←
Darren Smyth8,861 posts
Darren Smyth avatar

Darren Smyth

@EIP_Knowledge

Head of Knowledge at EIP, chemistry specialist patent attorney. Committee Member @ip_out 🏳️‍🌈Blogs at ipalchemist.com He/him

◷ Joined July 2011▧ 242 Photos and videos
Darren Smyth avatar
Darren Smyth@EIP_Knowledge·8 Dec 2022

So, I have changed my Twitter handle because I have a new role at EIP - Head of Knowledge. This means (amongs other things) that I lead our preparations for legal changes and developments. At the moment, that is mainly the Unitary Patent and Unified Patent Court!

Darren Smyth avatar
Darren Smyth@EIP_Knowledge·7 Feb 2025

The avalanche transceiver dispute at the UPC reaches its next stage, with the patentee now having prevailed in the action on the merits (after obtaining a provisional injunction).

EIP@EIP7 Feb 2025

After securing an ex parte provisional injunction (which was upheld on review and appeal), Ortovox have now prevailed in the action on the merits in their case against Mammut, relating to avalanche transceivers. Isabelle Schaller reports - eip.com/uk/latest/article/or…

Post attachment
Darren Smyth avatar
Darren Smyth@EIP_Knowledge·5 Feb 2025

The UPC doing their best to make patents enforceable despite difficulties in service in China. Two interesting decisions by default relating to provisional injunctions.

EIP@EIP5 Feb 2025

The UPC grants two provisional injunctions in decisions by default. No response was received from the Chinese defendant. Service of both the applications for provisional injunctions and the orders themselves took place by publication on the UPC website, after service through Chinese judicial authorities failed. @EIP_Knowledge reports - eip.com/uk/latest/article/de…

Post attachment
Darren Smyth avatar
Darren Smyth@EIP_Knowledge·4 Feb 2025

The UPC has considered infringement by equivalents a few times. Here, it declined to opine on a specific test, noting that any test requires functional equivalence as a prerequisite, which was lacking in the case.

EIP@EIP4 Feb 2025

A further decision from the UPC involving assessment of infringement by equivalent means finds functional equivalence lacking, and so declines to elucidate a full test. @EIP_Knowledge reports - eip.com/uk/latest/article/in…

Post attachment
Darren Smyth avatar
Darren Smyth@EIP_Knowledge·4 Feb 2025

Attempts to set aside a decision by default failed. The original failure to meet the defence deadline is confirmed as fatal by the court (although still subject to appeal).

EIP@EIP4 Feb 2025

The UPC confirms that having been refused an extension for filing a defence leading to a decision by default, a party cannot set aside the decision by default unless it can show justifiable reasons for missing the deadline. This case confirms again the importance of compliance with UPC deadlines, which are hard to extend. @EIP_Knowledge reports - eip.com/uk/latest/article/up…

Post attachment
Darren Smyth avatar
Darren Smyth@EIP_Knowledge·31 Jan 2025

I argue that the UPC ruling that is has jurisdiction over the UK part of a European patent to consider infringement is a conventional reading of the Brussels Ibis Regulation - German court has jurisdiction over German defendants is a less controversial reading of the case.

EIP@EIP31 Jan 2025

The UPC has ruled that it has jurisdiction to decide infringement for the UK part of a European patent, when the defendants are based in UPC territory. @EIP_Knowledge argues that this follows a conventional understanding of the jurisdiction rules - eip.com/uk/latest/article/up…

Post attachment
Darren Smyth avatar
Darren Smyth@EIP_Knowledge·30 Jan 2025

Here, the UPC elects to extend a period for one of the defendants, rather than order a stay, in view of upcoming EPO appeal hearing.

EIP@EIP30 Jan 2025

Milan Local Division grants extension of time period for filing statement of defence due to imminent EPO appeal hearing in parallel proceedings. Stuart McKellar reports - eip.com/uk/latest/article/ex…

Post attachment
Darren Smyth avatar
Darren Smyth@EIP_Knowledge·29 Jan 2025

For at least the second time, the UPC Court of Appeal has reversed a first instance decision that I thought was clearly correct. I had better stop predicting.

EIP@EIP29 Jan 2025

The UPC Court of Appeal has controversially ruled that the UPC does have jurisdiction to determine damages after a decision from a national court on infringement. @EIP_Knowledge looks at this surprising decision - eip.com/uk/latest/article/up…

Post attachment
Darren Smyth avatar
Darren Smyth@EIP_Knowledge·27 Jan 2025

Provisional injunction on hand held vacuum cleaners overturned on appeal as CoA was not convinced the accused products worked as the patent claim requires.

EIP@EIP27 Jan 2025

Dyson's provisional injunction against SharkNinja relating to hand-held vacuum cleaners was overturned on appeal. Harry Radford reports - eip.com/uk/latest/article/up…

Post attachment
EIP avatar
⟳ Darren Smyth retweeted
EIP@EIP·24 Jan 2025

Having prevailed at the central division with the patent maintained in amended form, Edwards is also successful at the Munich local division in asserting its patent on prosthetic heart valves against Meril. Monika Rai reports - eip.com/uk/latest/article/ed…

Post attachment
Darren Smyth avatar
Darren Smyth@EIP_Knowledge·24 Jan 2025

This is the second DexCom case at the Paris Local Division to be decided purely on the issue of the validity of the patent. (The first case was one of the very first UPC decisions on the merits).

EIP@EIP23 Jan 2025

The Paris Local Division has revoked a further DexCom patent on the ground of lack of inventive step. As in an earlier decision by the same division and similar parties relating to a different patent, in view of the finding of invalidity, infringement was not considered. Read the report here - eip.com/uk/latest/article/pa…

Post attachment
EIP avatar
⟳ Darren Smyth retweeted
EIP@EIP·22 Jan 2025

The UPC has confirmed that breach of a standstill agreement between the parties does not deprive the Court of jurisdiction, nor does it render an action inadmissible. It can only give rise to liability for breach of contract. @EIP_Knowledge reports - eip.com/uk/latest/article/br…

Post attachment
Darren Smyth avatar
Darren Smyth@EIP_Knowledge·22 Jan 2025

This is an interesting little judgment clarifying what a patentee must do after securing a provisional injunction by the mandatory deadline in order for the injunction not to be revoked.

EIP@EIP22 Jan 2025

After being granted a provisional injunction, a patentee has to start an action on the merits within a specified time, or the injunction will lapse. Here, the UPC clarifies that it is only necessary to file a Statement of Claim through the CMS by the deadline; it is not necessary for the court fee to have been received by the court within the time period. @EIP_Knowledge reports - eip.com/uk/latest/article/in…

Post attachment
Darren Smyth avatar
Darren Smyth@EIP_Knowledge·21 Jan 2025

This is a really interesting decision from the UPC finding infringement by equivalent means, and suggesting a 4 stage test by which equivalents should be assessed. We shall see if it is adopted more widely.

EIP@EIP21 Jan 2025

The UPC local division in The Hague finds a patent infringed by equivalence and suggests a test by which equivalence should be assessed at the UPC. @EIP_Knowledge reports - eip.com/uk/latest/article/up…

Post attachment
Darren Smyth avatar
Darren Smyth@EIP_Knowledge·21 Jan 2025

Insulet fails in two actions for provisional injunctions against EOFLOW and Menarini, respectively. Menarini in turn had failed to get the actions joined, or to intervene in the other case.

EIP@EIP21 Jan 2025

Insulet fails in provisional injunction applications against EOFLOW and Menarini, mainly due to doubts about the validity of the patent. Nunzio Pucci reports - eip.com/uk/latest/article/up…

Post attachment