←
Aidan Morrison4,442 posts
Aidan Morrison avatar

Aidan Morrison

@FootnotesGuy

Researching energy and defence. Physics and data science background. Happy getting into the weeds.

◷ Joined March 2025▧ 2,061 Photos and videos
Aidan Morrison avatar
Aidan Morrison@FootnotesGuy·29 Jul 2025

This is the story of how a fund chaired by former Labor PM Julia Gillard acquired a wind farm project just six days before Labor Energy Minister Chris Bowen underwrote its future revenues with taxpayer money. Today we've learned Julia's fund is trying to flip it. For a profit. HMC Capital's 'Energy Transition Fund' rushed to acquire the Neoen Victoria portfolio. They hadn't even raised any money in their fund. They closed with almost a billion dollars worth of borrowed money and IOU's. Less than a week later, Chris Bowen announced Kentbruck Wind Farm to be successful in the first round of the Capacity Investment Scheme. My rough calculations suggest they will receive something like a billion dollars from taxpayers (and maybe much more) over 15 years. Sweet deal. A billion dollars of fancy financial monopoly money one week. A billion dollars of promised taxpayer dollars the next. I want to emphasise that I have no evidence of anything illegal or improper taking place. Rather, I want to point out how odious and repugnant the official, proper, legal business of renewable energy has become. Yesterday Chris Bowen announced he wanted to supersize the CIS subsidy scheme, yet again. Today Ross Garnaut seemed to cheer this on, whilst pointing out "There are now virtually no new investment commitments for solar and wind generation that do not have CIS or other Government underwriting," What happened to a sense of propriety? Since when do we celebrate people rushing to put their snouts in the trough? Or rushing to fill the trough even higher? Unlike the UK who publish a 'going rate' for technology subsidies, our renewables are subsidised through a secret tender process. Every project gets to ask for whatever revenue they want to proceed. @AEMO_Energy facilitates a secret beauty pageant, where they award points for things like indigenous participation or community engagement, alongside financial value. And Chris Bowen makes the final call. The bids remain secret. There's no cap to the pay-outs. Since AEMO is a private company, there is no scope for an FOI request, and AEMO aren't not subject to parliamentary oversight through Senate Estimates. So no-one can ever prove an allegation that Bowen has bestowed special favour on a friend's project if that was what he did. But equally, he can never prove that he selected strictly according to merit. We are just expected to trust the black-box of Bowen's subsidies. So I'm going to say out loud, with full voice, that I hope everyone can agree on: If this is what the future of 'clean energy' looks like in Australia, it looks absolutely FILTHY. Any firm that talks about ESG seriously should start taking the "G" a bit more seriously and steer clear of projects that thrust their snouts into Bowen's hopelessly opaque, bottomless trough of government funds. Or at the very least, purge their boards and senior leadership of all the former Labor staffers, donors, and industry lobbyists who have had a hand in designing the trough, and filling it up. The reality is that there are no natural profits to be made in generating renewable electricity in Australia. Every dollar of profit in this industry is really a cheque signed by a politician, with Chris Bowen signing all the biggest cheques, worth untold billions, in the next three years. It's all legal. It's all official. And it's absolutely obscene. Mega-thread below. (It'll come in stages) 1/

Post attachment
Aidan Morrison avatar
Aidan Morrison@FootnotesGuy·12h

Heck, let’s fight fire with fire. Here’s my completely unhinged rant and ramble in response to @friendlyjordies unhinged rant and ramble below. Buddy, it’s a transmission line. Not a transistor. I know they sound similar, but they’re really, well… not similar at all.

14:30

Let's take a look into the Victorian Liberals

2:30
Aidan Morrison avatar
Aidan Morrison@FootnotesGuy·20h

Today Robert Gottliebsen is writing that the whispers coming out of the 'High Country' are that the newly announced price of $22-25 billion is also not realistic, and probably double that price is more likely, around $40-50 billion for the tunnels and pumps. Transmission extra. This doesn't seem all that unlikely, given recent history. At each stage, the cost estimates have increased, they've roughly doubled. I actually don't think that this indicates an actual estimate of expected cost, so much as throwing hand in the air and admitting that they've (still) got no idea, but it will be at least as much again as what's gone before. The Labor government has a real habit of announcing plans with settled-sounding titles, that they've got no idea how they'll actually deliver, and end up bungling beyond belief. Capacity Investment Scheme, Gas Reservation.... And in this case, the geology is such that there's an extremely challenging section of geology, maybe 900m or so, called the Long Plain Fault Zone. We've already ordered one brand-new boring machine custom made for that section. It's not clear whether it's in position, or still digging it's way down, or making progress, or stuck already, or what. But I think that it's quite likely that the latest $22.5-25 billion estimate is really just a compromise public figure that pushes the decision to continue, and a budget to keep going, out to at least beyond the next election... But the true answer is they've got no idea really, and credible people think it could be double that again. Have a read of the thread a wrote a little while back on the state of the geology that was understood when the project first got sign-off.

Post attachment

Last week I wrote a thread supporting @PaulineHansonOz's call to cancel Snowy 2.0. I argued that hard part was barely started. I've just glanced some of the geotechnical work from original the feasibility study. It's shocking. They knew that they knew nothing. A 🧵of horrors discussing the Long Plain Fault Zone, and the trouble of the headrace tunnel, which is the longest tunnel, at best half complete, with the most difficult geology still to come. I won't attempt to diagnose this in detail. But the risks were clear at the outset, and still aren't retired. 1/

Aidan Morrison avatar
Aidan Morrison@FootnotesGuy·Nov 16

This is horrifying. It’s slowly dawning on me that this Labor government couldn’t organise a piss-up in a brewery. It’s just rank incompetence and water-treading as far as the eye can see. They got away with blaming the previous side for 3 years. And the public bought it. Now we’re at 4.5 years, and their signature policy schemes should be maturing. But it’s clear they’ve got… nothing. Na da. Reading @saulkavonic’s piece here on the gas reservation scheme is gut-wrenching, because I feel as though I’ve seen it all before in the Capacity Investment Scheme. Total discretion for each decision resting with the minister. No publication of costs, or advice from the regulatory body managing the contracts… ever. Critical clauses changed in drafted contracts even AFTER announcing winners, making the terms they bid on baseless. Just general competence stuff. And then, unsurprisingly, barely any of the winners have won something that actually lets them reach financial close. Complete failure on any and every metric. I could see this gas debacle coming when I heard Tim Ayers face the first Senate Estimates after the reservation policy was announced. The concessions he made about matters that were still being considered made it clear they announced an intention for a policy title. They had no idea how to make it work. Announce first… then muddle through. Obfuscate, bluster, lie if necessary. You kinda can’t un-see it once a few critical pieces fall into place. I just hope the rest of the population have the scales fall from their eyes too.

Labors proposed reservation policy - is just giving Bowen a mandate for back room deals and to make it up as he goes each year. They couldnt even get basic drafting right They could have just copied WAs system that works pretty well. But they have chosen to invent a convoluted laborious policy that gives the minister discretion to do whatever he wants. see: Labor’s ‘embarrassing missed opportunity’ on rare energy support theaustralian.com.au/comment…

Post attachment
Aidan Morrison avatar
Aidan Morrison@FootnotesGuy·Nov 16

Anyway, long way of saying prices heading right back up again. What Chris Bowen has been boasting about is ephemeral. Wholesale prices are low, but not for timeframe that they would help to lower bills. It's a meaningless vanity stat. 13/13 facebook.com/share/r/1A49coX…

Aidan Morrison avatar
Aidan Morrison@FootnotesGuy·Nov 16

Note that NSW price spike's effect seems to have had a (slightly smaller) impact on Victorian and Queensland quarterly forward prices too. Not surprising, given their interconnections. Hard to know whether another market glitch would've done the same thing a few months later anyway... but if not, then that event has conceivably added a couple billion in electricity costs to retail bills over the following year, just in NSW. That's just a back-of-beer-coaster calc... But still, it towers over the $15 million that Snowy Hydro netted from that incident. 12/

Post attachment
Aidan Morrison avatar
Aidan Morrison@FootnotesGuy·Nov 16

This happened. Snowy Hydro did some very aggressive, and arguably disingenuous bidding, which resulted in the largest price spike in NSW's recent history. It seems that that alone wiped out the near-term confidence in low prices. 11/

I think this is evidence of our government-owned energy generator, Snowy Hydro, unethically gouging consumers. It might be legal. Maybe. But I think it's wrong. Electricity consumers and taxpayers should be furious. I pulled this data with the help of AI. This would be days or weeks of work a few years ago. Now getting all the data in the ideal format to understand takes just minutes. Much harder is figuring out what it actually means. I should hasten to say, I'm pro-market enough to hate it when people rail against 'price-gouging'. Provided the market isn't rigged, there's nothing wrong with sellers charging what they can. Prices are important signals. If the market's functioning properly, it will bring in new supply from competitors, and/or allocate limited supplies to those with greatest need. But in this case, I think the actions taken by Snowy Hydro show absolutely masterful exploitation of failures in our energy market, in particular transmission constraints and poor system design, which competitors have no means of correcting through new supply. Because the supply is fixed by a badly designed transmission build-out, competition is held away. The damning thing here is the change in the ramp-down rates. That's what makes the whole thing go from smart, and brutally self-interested manipulation of the market, to something that seems to me to be dishonest. That, set in the context of the counterprice flows, and the market intervention by @AEMO_Energy to impose constraints that would affect other competitors ability to provide power in the market. You see, the first thing you'd think of for re-bidding behaviour that's potentially profit-maximising, and hurting consumers, is raising your bids to higher prices, when you know that there's a shortage. That's child's play compared to what's going on here. At rebid 6, Snowy drops their bid down to negative values for half their capacity. (See green block start on bottom panel) Ie, "I'll pay people to take away my power". Surely lower bids helps lower prices right? Usually right, but here it's wrong. And this is where Snowy Hydro's market team shows they're true ninjas. They know that there's a bottle-neck so a bunch of power in Southern NSW can't reach Sydney, and push down prices at the reference point. So they bid super-low. Negative $1000. The minimum. That guarantees they get dispatched. The plebs in the wind-farms trying to get every MW they can out at a positive price would never take that kind of risk. So they bid negative, massively, to ensure that their power is flowing to market ahead of any other generator in Southern NSW. But that's only the opening move, and Snowy Hydro are thinking many steps ahead already. They would know the network well enough to know that turning their own pumps on in this part of the network will force power over the border into Victoria against price signals. Victoria has negative prices, NSW positive, at 13:40. Prior to this point, before Tumut 3 turns on, a bit of power is flowing from Vic to NSW, which is helpful. Their negative prices helps bid down NSW's positive prices. Which is good. Until... Tumut 3 turns on nearly 900MW in far-South NSW with their crazy-low bid. Then power starts flowing the wrong way, from positive prices to negative, over the Vic border. Promising generators they'd get paid to generate, then promising Victorian consumers they'd get paid to consumer NSW's excess. This "negative residue" starts to build up slowly at first. But as prices rise in NSW, as the afternoon heat builds, it speeds up a little. Then comes Snowy Hydro's next big move. Rebid 7 in the table. They push their entire 1.78GW generation capacity down to the floor price, so it gets dispatched. And this pushes a mass of electricity across the border at a pretty big counter-price delta. Snowy Hydro knows perfectly well what this does. It pushes the cumulative residues over a level where AEMO has a policy to intervene, imposing a constraint on the market to stop these negative residues building up too high, racking up bills for high priced generation in one state that no-one in the other state where the power landed agreed to pay for. Effectively the idea is to 'clamp' the interconnector to stop power flowing the wrong way across it. But you can't actually stop electrons by clamping the interconnector. You have to adjust the pushes and pulls of generators and loads to prevent the electric fields pushing power the wrong way. That means directing generators to switch off. And here's the real cunning in Snowy Hydro's plan. Because they had so obviously caused the mayhem by pushing nearly 2GW into the grid in a place where the power flowed over the border away from where it was really needed, surely AEMO's new constraints to prevent that flow would switch that generator (Tumut 3) straight back off? It was dispatching nothing an hour earlier. Surely they get switched off? Anticipating this, right back at rebid 6 Snowy had adjusted their ramp-down rates registered with the market operator. This is the step which crosses a line in my mind. Because I strongly suspect that nothing at all changed in the technical capability of Tumut 3 that meant that it couldn't be ramped down as fast as they had told the market they could do minutes before, and would tell the market they could do again just a few hours later. The reasons given mention nothing about technical problems. So this is done as a market move. They know this can make them money, but the truth is that their machinery could ramp at the same (high) rate throughout this episode, I assume. But by lowering their ramp rate down so far, to just 18MW/minute, they effectively meant that AEMO couldn't turn them off. They can only be gradually ramped down. They should've been the first ones turned off to prevent the counterprice flows, but they'd manipulated their ramp so that they couldn't be switched off. Consequently, all the other generators in Southern NSW got switched off in preference. And this drove prices sky-high, because Sydney needed energy. Prices reached over $20,000/MW in a couple of increments soon after. And, apparently, because the most badly positioned generator (Tumut 3) that was pumping out energy near the Victorian border couldn't be ramped down quickly, enormous 'negative residues' accrued, with a couple million in the 5 mins after AEMO notified the market of the constraint to (attempt to) limit the counterprice flows. And, more than a million ten minutes later. These 'residues' just get lumped onto network charges, and end up being paid by consumers. So it's pretty clear that Snowy Hydro's re-bid limiting the ramp rate caused those additional negative residues to arrive, hurting consumers directly. But also very likely, though there are few more moving parts involved and hence just slightly harder to say with certainty, the bidding behaviour here, which triggered the market intervention to clamp the interconnector to Victoria, almost certainly contributed to the price volatility reaching such extreme peaks in NSW. That would be a much, much more significant cost to consumers, I've seen estimates from @EnergyWrapAU putting Snowy's windfall at around $15 million in one hot hour. So this I think crosses a line for me. Because the changed ramp-down rate is almost certainly made-up, reflecting nothing in their machinery at all, and because they knowingly caused bad outcomes for consumers on the way to getting paid that otherwise wouldn't have occurred (the counter-price flows for sure, and the price spike almost certainly) I don't think it's ethical behaviour for any generator, and certainly not one owned by taxpayers. I strongly suspect that if Snowy Hydro had left Tumut 3 with their bids as they were at 13:30, that the counterprice flows would have been far more moderate, possibly not triggering an intervention. And also NSW wind generators a little closer to Sydney would have done a better job meeting rising demand, and prices might have risen a bit, but to nothing like the extend that they actually did when they were forcibly switched off while Snowy Hydro was running Tumut 3 which was sending power the wrong way over the border into Victoria. Because they couldn't be switched off because of the manipulated ramp-rates.

Post attachmentPost attachment
Aidan Morrison avatar
Aidan Morrison@FootnotesGuy·Nov 16

But this was completely reversed a quarter later. As at a few days ago, the futures for the next few quarters are back at the level when markets hadn't really believed the recent lull was structural. Essentially wiping out the actual benefit of lower recent prices for consumers. This is... a little wierd. What happened to change things back up? 10/

Post attachment
Aidan Morrison avatar
Aidan Morrison@FootnotesGuy·Nov 16

Look at how the future price for the last quarter of 2026 fell massively between the prices traded at 31 October 2025, and July this year, just one quarter in advance. What explains this fall? Well, average prices had remained low for a solid twelve months. Four quarters. That's enough to incorporate any seasonal fluctuations. Market start to believe that this is real signal, and not just noise. Since spring is a shoulder season, usually good wind, growing solar, not crazy hot, the forward price was lower than recent averages. 9/

Post attachment
Aidan Morrison avatar
Aidan Morrison@FootnotesGuy·Nov 16

This phenomenon is also clearly visible in the quarterly swaps. The black is real wholesale prices. The coloured lines are prices available, at certain historical dates, for quarterly swaps into the future. You can see that further out, 2029 or 2030, all the lines converge, at prices around where they were, about $100, or a bit above or below, depending on which state. But in the shorter term, there was some real variance, which warrants another explanation. 8/

Post attachment
Aidan Morrison avatar
Aidan Morrison@FootnotesGuy·Nov 16

This chart also shows how the fall in the wholesale prices on the 12-month average are much, much larger than the falls in forward contracts in 2028 and 2029. 7/

Post attachment
Aidan Morrison avatar
Aidan Morrison@FootnotesGuy·Nov 16

But the really important story is about what the markets think and thought about where prices would go. In practice, all the markets knew what Rystad did... once coal closed, prices would rise again. There's a bit going on here to unpack. My AI scrape of data finds some discontinuities in publically available data from achive/current sources. So there's some gaps, and point dots. But the lighter colours are the swaps for baseload futures at later years, the lightest Calendary Year 2030. You can see in all cases, these later-year estimates of average price aren't nearly as lwow as existing 12-month lagging average prices, the solid black lines. In Victoria and NSW, they've barely tilted down in the last year. That's because everyone knows that Yallourne is scheduled to close in 2028, and that means trouble. In NSW and Queensland, futures did trend right down, for a bit... But 2030 didn't ever dip down far below $100/MWh in NSW, that's because Eraring is due to close in 2029, and that again means any slack in the system now will be wiped out. (And then some, if you ask me.) Also very interesting, the latest data, the squiggles right up to the right, are elevated again. This means that they low wholesale prices that Bowen has been boasting about are already useless for consumers, because markets are pricing their demise already. They were but a fleeting illusion. And everyone knows it. 6/

Post attachment
Aidan Morrison avatar
Aidan Morrison@FootnotesGuy·Nov 16

Here's another image that contrasts the different states, and the 3-month vs 12 month rolling average difference. 5/

Post attachment
Aidan Morrison avatar
Aidan Morrison@FootnotesGuy·Nov 16

The Rystad report, which doesn't seem to be released publicly, says prices will rise from the current $60/MWh up to $110. And this is *almost* a doubling. But actually, that's cheeky. Only Victoria is down quite that low. And $110? Everyone except Vic was there or higher last year anyway. The story is "as you were", not a descent into hell. 4/

Post attachment
Aidan Morrison avatar
Aidan Morrison@FootnotesGuy·Nov 16

The three-month rolling average shows a bit better how bumpy wholesale prices are... But you can see in the shaded last 12-month, the ride has been smoother. Decent coal power station performance has been a factor, as has the additionl of loads of consumer batteries. 3/

Post attachment
Aidan Morrison avatar
Aidan Morrison@FootnotesGuy·Nov 16

The reality is that wholesale prices have recently dipped very suddenly. Or at least, on the 12-month rolling average, we've had a really good run. Recent history has been >$100/MWh. But it's slumped appreciably. 2/

Post attachment