OG GenAI Skeptic; spoke at US Senate. Warned about hallucinations in 2001. Advocating world models & neurosymbolic AI ever since. Author, Marcus on AI & 6 books
Three thoughts on what really matters:
1. Fuck cancer
2. Friends are irreplaceable
3. The new "Marcus test" for AI is when AI makes a significant dent on cancer
May that happen sooner, much sooner, rather than later.
In memory of my childhood friend Paul.
🦔The IMF says circular AI deals, where companies fund the customers who buy from them, now top $1 trillion. About two-thirds of that money is borrowed. Kristalina Georgieva, who runs the IMF, told CNBC the world economy is “standing on one leg on the AI leg,” though she called the recent market swings orderly.
My Take
Every time Nvidia funds a customer and that customer buys Nvidia chips, the purchase shows up in the GDP numbers as business investment. Harvard economist Jason Furman figured tech spending like this made up 92% of U.S. growth in the first half of last year (he thinks other parts of the economy would have filled in maybe half of that without the AI boom). So if the news says the economy is humming while your paycheck and grocery bill say otherwise, part of the difference is AI companies passing money around in a circle.
That leaves governments in an awkward spot. Finance ministers want the growth number, and regulators have a reason to look away until something breaks. The other leg was supposed to be wages and everyday spending, and I would definitely feel a lot better if growth came from that one again.
Hedgie🤗
Alphaville: "Even before Jensen Huang’s exit, Nvidia’s balance-sheet-as-service was already showing signs of approaching peak bloat. Bloomberg reported last week that a $500bn AI finance platform launched in August had delivered no deals, as lenders wanted bigger backstops. Banks including JPMorgan, Citigroup and Goldman have all been talking up their underwriting discipline and how they’re limiting exposure to the junk-rated issuers. We’ve also had the US commerce department’s Bureau of Industry and Security this week announcing a tighter regime on AI chip exports with new restrictions on the sale of advanced hardware to Singapore, Indonesia, Thailand, Malaysia and Brazil. The idea is to close a loophole that might allow Chinese companies to lease offshore capacity from offshore data centres, particularly in south-east Asia. Analysts at Jefferies estimate that the new restrictions put between $44bn and $62bn of Nvidia’s 2027 chip sales at risk, equivalent to 11 per cent and 16 per cent of its 2027 data centre revenue at the consensus level."
As I warned in my September report on "The AI Trade" (sageroadresearch.com/product…):
"Circular dealmaking is clearly the key systemic vulnerability of the AI trade. For just a few examples that tell the story of intertwinement between the biggest stakeholders in the AI revolution: According to Barclay’s, OpenAI and Anthropic will account for 13% of AWS revenue this year and 18% next year. For Google Cloud, those numbers are 27% this year and 48% next year, according to UBS calculations. Meanwhile, Microsoft owns 27% of OpenAI. Meta and OpenAI are large shareholders in AMD. And as the WSJ put it recently, “Nvidia is now the banker to the AI boom,” backstopping loans to and compute capacity for everyone from OpenAI and CoreWeave to Australian AI startups.
This circularity threatens to “inflate AI’s growth by blurring the lines between real demand and companies effectively buying from themselves,” as Fast Company summed up in March. From circular dealmaking comes artificially inflated expectations along with house-of-cards vulnerability, which now includes the banking system. As the FT summed up earlier this month about a $200 billion “Wall Street finance machine for Anthropic”, which brought “together Google, Broadcom, Apollo, Blackstone, Morgan Stanley and a slew of crypto miners in a web of transactions”: “Big Tech is creating funding models for AI that reach far beyond traditional corporate spending and tie more of the financial system to the industry’s growth.”
in truth, Jensen pulled a Biden; sticking around too long without building proper succession plan.
he also pulled a Trump, surrounding himself with sycophants (or just dismissing other people with contrary views) and making bad decisions that could easily have been avoided.
I wonder how many retail investors are thinking of what junk bond status will mean for Anthropic, its ability to be profitable, and to have a rising share price? Without that rising share price, there is no reason to invest. Unfortunately, many retail investors will ignore this
BLACKSTONE WARNS ANTHROPIC WILL DEBUT AS JUNK AFTER RECORD IPO
Blackstone has told investors that Anthropic is likely to receive a double-B credit rating from major agencies after going public—placing it firmly in junk territory and below investment grade. This reverses Blackstone’s earlier guidance that the company would reach investment-grade status by year-end.
Why it matters:
- A sub-investment-grade rating would raise Anthropic’s borrowing costs.
- It would also limit access to large pools of institutional capital, including pension funds and insurers that face restrictions on junk-rated debt.
- The shift is significant given the scale of the company’s planned infrastructure spending.
Context:
The warning comes as Blackstone participates in Project North Star, Anthropic’s roughly $63 billion financing to lease about 1.5 GW of Google AI chips.
Deal structure:
- More than $42 billion in senior loans (guaranteed by Broadcom)
- Roughly $18 billion in junior debt (backed by Anthropic’s lease payments)
- Blackstone funds taking about $9 billion of the junior tranche, at yields above 10%
What’s next:
Anthropic’s IPO prospectus outlines more than $800 billion in computing-infrastructure commitments through 2045. Without an investment-grade rating, the company is expected to keep relying on stronger partners and higher-cost financing.
Moody’s, S&P, and Fitch have not yet issued formal ratings for Anthropic.
Those supporting Jensen Huang’s return to Nvidia after the scandal he’s just caused are misreading the room, John Authers writes. Get over it and move on bloomberg.com/opinion/newsle…
Translation: "please don't hurt my stock portfolio"
Fact: Gary has always offered solutions (neuro-symbolic AI) and the industry is now using those solutions without actually admitting it.