←
Kim Eggleton6,167 posts
Kim Eggleton avatar

Kim Eggleton

@EggletonKim

Twin mum into #publishing, #equality, and #dessert. At @ioppublishing working on #peerreview #integrity #inclusivity #ethics, she/her, all opinions my own.

◷ Joined September 2011▧ 454 Photos and videos
Kim Eggleton avatar
Kim Eggleton@EggletonKim·25 Mar 2022

AND an improvement in integrity education, and the main one - a change in the incentive structure within academia. As long as we equate citations with “quality”, there will be publication manipulation. Here endeth the lesson.

Nick Mark MD avatar
⟳ Kim Eggleton retweeted
Nick Mark MD@nickmmark·22 Jan 2025

🚨Apparently all NIH Study Sections have been suspended indefinitely. For those who don’t know, this means there won’t be any review of grants submitted to NIH Depending on how long this goes on for, this could lead to an interruption in billions in research funding.

Kim Eggleton avatar
Kim Eggleton@EggletonKim·13 Jan 2025

I hope this doesn't come across as a whine, we have come SO FAR in the last couple of years, but there is still such a long way to go, and despite our best efforts, fraud (or at least attempted fraud) feels to be on the increase.

Opinion: Publishers need more help to combat malicious academic networks Better tech alignment, industry guidance and identity verification would all help – as would meaningful and visible punishments, says Kim Eggleton ow.ly/2xOO50UEoB1

Post attachment
Kim Eggleton avatar
Kim Eggleton@EggletonKim·15 Nov 2024

Excited to be speaking at this event on Thursday 21st on how to handle suspected cases of paper mills. It will be super interactive and will test your brain! #ResearchIntegrity #papermills

📢 MORE SPACES AVAILABLE PUBLICATION INTEGRITY WEEK 2024 Due to the popularity of the Paper Mills and Working Together days we have increased the number of spaces available. Find out more! publicationethics.org/events… #PublicationIntegrityWeek #ResearchIntegrity #PublicationEthics

0:16
Kim Eggleton avatar
Kim Eggleton@EggletonKim·24 Sep 2024

Other things we've introduced include: - anonymous peer review - publication of reviews with the article - reviewer feedback programme - co-review - free, detailed reviewer training As Publishers and Editors we have a responsibility.

Kim Eggleton avatar
Kim Eggleton@EggletonKim·24 Sep 2024

At @ioppublishing we're working hard to make bad-mannered reviews a thing of the past. Among other things), we have dedicated, internal Editors who screen out problematic comments BEFORE they get to authors #PeerReviewWeek #PeerReviewWeek24 nature.com/articles/d41586-0…

Kim Eggleton avatar
Kim Eggleton@EggletonKim·23 Sep 2024

some compassion to peer review. The most helpful reviews are not those that say yes, but those that constructively engage with the work. We help reviewers make the right kind of impact on a paper, because behind every paper is a person nature.com/articles/d41586-0… #PeerReviewWeek 2/2

Kim Eggleton avatar
Kim Eggleton@EggletonKim·23 Sep 2024

Sadly there are times when a reviewer report crosses my desk and I’m struck by the thoughtlessness of how things are phrased. We’ve all had negative feedback but there’s a way to position things without tearing someone down. I’m super proud of @IOPPublishing’s work to bring 1/2

Jimmy Koppel avatar
⟳ Kim Eggleton retweeted
Jimmy Koppel@jimmykoppel·26 Aug 2024

Everyone's talking about Sakana's AI scientist. But no-one's answering the big question: is its output good? I spent hours reading its generated papers and research logs. Read on to find out

Introducing The AI Scientist: The world’s first AI system for automating scientific research and open-ended discovery! sakana.ai/ai-scientist/ From ideation, writing code, running experiments and summarizing results, to writing entire papers and conducting peer-review, The AI Scientist opens a new era of AI-driven scientific research and accelerated discovery. Here are 4 example Machine Learning research papers generated by The AI Scientist. We published our report, The AI Scientist: Towards Fully Automated Open-Ended Scientific Discovery, and open-sourced our project! Paper: arxiv.org/abs/2408.06292 GitHub: github.com/SakanaAI/AI-Scien… Our system leverages LLMs to propose and implement new research directions. Here, we first apply The AI Scientist to conduct Machine Learning research. Crucially, our system is capable of executing the entire ML research lifecycle: from inventing research ideas and experiments, writing code, to executing experiments on GPUs and gathering results. It can also write an entire scientific paper, explaining, visualizing and contextualizing the results. Furthermore, while an LLM author writes entire research papers, another LLM reviewer critiques resulting manuscripts to provide feedback to improve the work, and also to select the most promising ideas to further develop in the next iteration cycle, leading to continual, open-ended discoveries, thus emulating the human scientific community. As a proof of concept, our system produced papers with novel contributions in ML research domains such language modeling, Diffusion and Grokking. We (@_chris_lu_, @RobertTLange, @hardmaru) proudly collaborated with the @UniOfOxford (@j_foerst, @FLAIR_Ox) and @UBC (@cong_ml, @jeffclune) on this exciting project.

Post attachmentPost attachmentPost attachmentPost attachment
Retraction Watch avatar
⟳ Kim Eggleton retweeted
Retraction Watch@RetractionWatch·27 Aug 2024

Exclusive: Thousands of papers misidentify microscopes, in possible sign of misconduct retractionwatch.com/2024/08/…