←
DataFramed358 posts
DataFramed avatar

DataFramed

@FramedData

A Canadian economist interested in history, data, demographics, politics and culture.

◷ Joined February 2022▧ 13 Photos and videos
DataFramed avatar
DataFramed@FramedData·29 Jul 2023

Change in real GDP per capita from 2019Q4 to 2023Q1: 🇺🇸 +5.1% 🇮🇹 +4.0% 🇦🇺 +3.8% 🇯🇵 +2.8% 🇫🇷 +0.1% 🇩🇪 -1.9% 🇨🇦 -2.0% 🇬🇧 -2.1% Canadian GDP per capita was 85% of the U.S. in 1990, 77% in 2019, and is now in free fall. #Canadaisbroken

DataFramed avatar
DataFramed@FramedData·6 Jul 2023

2: The real answer is [nice sounding non-solution Z] Try it out. X = immigration, Y = housing crisis, Z = tax the rich and build a smattering of social housing or X = "compassionate" crime policies, Y = rising crime rates, Z = gun confiscations.

DataFramed avatar
DataFramed@FramedData·6 Jul 2023

Every political argument in Canada in 2023: Person 1: It looks like [sacred policy choice X] is having [bad consequence Y], maybe we need to make changes. Person 2: But [sacred policy choice X] is essential! Are you saying we shouldn't do it?! 1: No, but we can change things!

DataFramed avatar
DataFramed@FramedData·6 Jul 2023

It also leads us straight away to social desirability biased habits of thought. Because this is every issue now, political disagreement is polarized and unproductive.

DataFramed avatar
DataFramed@FramedData·6 Jul 2023

One of our biggest problems in Canada is how we've elevated policy choices to sacred values. This means we can't make, or even contemplate, trade offs. It makes us stupid. We seem to care more about what our government's actions say about us than if they are sensible or effective

DataFramed avatar
DataFramed@FramedData·29 Sep 2022

If Prince Edward Island was a country its population growth rate would be top 5 in the world. No wonder no one can afford a house there anymore.

Post attachment
DataFramed avatar
DataFramed@FramedData·26 Aug 2022

- Lots of references to the 1970s. - "The job is not done. We will keep at this until its done." And now we watch the markets tumble for the rest of the day.

DataFramed avatar
DataFramed@FramedData·26 Aug 2022

- Another unusually large rate hike in September may be appropriate but will depend on the totality of the data. - At some point it will be appropriate to slow the pace of hikes, but the historical record cautions strongly against premature ends to hiking cycles.

DataFramed avatar
DataFramed@FramedData·26 Aug 2022

Jerome Powell at Jackson Hole: - The U.S. economy is slowing but it shows strong momentum, the labour market is strong and demand for workers is way ahead of supply. - Policy stance is near neutral, but there is no reason to stop at neutral when inflation is this high.

DataFramed avatar
DataFramed@FramedData·18 Aug 2022

So my call is: Absent a big recession and if nothing changes, the best guess is nominal price decline of 15-20% across the GTA from here. If rates rise more than anticipated though, it could easily be a lot more.

DataFramed avatar
DataFramed@FramedData·18 Aug 2022

I don't think the latter is likely; the city has changed a lot compared with the 1980s-1990s. However, a correction to 2019 affordability seems probable. Wages are growing (roughly 5% a year), so the nominal price decline will be smaller than the real one.

DataFramed avatar
DataFramed@FramedData·18 Aug 2022

If you assume that affordability falls back to that 35% plateau and rates are unchanged, it implies a real correction of 26%. If you think it corrects back to its long-run average, it implies a correction of 43%.

DataFramed avatar
DataFramed@FramedData·18 Aug 2022

The last affordable year this time was in 2015. Real prices rose 23% to the 2017-2019 plateau (affordability = 35% of incomes) and then 40% more in 2020-2021 (to worst-ever affordability of 47%). A total rise since 2015 of 70% (again inflation adjusted).

DataFramed avatar
DataFramed@FramedData·18 Aug 2022

Before the 1980s bubble, the last affordable year was 1987. Inflation was high back then, so we'll look at real prices. They increased by 44% to the peak in 1989. Rates fell a bit over the next two years, so affordability was re-established by a 30% real house price correction.

DataFramed avatar
DataFramed@FramedData·18 Aug 2022

Historically, the average is 27%, i.e. the average carrying cost of the typical single-family house in Toronto cost about a quarter of a couple family with kids' pre-tax income. As of June 2022, that number is 47%, an all-time high.