←
Gitmo Watch46,547 posts
Gitmo Watch avatar

Gitmo Watch

@GitmoWatch

Front row seats at the Guantanamo military commissions. RT not confirm.

◷ Joined February 2012▧ 1,046 Photos and videos
Gitmo Watch avatar
Gitmo Watch@GitmoWatch·May 13

The commission in recess until 0900 hours tomorrow, when defense counsel for Mr. Mohammed, Mr. bin ‘Attash, and Mr. Al Hawsawi will address the LHM statements in a closed session to present their classified arguments.

Gitmo Watch avatar
Gitmo Watch@GitmoWatch·May 13

In conclusion: Engle tells the judge that admitting the LHM statements carries a significant societal cost. He argues that trying the 9/11 case using these statements obtained by torture would damage the United States’ reputation in the eyes of the world.

Gitmo Watch avatar
Gitmo Watch@GitmoWatch·May 13

In conclusion: Engle tells the judge that admitting the LHM statements carries a significant societal cost. He argues that trying the 9/11 case using these statements obtained by torture would damage the United States’ reputation in the eyes of the world.

Gitmo Watch avatar
Gitmo Watch@GitmoWatch·May 13

He further argues that the government relied on selectively chosen excerpts rather than the full conversation with other detainees, and that these excerpts do not demonstrate any detailed knowledge of the 9/11 attacks.

Gitmo Watch avatar
Gitmo Watch@GitmoWatch·May 13

Engle challenges the government’s recording offered as evidence of voluntariness, noting it was translated by a linguist who does not speak bin ‘Atash’s dialect.

Gitmo Watch avatar
Gitmo Watch@GitmoWatch·May 13

Engle highlights a contradiction between the two interrogating agents: Gaudin testified that bin ‘Atash introduced the topics himself, while McFadden asserted that the agents were the ones who introduced them.

Gitmo Watch avatar
Gitmo Watch@GitmoWatch·May 13

None of the behaviors or conditions bin ‘Atash exhibited during the LHM process support the government conclusion that his statements were voluntary.

Gitmo Watch avatar
Gitmo Watch@GitmoWatch·May 13

Engle argues that the CIA starved and tortured bin ‘Atash to shape him into the figure the FBI needed for the LHM.

Gitmo Watch avatar
Gitmo Watch@GitmoWatch·May 13

During his custody, bin ‘Atash repeatedly asked CIA personnel for more food as his weight continued to drop while interrogations continued. He later passed a 25 cm round worm that further contributed to his weight loss while CIA was starving him.

Gitmo Watch avatar
Gitmo Watch@GitmoWatch·May 13

Engle argues that bin ‘Atash never saw himself as a senior Al Qaeda leader; rather, he was repeatedly told he was one only after his capture. Engle further contends that the torture bin ‘Attash endured altered his own account of his involvement, from 2004 through the LHM.

Gitmo Watch avatar
Gitmo Watch@GitmoWatch·May 13

Engle also notes that the admonishment language changed in Oct 2007. The version given to bin ’Atash in Jan 2007 included language about the detainee being returned to prior custody, but that language was removed in the later admonishments.