substack.com/p/tommy-j… from 1976 forward.

Notice the strategy here. None of the peer reviewed studies summarized point to femicide. The facebook group is calling higher rates of IPH compared to white women femicide. This is so badly misinterpreted that it is laughable.
This tweet is unavailable

Moral panics are not facts. Not a single person has established a drfinition nor presented any mortality data showing that Black men are killing Black women based solely on their identites. No IPH data or general homicide data supports this claim.
This tweet is unavailable

I do not believe Black womwn are our enemy. I believe there are Black women that deliberately harm Black men just as there are Black men who harm Black women. It is not a group vs group issue.
Black women have always been your enemy

There are ethnographies describing Black women having sex with white men during Jim Crow & desiring white men. We need to look at history anew that looks at how Black people acted during segregation, not the romanticized stories offered by theory.
BLACK WOMEN were fucking WHITE KLANSMEN, giving them access to Black neighborhoods AND feeding them information about the community. These men would leave, go home to their white wives, then come BACK and burn those same neighborhoods down. This woman lived it. Watch this shit 👇🏿

I write about Mr. Banks in The Man-Not. This isnthe vulnerability Black males have to false accusation in the United States.
At 16, Brian Banks was one of the best high school linebackers in America. USC had offered him a full scholarship. Pete Carroll personally called him. One afternoon at school he made out with a classmate. Consensual. By the end of the day he was in jail, charged with kidnapping and rape. She said he dragged her into a stairwell. It never happened. The DNA came back negative. His mother sold her house and her car to pay for a lawyer. He couldn’t make bail. He spent a year behind bars waiting for trial. His lawyer told him: plead no contest, or risk 41 years in prison. He was 17. He took the deal. He did 5 years in prison. Then 5 more on parole. Registered sex offender. GPS monitor on his ankle. Couldn’t go near schools or parks. No one would hire him. Meanwhile, the girl and her mother sued the school district for not keeping her safe. They won $1.5 million. In 2011, a Facebook friend request popped up on his screen. It was her. She wanted to “let bygones be bygones.” Brian went to a private investigator. They hid cameras in the office and invited her to talk. She came by bus. On tape, she admitted it. He never raped her. He never kidnapped her. Then she said she still wouldn’t tell prosecutors the truth. Because she’d have to give back the money. In May 2012, a judge cleared his name. The hearing took less than a minute. 10 years of his life. Gone in one lie. Erased in 60 seconds. A few days later his phone rang. “I’m looking for a linebacker. You know where I can find one?” It was Pete Carroll. The same coach who recruited him 10 years earlier. He finally signed with the NFL’s Atlanta Falcons. At 27. The dream he had at 16. She was ordered to pay $2.6 million back. What should happen to someone who steals 10 years of your life with one lie?

To think, these men sacrificed their lives for a chance at Black liberation just for feminists and today’s activist, podcaster, and pundit class to generalize them as rapists, patriarchs and abusers smh. Why would Black men sacrifice themselves again knowing that’s what’s on the other end of it?
Clinched fist salute to all #BlackPantherParty Veterans who gave their life in service of the People! #BPP60