From @TheAthletic: Rassie Erasmus, head coach of South Africa’s Springboks, is both a mad genius and an appalling loser, our columnist writes. "But rugby should not want to extinguish the defiance that makes him exceptional." nyti.ms/490Lukr
Australia could front up, admit they're bang to rights and have been doing it for a while as a team. Or they could throw Bancroft under a bus and express horror at the shoddy behaviour of a player. Place your bets...
From @TheAthletic: Australia’s national sport is in crisis. Sandpapergate has made the captain’s position untenable.
It is inconceivable that Pat Cummins can continue to lead the Australian cricket team, our columnist writes.
nyti.ms/4CcnQia
It’s actually a tough read that Bancroft piece.A young man living his childhood dream,completely failed upon by the teams leadership incl coaches.Then his so-called team mates who he was trying to help/impress isolate/gaslight him further publicly as the yrs go by. Career ruined
This is true. Greenberg’s leadership will be truly tested now at how he deals with this. That’s why you’re paid the big bucks as a CEO. First person I’d be calling for a chat is Kate Hutchison. She seemed the only one with moral fibre in that set up at the time.
🗣️ “This is a reckoning. This is a time to face up to what happened.”
➡️ Gerard Whateley says CA can no longer sidestep the Sandpapergate saga following Cam Bancroft’s revelations.
#Cricket
Have to agree with this.
These new laws are a complete mess if they are saying Prendergasts tackle wasn’t a hip drop.
It’s about as textbook as a hip drop can get.
Or are they saying it was, but a YC offence only, so no further punishment.
@WorldRugby need to clarify ASAP
you can not make this up 🤡
on the right, @WorldRugby own video guideline showing what is a hip drop tackle.
on the left , Prendergast. for which he has now been cleared.
what a mess this organisation is.
In just ten Premier League games, four penalty decisions have been judged to have been reviewed incorrectly by VAR in matches involving Arsenal.
The latest means the Gunners have been on the end of three wrong calls against them, and one in their favour.
football.london/arsenal-fc/n…
How many texts/emails/calls do you reckon Kate Hutchison has received this morning!? She should be brave, like she was then, and speak up. Australian cricket fans deserve to hear her side.
The only person who appears to come out well with respect to ‘Sandpapergate” is the team’s media manager on that tour, Kate Hutchison
From Cameron Bancroft’s article …
Pat Cummins,boofhead Lehmann & the bowling cartel are ‘unAustralian’. Duplicitous liars & frauds who were willingly happy to throw a few teammates under a bus to save their own asses.And worst,publicly double-down on it multiple times. In Aussie terms: what a bunch of ‘shitcunts’
Pat Cummins has torched his own reputation over Sandpapergate - the poster boy of Australian cricket betrayed the essence of his nation's character, savaged his own team-mates and let three pals swing in the wind. He cannot remain as captain trib.al/CGubT2u
Rassie, the Ref and Rugby’s Ugly Underbelly
Here we go again. Another Springbok defeat to France, another Rassie Erasmus meltdown, and another embarrassing episode for South African rugby.
You’d think we’d have learned something by now. Apparently not.
Rugby is one of South Africa’s greatest passions. But there’s a darker side to our beloved game. And frankly, I’m getting sick of it.
I’m talking about the growing culture of bullying, intimidation and outright nastiness that seems to follow the Springboks whenever things don’t go our way.
Remember November 2022? The Boks lost 30-26 to France in Marseille. It was supposed to be a special occasion for English referee Wayne Barnes, officiating his record 101st Test.
Instead, it became a nightmare.
Barnes and his wife Polly were subjected to horrific online abuse. Death threats, threats of sexual violence and disgusting messages involving their children. The Rugby Football Union was sufficiently alarmed to lodge a formal complaint with SA Rugby.
And who was busy posting clips questioning Barnes’s decisions? Our very own Rassie Erasmus.
I’m not suggesting Rassie personally encouraged anyone to threaten Barnes or his family. Barnes himself has said he doesn’t know whether Rassie’s posts caused the abuse. But surely Rassie understands that when someone in his position publicly questions a referee’s performance, a certain breed of supporter takes that as an invitation to pile on.
Fast-forward four years and we’ve gone full circle.
The Boks lose 21-19 to France in Paris last weekend. Three days later, Rassie acknowledges that his team deserved to lose and had only themselves to blame.
Fair enough. That’s leadership.
Then out comes the familiar grievance catalogue.
This time Rassie went considerably further by asking whether a TMO who saw infringements and deliberately ignored them would be guilty of match-fixing or manipulating the result.
That’s an extraordinary suggestion to put into the public domain without compelling evidence.
Let’s be clear: Rassie Erasmus is a brilliant rugby coach. Two World Cups, tactical innovations that have transformed the game, and an extraordinary ability to get the best out of his players. His place among rugby’s coaching greats is secure.
But being a genius doesn’t give you a free pass to behave like a petulant child whenever things don’t go your way.
The bigger problem is what this behaviour does to the culture surrounding our game.
Spend five minutes on social media after a Springbok defeat and you’ll see what I mean. Every controversial decision becomes evidence of a conspiracy. Every referee who makes a mistake is apparently incompetent, biased or corrupt.
And anyone who dares challenge the mob risks being labelled unpatriotic.
Refereeing rugby is an extraordinarily difficult job. The laws are complicated, interpretations vary, and officials must make split-second decisions under enormous pressure.
Even after countless slow-motion replays, experienced pundits frequently disagree.
When someone with Rassie’s influence raises the possibility of corruption in a dispute over refereeing decisions, I believe he gives oxygen to the worst elements of rugby fandom.
We’ve already seen the sort of abuse referees can face with Wayne Barnes.
What young referee, watching all this unfold, would willingly sign up for a career where a bad afternoon at the office might result in death threats against their family?
And without referees, we don’t have a game.
Rassie has every right to be angry. He has every right to raise concerns through the proper channels.
What he doesn’t have is the right to undermine the integrity of the sport simply because he doesn’t like the outcome.
And we supporters need to look in the mirror too.
I’ve supported the Boks through wonderful victories and some truly miserable defeats. I’ll continue doing so.
What I won’t do is defend the indefensible simply because the man responsible has delivered two World Cups.
As the sandpaper-gate refuses to die down with Cricket Australia creating a forum for players to air their views, this prophetic prediction of the great Shane Warne hits differently.