
This does not auger well for the pending motion for acquittal.
This tweet is unavailable

Crypto lawyer, but not your lawyer. Former AscendEX/ Paxful/SEC / Tweets are mine, not legal advice, etc.

This does not auger well for the pending motion for acquittal.
This tweet is unavailable

11. To be abundantly clear, the way this complaint was filed was the only (IMO slim) chance to ever get the relief sought. Events just moved against plaintiff in a way not expected under the Biden admin in charge when filed.

10. It counters 2 general rules of appeals courts: (a) don’t decide issues in the first instance that were not decided at the district court level and (b) don’t decide cases on “how they should have been brought” and hold parties to the strategic choices they made in the DCT.

9. Effectively asking an appeals court to rule not only on an issue which was not decided in the district court, but also one that the appellant specifically disclaimed in his pleadings as an issue (and one he was NOT asking the court to decide) is a tough ask.

8. That makes for a really tough appellate pivot. The argument now has shifted to “we need a get out of jail free card for b1C because even if we knowingly launder criminal funds b1C cannot be applied to non-custodial devs.”

7. The district court used the Blanche memo to say no legitimate fear under 1960(b)(1)(B) and noted that 1960(b)(1)(C) was inapplicable because Lewellen expressly said he would never violate it.

6. When the Blanche memo came out, it undercut any argument that there was a legitimate fear of immediate prosecution under 1960(b)(1)(B).

5. It might give me that relief for failure to register my car if I can show that there is something about my car (an immutable characteristic) that renders my car outside of the current registration requirements.

4. Part of the reason is that a court is never going to give declaratory relief on future uncertain events. A court will not give me an eternal “get out of jail free” card for speeding merely because I say I will never break the speed limit.

3. He effectively disclaimed any request to seek relief against prosecution under 1960(b)(1)(C) by alleging that he would never knowingly transmit criminal funds (an element of 1960b1C but not b1B).

2. At the time the complaint was filed, there was a strategic decision to seek relief solely under 1960(b)(1)(B) – the federal regis reqmt. He asked for an order stating that he was not required to register federally because he would never take custody or exercise control.

1. The problem with putting the eggs in the Lewellen basket is that the litigation is an INCREDIBLY poor vehicle for getting any clarity on 1960(b)(1)(C).
You know you have been waiting for our take... Disappointing to see the BRCA protections limited. Still helpful to codify the regulatory protections for developers, but the lack of criminal law protections means @LewellenMichael's case against DOJ becomes even more important. coincenter.org/the-proposed-…

Watching the CFTC go above & beyond to protect its PM jdxn bring back painful memories of early e-cig days. Flaming Dragon got better treatment from Les Grossman than we did calling the FDA and saying "states are picking on us."

Would also seem to preclude CFTC from ever taking any emergency enforcement action against any PM. If a PM is violating enuf rules & threatening consumer protection, how can CFTC seek its own emergency relief against the PM (say FTX)? Won't that action cause an emergency?

One of the interesting rationales provided by the CFTC in the Kalshi order for why emergency relief is appropriate is that a sudden shuttering will cause market disruption as traders move to other prediction markets. Does that mean Kalshi is TBTF in CFTC eyes?

See #10. I think it's bat s&$# crazy. I also think the politicians know that. But bc I'm part of the last gen to grow up on School House Rock, I think the fig leaf might be just thick enough so it suffices as a public excuse for a no vote w/o consequences.