
🚨 Mauricio Pochettino failed at Chelsea because he changed tactics too often. Some weeks it was good, some weeks it was bad. He found a clear and successful game-model towards the end of his time at the club, but it was too little too late. For him to succeed at Manchester United, he must implement a top game-model and stick to it. If he doesn't, the team will flatter to deceive, both on the pitch and in the transfer market. Some weeks he will get the tactical balance right. Some weeks he will get it wrong. Plus, in the transfer market, there will be a lack of clarity in signing specific profiles the team needs to improve. People talk about the lack of expenditure at Spurs hampering his project, and they're right, but he was given a lot of money at Chelsea which was not used wisely. Pochettino will be loved by players and fans + he will be able to handle the scrutiny at Manchester United, but this was the case at Chelsea and he failed. Ultimately, the success of the project comes down to his ability to find a top game-model, stick to it, and build around it. Will he do that? If his time at Chelsea is anything to go by, then the answer is no. But, with the USA, the game-model and tactical clarity was more consistent. Was it elite? Not quite, but it had balance, it was decent tactically, and with a good enough set of players who perform reliably it can supersede any tactical faults. The goal? Implement that model at United, stick to it in upwards of 90% of games, and build around it in the market; if he does that then why can't he succeed, even if history suggests that he won't because of what happened at Chelsea. Let's see. Only time will tell. In the short-term, I will be a lot more tolerable of systematic changes to reduce games to fine margins. I even expect him to use a back 5 at times because of the lack of trust he will have in his central defensive options due to their lack of athleticism/quality. In the long-run, though, that will not be acceptable. He must increase the margins, not reduce them. I go back to it… long-term, Pochettino needs to pick a specific, high quality tactic and build around it. Even if it is not completely bulletproof tactically, which I don’t expect it to be because I have never seen him implement a completely flawless tactical system, it COULD still result in Manchester United winning major titles IF the system is top AND the player quality, balance, and depth is elite. This is feasible if the recruitment and squad building is top. But this is what I demanded from him at Chelsea and he didn't deliver. In fact, it was really quite awful for much of his tenure. It only became 'top' towards the end of the season, but much of the damage was already done at that point season outcome-wise. Football has changed a lot since his Southampton and Spurs days + his PSG team were a unique case because of the presence of Messi, Neymar, and Mbappe, so all competent analysis should focus heavily on his time at Chelsea and with the USA. Do those tenures lean more towards success or failure? The Chelsea experience is more negative than positive, even if Pochettino showed that he has evolved tactically relative to the modern game towards the end of his tenure. The USA tenure is more niche because of the unique ecosystem that they exist in, although their World Cup campaign was encouraging, albeit short. Ultimately, Manchester United and INEOS have hired a coach where there is quite a few question marks around him. It was bad more often than it was good at Chelsea, so the harsh reality is he will have to have improved and learnt from that failure to succeed at United. Suggesting that he will succeed would be based on nothing other than illogical hope because history suggests that he will be too flexible tactically and that he will ultimately fail as a consequence of it. However, that assumption would suggest that the future always behaves like the past, but that is not true because people often learn, evolve and grow as they gain new experiences (see Eddie Howe at Bournemouth vs Newcastle). Will Pochettino have learnt enough in that time to succeed at Manchester United? Only time will tell. This is the situation in full. Let's see how it plays out, but I will admit that I am rooting for him because of who he is as a bloke. He is widely adored for good reason. I hope it works out 🤞



















