Being an investor means owning a business and participating in everything that business creates: its earnings, its cash flows, its growth.
Being a speculator means chasing prices and hoping the market cooperates.
Ben Graham said it best:
“A stock is not just a ticker symbol or an electronic blip; it is an ownership interest in an actual business, with an underlying value that does not depend on its share price.”
When you buy a good business at a good value, you are not just buying a stock. You are buying the right to participate in the growth of the business itself.
If you overpay, the math works against you. You now need the business to grow faster than expected, or you are relying on someone else to bail you out at a higher price.
When you purchase a business at a great value and you can sleep well at night because your focus is on the strength of the business itself.
Speculate on prices and you will lose your mind watching a stock quote that changes every second of every trading day.
Be the investor. Not the speculator.
#investing
Is Lam Research $LRCX attractively valued today? Chuck Carnevale takes a closer look at its fundamentals and valuation using FAST Graphs.
#Investing#StockAnalysis#FASTGraphs
Is Cummins $CMI attractively valued today? Chuck Carnevale takes a closer look at its fundamentals and valuation using FAST Graphs.
#Investing#StockAnalysis#FASTGraphs
Is Caterpillar (CAT) Overvalued?
Chuck Carnevale examines Caterpillar's earnings, historical valuation, and current stock price using FAST Graphs.
Is CAT trading above its fair value?
Watch the analysis!
#Caterpillar#CAT#FASTGraphs#StockAnalysis#ValueInvesting
Great investors learn from the past—but invest in the future.
Chuck Carnevale examines 6 stocks to show why historical earnings, fair value, and future growth expectations matter when making investment decisions.
#FASTGraphs#ValueInvesting
ARE WE IN A DOT-COM BUBBLE AGAIN?
Today we're looking back at $CSCO in 2000 and comparing it to $NVDA today to see if the AI trade is 2000 all over again.
WHAT 2000 TAUGHT US:
Cisco closed at a record $80.06 on March 27, 2000, at well over 100 times earnings. Over the next 25 years, it grew earnings roughly tenfold, started paying a dividend and bought back a large share of its stock. The stock did not close above the 2000 high until 2025.
At 100x earnings, 20 years of results were already baked into the price. Over the short term, excitement and pessimism drive prices to extremes. Over the long term, earnings and cash flow drive prices.
The second lesson from 2000 gets less attention. Cisco's customers were carriers that borrowed to build networks for demand that had not arrived yet, and many double-ordered equipment. When the financing stopped in 2001, the orders stopped. Cisco wrote off more than $2 billion of inventory, reported a loss, and watched revenue fall. The 100x multiple was the first problem. Estimates that assumed debt-financed customers would keep spending were the second.
CISCO TODAY (from @FASTGraphs):
Price: $93.85
Blended P/E: 20.70x
Normal P/E: 14.98x
FG Score: 72 (Growth 39, Predictability 88)
Dividend yield: 1.79%, raised every year since 2012
Since 2006 the price is up 444% and earnings 352%. The 20-year return is 7.87% a year against 9.37% for SPY, because the window opens with the stock still recovering from the crash at about 17 times earnings.
Then 2026 happened. AI infrastructure orders from hyperscalers hit $9.3 billion in fiscal 2026, and the stock rose about 60% to a record near $130, roughly 30 times the $4.33 it earned that year and double its Normal P/E. It fell 7% after the August report on gross margin and 7% more last Thursday on a Morgan Stanley downgrade. It is now 28% below the high and still at 20.70x. Analysts expect 17.55% growth this year and about 8% a year after that, and 8% growth is what earned Cisco a 14.98x P/E, not 30x.
Forecasting tab: at the 5-year normal of 15.49x on the 2029 estimate of $5.97, the stock price would be $92.39, below today's price. At 18x, it would trade at $107.46. At today's 20.70x it would be $123.58.
NVIDIA TODAY (from @FASTGraphs):
Price: around $186
Blended P/E: 22.76x
FG Score breakdown: Growth 99, Profitability 97, Financial Strength 98, Cash Flow Generation 91, Predictability 5
Since 2006, earnings are up 56,775% and the price 50,779%. Earnings outran price, so the multiple contracted. The 20-year return is 33.73% a year against 9.37% for SPY. Over the last 12 months, the stock returned -0.49% vs. 10.83% for the index, while earnings nearly doubled, meaning the multiple roughly halved.
July quarter: revenue $96.22 billion, gross margin 75.0%, operating margin 66.24%, return on equity 112.50%, long-term debt to capital 13.95%. About $26 billion was returned to shareholders in the quarter.
Two cautions. Operating cash flow was $24.08 billion against $59.69 billion of net income, down from $50.34 billion the quarter before. And Predictability of 5 reflects an earnings record with real down years, 2019 and 2022 among them. The balance sheet is a fortress. The earnings stream, historically, has not been.
Forecasting tab: the 5-year normal of 48.69x on the 2029 estimate of $21.51 produces $1,046.97 and a 116% annual return, which is a little bit shocking. At 15x it is $322.65. At 20x, it is $430.20. The stock trades at 11.8 times the 2028 estimate, so the market is discounting those results rather than paying a premium for them.
If fiscal 2028 earnings stall at fiscal 2027's $9.26, 15x is $138.90, a 26% loss, and 20x is $185.20, flat. That is the 2001 scenario: multiple compression plus an earnings stall.
THE CATCH:
Both companies sell into the same buildout: Cisco with $9.3 billion of AI orders and a $7.5 billion target for fiscal 2027, Nvidia with $89 billion of data center revenue in a single quarter. Some of the customers are financing it the way the carriers did. Oracle reported negative free cash flow of $5 billion in its August quarter, sold $20 billion of stock and plans to raise $45 billion to $50 billion this year for data centers. Nvidia's estimates, 94% growth this year and 71% next, need that spending to continue. So does Cisco's $7.5 billion.
Neither stock trades anywhere near 100 times earnings. At today's prices, the current P/E is not the 2000 risk. The future "E" is.
Cisco reports Thursday. Check product orders against last quarter's 35% growth, AI orders against $4 billion and gross margin against 66.3%.
Nvidia reports November 17. Check revenue against the $108 billion guide, then operating cash flow against net income.
Is American Express (AXP) Stock Fairly Valued?
Chuck Carnevale takes a closer look at American Express using FAST Graphs, examining earnings, historical performance, and stock valuation.
$AXP#FASTGraphs#AmericanExpress#StockAnalysis
Is Honeywell (HON) Stock Fairly Valued?
Chuck Carnevale examines Honeywell's earnings, valuation, and historical performance using FAST Graphs.
Is HON a buying opportunity or currently overvalued?
$HON#FASTGraphs#Honeywell#StockAnalysis#ValueInvesting
$NVR went bankrupt in 1992, but it's up 800% since 2006, and you've probably never heard of it.
EPS crashed 81% from the 2006 peak to the 2008 low. Then grew 1400% from 2011 to 2024.
They don't hold earnings calls, don't give guidance, and only six analysts cover the stock.
VALUATION (from @FASTGraphs):
Blended P/E: 18x
Normal P/E: 17x
Fair Value P/E: 15x
EPS yield: 5.54%
FG Score: 66 (Predictability 79, Financial Strength 77, Growth 46)
Dividend: none
Over 20 years, NVR compounded at 13% a year vs 10% for the S&P 500. Over the last year, it's down 11% vs. +15% for the S&P 500.
THE BUSINESS:
NVR is the fourth-largest homebuilder in the country by closings, selling under the Ryan Homes, NVHomes, and Heartland Homes names in 37 metro areas across 16 states. What makes it different is what it refuses to own: land.
Most builders buy raw land, develop it, and carry it on the balance sheet for years before building a house.
NVR takes a different approach. They sign option agreements with developers for finished lots, put down a deposit that typically runs up to 10% of the lot price, and buy each lot one at a time after they've sold a home to be built on it. If a community stops working, they walk away, and the deposit is the entire loss.
At the end of September, they controlled about 185,300 lots with $917 million of deposits, and wrote off $24.8 million of them in the third quarter, which is the model doing exactly what it was designed to do. Mitigate risk.
NVR builds to order from a model home instead of building spec inventory, makes the wall panels and roof trusses in their own plants, and provides the mortgage for 86% of its buyers.
Their model was written in bankruptcy court. In the late 1980s NVR was a land developer running on borrowed money, with a savings and loan attached. It lost $260.5 million in 1990 and filed Chapter 11 in April 1992. The company that came out in 1993, with bondholders owning 91% of it, has reported a profit in every year on the FAST Graph, including 2008, 2009 and 2010, when D.R. Horton and Lennar each lost money three years in a row.
THE FUNDAMENTALS (FY 2025):
• Revenue: $10.10B
• Net income: $1.34B
• Operating margin: 14.32%
• Return on equity: 34.29%
• Return on invested capital: 22.84%
• LT debt/capital: 21.41%
• Operating cash flow: $1.12B
• Investing cash flow: -$71M
• Financing cash flow: -$1.76B
Nearly every dollar of cash flow goes to buybacks. Since 2006, net income is up 128%, but EPS is up 396% because the diluted share count went from 6.67 million to about 3.1 million.
EPS HISTORY:
2006: $88.05
2008: $17.04
2011: $23.01
2016: $103.61
2020: $230.11
2024: $506.69
2025: $436.55
2026E: $337.72
THE CATCH:
Housing is in its worst stretch in over a decade. Builder confidence is 29, the lowest since 2012; the 30-year mortgage is above 7%, and 43% of builders are cutting prices. NVR's Q3 orders were down 7%, cancellations were up to 21%, gross margin dropped to 18.3% from 21.0% and Analysts have FY 2026 EPS down 23%.
The stock currently trades at a blended P/E of 18.06x, which is above the 17.64x Normal P/E. A cyclical's P/E looks lowest at the top (about 8x in 2006) and highest at the bottom (20x+ in 2011), so 18x on trough-year earnings could indicate the stock is undervalued but investors buying today are betting on a turnaround in housing which is hard to time.
Is $NVR on your watchlist or are you putting it in the "too-hard" pile?