On the @BookShark podcast for homeschoolers, host Janna Koch and I talk about how our culture has undermined our trust in our kids. Grifters have told us children can't do anything without a special product, procedure or class.
Not true!
open.spotify.com/episode/1lx…
Gee why?
"AI toy meant for toddlers is pulled from shelves after it tells stories of gang rape and murders"
"The Pixie-Paw had no problem describing...topics from the Khmer Rouge regime to the gas attacks in Syria..."
Sweet dreams, snookums!
dailymail.com/news/article-1…
Unstructured activity is good for children. I think we begin team sports too young now, sandlot games were a healthy thing. We sometimes played basketball on weekends for four or six hours, until we had blisters from the hot pavement.
The other day, two 10-year-old boys knocked on our door and asked if my son could ride bikes. My son knew the boys from school but had never hung out with them.
They ended meeting up with three more friends along the way. My son was gone for hours.
How often do kids get unstructured time, where they have to decide where to go and what to do?
One way to “cure” the loneliness epidemic may be to stop calling it an epidemic.
In new research, @annsomerswh at @ChristensenInst finds that loneliness is poorly defined and therefore used as an umbrella term to describe many different circumstances.
Through in-depth interviews—specifically with parents—Ann Somers identifies 5 distinct situation-types of “lonely” that could each benefit from distinct solutions.
Why is that framing so important? Loneliness is one of the MANY complex social problems that, today, often gets wrapped in a single, simple “mental health” narrative. Things like poor grades, unemployment, divorce, and, yup, loneliness, all get labeled “mental health” problems. But that implies what’s needed for all is a mental healthcare solution.
More people are then directed toward unnecessary medicalization (i.e., therapy and/or medications) and attention is diverted from other solutions that could be more effective and appropriate in both the short and long term—e.g., education support for bad grades, jobs for unemployment.
Calling everything a mental health problem is also bad for people with mental illness, who DO specifically need mental health care, but often can’t get it because resources are misdirected toward those who don’t need it or won’t benefit from it.
The rise in loneliness has been called an “epidemic”—medical language which further frames the problem as one of public health appropriate for medical solutions.
Ann Somers tactfully uses that language to redirect the loneliness conversation away from mental health and medical solutions by disaggregating loneliness and transparently offering first-line non-medical proposals instead.
Language matters because it affects how we approach challenges and allocate resources and attention. Mental healthcare is not a magic fix-all—and most problems don't have a one-size-fits-all solution whether it's medical or not. Including loneliness.
"The Geo-Located Generation: What nonstop surveillance is doing to children"
GREAT @Atlantic piece abt the underrated FLIP side of kids being on phones: parents using phones to watch their kids.
This impacts the parent/child bond AND independence!
letgrow.org/childhood-indepe…
Or your culture has parents that unsupervised kids are automatically in danger and no decent mom or dad lets them leave the house.
This is reinforced by cruel parenting norms, and sometimes the law.
Both of which @LetGrowOrg is working to reverse!
I’m sticking with my belief that if your reasonably competent 12-year old can’t be trusted navigating your city independently either you are overly protective or your city is seriously messed up.
And to think we don't let kids climb up a standard, playground slide. "Too dangerous!"
Meanwhile, in Indonesia...
facebook.com/reel/1421931546…
h/t Patti Dennison Rynerson
The Kansas story about a mom at soccer whose car drove onto field and killed 2 is so painful. So tragic.
AND how awful that getting up at 6 to drive 200 miles so your kids can play a game has been normalized, writes @LindaFlanagan2:
linkedin.com/feed/update/urn…
I love this study but it always seems like we are discovering the equivalent of "Food solves starvation!"
This one:
"Children who visit a playground or park once a week may enjoy better mental health later on. It also helps build their social skills."
healthday.com/health-news/ch…
In the 80s my friend Lena Einhorn started studying why cancer is so rare in newborns, and when malignant cells are transplanted to embryos, they often lose their malignant characteristics.
Hmm!
AT LAST the research has resurfaced!
onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/…
Intriguing study: Head Start kids who got social emotional training were doing better, socially/emotionally, in their early 20s.
Wish the researchers had done same study but given the kids FREE PLAY!
studyfinds.com/kids-who-lear…
“Once we had that tool,” a mom of four tells @sarahzhang (the writer of this excellent piece in The Atlantic) “it felt like we were irresponsible if we didn’t use it.”
This is my worry with so much parenting tech (and a major theme of CITY WITHOUT CHILDREN): Are you irresponsible if you choose not to use the Owlet or the Nanit to monitor your newborn's breathing? (There's SIDS risk, you know!) What about if you don't use Orchid to assess your embryo's health prior to implantation––are you abdicating your responsibility as parent? What about the livestreams provided by so many daycares––shouldn't you be spot-checking to ensure the workers are treating your child well, that they aren't in distress? Consider the possibility of the shame and guilt that would haunt you forever, the thinking goes, if you were insufficiently vigilant, since you *had the technology and therefore the ability* to monitor in a way that prior generations didn't.
But the problem is that we're moving the parenting goalposts from constant vigilance & supervision to something even less doable: Constant surveillance. People will have a worse experience of parenthood, depriving their children of substantial, yet hard-to-measure developmental milestones. They might have fewer children as the standards creep upward.
We're well past the point of diminishing returns, and it's all curdling into a spiritual crisis.
My letter in today's @NYTimes boils down to:
Maybe what kids really need is not more $ for mental health interventions but more independence and free play.
At least try that FIRST.
nytimes.com/2026/11/07/opini…
Come hear holiday puns from some of the quickest wits in the west. (Well, actually in the east.)
TUES, DEC 8
PUNDERDOME
At Littlefield's in Bklyn.
8 p.m.
Hope so you see there!
Tickets here!
littlefieldnyc.com/event/?wf…@Punderdome3000