←
Andrew Whitby14,001 posts
Andrew Whitby avatar

Andrew Whitby

@EconAndrew

Data scientist, author THE SUM OF THE PEOPLE. Prev. @worldbank, @nesta_uk, @UniOfOxford. I'm interested in things.

◷ Joined September 2012▧ 1,458 Photos and videos
Andrew Whitby avatar
Andrew Whitby@EconAndrew·Nov 13

I just realized I had the melody of “I left my heart in San Francisco” totally wrong, because in my head I was singing it to “San Francisco (Flowers in your Hair).” I am now aware of this decades-old error, but I *cannot* hold the less catchy correct melody in my head.

Andrew Whitby avatar
Andrew Whitby@EconAndrew·Nov 11

(Caveat: All of this is said as someone who considers himself proverbially EA-adjacent at best, and is not in the forums, where I’m sure all these arguments have been pored over with far more rigor than I have done.)

Andrew Whitby avatar
Andrew Whitby@EconAndrew·Nov 11

If you allow this kind of reasoning, i worry I can justify giving to the Met or Harvard (the very kind of giving EA stood against), because if the next Elon has more historical and cultural awareness he won’t dismantle USAID2, and that has a bigger impact than all the bednets.

Andrew Whitby avatar
Andrew Whitby@EconAndrew·Nov 11

More broadly, it’s hard to see how this flavor of EA is all that different from the Gates or even Ford foundations before it. It’s fine, but it’s definitely not EA-circa-2015.

Andrew Whitby avatar
Andrew Whitby@EconAndrew·Nov 11

You can argue (as @JustinSandefur did, frequently, at the time) that the World Bank was a particularly ineffective institution, but then any other growth-promoting institution has to show why it will be different.

Andrew Whitby avatar
Andrew Whitby@EconAndrew·Nov 11

Today EA is willing to embrace long, tenuous causal chains. Maybe it started with longtermism, but it also seems a consequence of the large pots of institutional money now behind it. “Your $ funded 3 conference attendees” appeals more to an institution than an individual giver.

Andrew Whitby avatar
Andrew Whitby@EconAndrew·Nov 11

Certainly EA missed impactful inventions just because they weren’t easily measured. Tractability was a virtue and a flaw. But it seems core to the philosophy.

Andrew Whitby avatar
Andrew Whitby@EconAndrew·Nov 11

Part of the early appeal of EA, I think, was quite direct interventions. “Your bednets save X lives.” Maybe that was just a dressed-up version of giving an Oxfam goat. Maybe interventions only worked on the margin, and were easily saturated.

Andrew Whitby avatar
Andrew Whitby@EconAndrew·Nov 11

FWIW I did my main bednet giving when I worked at the World Bank, which amongst the mess, is pretty focused on growth. The giving was partly diversifying away from (penance for!) my day job, but also reflected frustration with the long causal chain from my job to doing good.

Characteristically great Kelsey reply. But on this: “I agree it would be cool if there were an organization focused on effective institutional capacity building in poor countries, but the reason I and man others don't donate to this is not that everyone fails to realize how important institutions are, it's that even though many people have worked very hard on the problem for a long time they do not have a way better than the nets to turn my money into GDP growth in poor countries.” May I introduce our Global Growth Fund led by @JustinSandefur? coefficientgiving.org/funds/… Before we launched this I had some of Kelsey’s skepticism about tractability here. This thread talks about how I changed my mind: x.com/albrgr/status/18466225…

Andrew Whitby avatar
Andrew Whitby@EconAndrew·Nov 7

California’s @CA_DMV digital drivers license is such state capacity failure. 3 years in and you can’t use it to drive (legally) or buy alcohol (functionally).

Andrew Whitby avatar
Andrew Whitby@EconAndrew·Oct 23

The last decade must have been a weird time to be Armando Iannucci.

Pete Hegseth reportedly wanted Dwight Eisenhower's globe in his office, but did not want to wait for historians to move it and went rogue. Hegseth's staff then attempted to move it themselves and broke the historic globe.

Post attachmentPost attachment
Andrew Whitby avatar
Andrew Whitby@EconAndrew·Oct 21

Moreover I think prop 40 will fail, and may well shift the Overton window in the opposite direction.

Andrew Whitby avatar
Andrew Whitby@EconAndrew·Oct 21

My strongest objection to prop 40, I think, is it feels - unfortunately! - like an economist’s experiment rather than a serious policy. And this take represents that. It feels like Zucman is pointing at some optimising agent model, and - gotcha! But of course both can be true.

Now, the crucial flaw is that Jaros and @joshrauh simply ignore this. They assume that billionaires will leave permanently, frightened by the prospects of an annual wealth tax. But they just count the revenue from the one-time wealth tax. Not the revenue from the annual tax. The annual tax that triggered the “exodus” Jaros and @joshrauh imagine never materializes. The billionaires upended their lives for nothing.

Andrew Whitby avatar
Andrew Whitby@EconAndrew·Oct 16

Europe, famously known for never having produced an impractical super car.

It is. The US increasingly epitomises hyper-capitalist showmanship: a circus of clowns selling spectacle as innovation, with little added value to humanity. Europe still has a sense of class: engineering with purpose, creating things people actually want, need and can use. Spectacle vs substance