←
Gary Spedding132,631 posts
Gary Spedding avatar

Gary Spedding

@GarySpedding

Human rights & conflict transformation advocacy in solidarity with both 🇵🇸 & 🇦🇲. Can also be found fighting antisemitism. Contact: Gary@gary-spedding.com

◷ Joined July 2011▧ 5,156 Photos and videos
Gary Spedding avatar
Gary Spedding@GarySpedding·Aug 26

I've dedicated fifteen+ years to human rights advocacy on Syria, Lebanon, Armenia and Palestine. The work I do is independent,professional and free of others agendas. I work without a fixed salary. If you can support me at all please contribute here: buymeacoffee.com/garyspeddin…

Mairav Zonszein מרב זונשיין avatar
⟳ Gary Spedding retweeted
Mairav Zonszein מרב זונשיין@MairavZ·3h

If Israel actually treated Palestinians citizens as equals and was not occupying, expelling and destroying the lives of millions of them and failing to define its borders, it could justify the Jewish state thing

@EinatWilf: most countries are "based on a single dominant national, ethnic, linguistic, or religious group." Israel "is well within the global norm." El-Sayed's demand that Israel "not identify itself with a culture or a faith" applies only to Jews. tabletmag.com/sections/israe…

Al-Haq الحق avatar
⟳ Gary Spedding retweeted
Al-Haq الحق@alhaq_org·4h

🚨 URGENT: Today, Israeli Occupying Forces have launched a new ground assault in central #Gaza, advancing tanks near the densely populated Al-Bureij and Nuseirat refugee camps and closing Salah al-Din Road. /1

Gary Spedding avatar
Gary Spedding@GarySpedding·1h

Refusing to engage honestly and reflectively on these interlinked issues is a massive strategic mistake. If we truly want to honour what Palestinians have asked of us, we must be strong enough to fight external defamation and principled enough to clean our own house. Liberation demands nothing less. This isn't some game we are playing out here in the United Kingdom, Europe and America. It doesn't matter if your ego gets stroked or you get a fee endorphins because you 'won' that online argument. What does matter is real victories that provide material solidarity with Palestinians and promote tangible change in policy and action that further the liberation of Palestine and justice, human rights, dignity and freedom for Palestinians.

Gary Spedding avatar
Gary Spedding@GarySpedding·1h

I'd honestly much rather be putting the entirety of my effort into Palestine and other human rights advocacy without getting bogged down with all this stuff. It is exhausting and immensely frustrating. I also expect a torrent of abuse, threats, and smears as a result of choosing to speak up. Here's the thing; we know the tactics and strategies of Israel advocacy using smears, fabrications, racism, and false allegations. We have seen it just recently with attacks on Sky News' Alex Crawford from an Israeli diplomat. We rightly defended Alex and her impeccable journalism record and professionalism. But we make it so much more difficult on ourselves when we aren't equipped to recognise the difference between false smears such as those directed at Alex Crawford and very real concerns raised about figures like David Miller. Israel advocacy thrives on our own errors and shortcomings - why give them a victory by ignoring problematic individuals within our own ranks?

Gary Spedding avatar
Gary Spedding@GarySpedding·1h

Look at the damage already done: vast sums of money, media platforms, and political energy have been misappropriated and stolen from the Palestinian cause by grifters and problematic figures. Palestinian voices have a hard enough time getting a platform given our racist and biased media. I'm tired of saying this on repeat but we need to forensically example the input and output of figures like George Galloway, Chris Williamson, and David Miller... then we should look at the axtivities of people like Ken O'Keefe, Greta Berlin, Rania Khalek, Vanessa Beeley, and Yvonne Ridley... All are making bank on the blood of Palestinians and doing immense harm to the Palestinian cause overall

Gary Spedding avatar
Gary Spedding@GarySpedding·1h

When we react with reflexive defensiveness and refuse to examine legitimate concerns in good faith, we lower our movement's standards and abandon our own principles. Worse, we create a vacuum where bad actors, conspiracy theorists, and opportunists - particularly those with a ulterior motive or agenda (such as Assadists and Iranian-regime apologists) - can operate unchecked under the banner of "anti-imperialism" or "solidarity" while they promote extremely problematic ideas and rhetoric.

Gary Spedding avatar
Gary Spedding@GarySpedding·1h

As a movement, we are failing to acknowledge that bad-faith actors routinely deploying false smears against progressive groups does NOT mean every single allegation of antisemitism or misconduct is fabricated or malicious. Treating every critique as a smear is an intellectual and moral shortcut. It is also the case that dismissing antisemitism as entirely fake or a 'scam' weakens our credibility and does further harm to Jewish communities AND the Palestinian cause for which we are meant to be advocating to the best of our ability.

Gary Spedding avatar
Gary Spedding@GarySpedding·1h

Palestinians themselves have repeatedly asked international allies to be strategic and tactical. As Palestinian writers like Mariam Barghouti have emphasised in their guidelines for solidarity activists, solidarity is not about Western ego, saviorship, or speaking over Palestinians; it is about accountability and centring the liberation struggle responsibly. ramallahbantustan.wordpress.…

Gary Spedding avatar
Gary Spedding@GarySpedding·1h

As activists, our foundational commitment must be principled solidarity with all oppressed people. When we advocate for Palestinian liberation, we carry a profound responsibility to be the sharpest, most disciplined, and most effective advocates possible. Otherwise we become careless commentators screaming into the abyss and achieving virtually nothing except stroking our own egos.

Gary Spedding avatar
Gary Spedding@GarySpedding·1h

Understanding both realities at once is essential. Antisemitism often operates by positioning Jews as a hidden, conspiratorial elite (a trope that harms Jewish people while simultaneously diverting progressive movements away from dismantling actual systems of power, white supremacy, and state violence). Getting to grips with how this plays out, that actors on various 'sides' of the argument exploit Jewish vulnerabilities and antisemitism, is absolutely crucial.

Gary Spedding avatar
Gary Spedding@GarySpedding·1h

At the same time, we are not out here blind to how real antisemitism functions. Thanks to the crucial political education provided by Palestinian scholars and activists, as well as Jewish scholars, organisations and activists including April Rosenblum, @JFREJNYC, Ben Lorber, Rebecca Vilkomerson, Rabbi Alissa Wise, and the Diaspora Alliance (to name just a few), we understand that antisemitism is a real, systemic oppression—and that Jews remain a vulnerable minority.

Gary Spedding avatar
Gary Spedding@GarySpedding·1h

This machinery doesn't just attack critics of Israeli state policy, but also cynically exploits the real, generational trauma and vulnerabilities of Jewish communities that experience and face very real antisemitism. By conflating Jewish safety with unconditional support for Israel, it manufactures fear to chill speech, silence progressive organising, and paralyse Palestine advocacy.

Gary Spedding avatar
Gary Spedding@GarySpedding·1h

We need an honest, mature, and explorative reflection about where Palestine solidarity is at now, what obstacles we face, and how to be the very best advocates for Palestine that we possibly can be. We already know the playbook and bad-faith of Israel advocacy: Weaponising false allegations of antisemitism, fanning anti-Palestinian racism and Islamophobia, and orchestrating campaigns of bullying, harassment, defamation, and career destruction. 🧵

Gary Spedding avatar
Gary Spedding@GarySpedding·3h

- Public authorities must remain neutral arbiters of lawful political expression rather than using municipal resolutions to chill or delegitimise lawful political viewpoints held by elected councillors, council staff, or members of the public. On point four - local authorities are creatures of statute whose powers are governed by the Local Government Act 1972 and the General Power of Competence under Section 1 of the Localism Act 2011. While Section 1 grants broad powers, those powers must still be exercised for a proper purpose connected to the governance and wellbeing of the local area, in accordance with public law principles (Padfield principles) and fiduciary duties to local council taxpayers. - A motion that adjudicates on contested international political ideologies—and potentially commits officer time, policy reviews, or administrative resources to enforcing a partisan ideological position—strays beyond the proper statutory functions of a local authority. - Expending Council officer time and public funds to debate, administer, or implement ideological declarations that do not deliver local services and actively expose the Council to judicial review and Equality Act litigation constitutes an improper use of public resources. - Condemning a registered political party’s internal party policy and conference resolutions through official council motions raises concerns regarding local authority neutrality and the proper scope of municipal functions. In effect, it is not the place of a local authority to specifically condemn the party policy of a particular political party. That is a matter for political parties to hold robust debate on when it comes to the public sphere and especially at election time. In light of all the above I have requested that North Tyneside Council look at this motion closely and answer what steps the Chair of the Council, Chief Executive, and Monitoring Officer are taking to ensure that this motion is either rejected under the Constitution or accompanied by full, formal legal advice addressing the statutory risks outlined.