←
Rafael R. Guthmann10,987 posts
Rafael R. Guthmann avatar

Rafael R. Guthmann

@GuthmannR

Economist (papers.ssrn.com/sol3/cf_dev/…)

◷ Joined March 2019▧ 1,370 Photos and videos
Rafael R. Guthmann avatar
Rafael R. Guthmann@GuthmannR·3h

Brazilians also have a claim of inventing full-length computer-animated feature films because of Cassiopeia; even though Toy Story was released 2 months earlier, they claim it was not a "fully computer-animated film" for technical reasons: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cassio… This claim employs analogous logic to the argument for Santos Dummond having the claim of inventing the airplane.

So apparently Brazil legitimately teaches that the Wright Brothers didn't invent the airplane. This might be nuttier than denying the moon landing. The Wrights documented their invention quite well.

Renato Perim Colistete avatar
⟳ Rafael R. Guthmann retweeted
Renato Perim Colistete@RPColistete·13h

Fazendeiro de Brotas-SP organiza caça a colonos austríacos que haviam fugido de sua propriedade e captura idoso e algumas crianças, relata um jornal em 1886. (1/2)

Post attachment
Rafael R. Guthmann avatar
Rafael R. Guthmann@GuthmannR·9h

Na verdade, não é uma suposta "resistência" a aumentar impostos, mas o fato de o Brasil já ter uma carga tributária extrema para seu nível de renda e, portanto, capacidade de pagar: nosso código tributário já é o mais complexo do mundo e a receita tributária não tem espaço para aumentar pelo aumento de impostos. A partir de agora, a criação de novos impostos só vai deprimir ainda mais a atividade econômica formal. Não existe saída além de 1) Lula renunciar e Alckmin assumir, o que mudaria completamente as expectativas dos agentes (como foi com o Temer), ou 2) promover uma mudança de 180 graus na política fiscal do governo, com cortes robustos na trajetória de gastos futuros, para também mudar completamente as expectativas dos agentes com relação à solvência fiscal do governo. Não acho que nenhum dos dois vá ocorrer. O que acho que vai ocorrer é uma grande crise, provavelmente hiperinflacionária, como nos anos 80.

O governo aumentou a carga tributária em 2.p.p. do PIB e ainda assim temos um déficit primário de 0,6%. Como contrapartida, nenhum aumento de investimento, nem melhoria na educação e saúde. E ainda deixam +10p.p. do PIB de endividamento para as futuras gerações, com um insustentável custo de dívida. Será que não entenderam a resistência em aumentar impostos sem a contrapartida de oferecer eficiência e melhoria na qualidade dos gastos?

Post attachment
Rafael R. Guthmann avatar
Rafael R. Guthmann@GuthmannR·Nov 13

It's useful to consider GDP normalized by international comparisons of real output: normalizing the growth rate using US GDP as the yardstick, using PPP benchmark estimates. In this context, Brazilian underperformance is not as bad, as Brazil is growing a bit faster than developed countries like the US and Japan, but much slower than India, Indonesia, Russia, China, and many other major developing economies. The basic picture remains the same: output per working-age person in other developing economies grew 150% to 200% more than in Brazil since the year 2000, while Brazilian growth has been closer to that of a mature economy than that of a dynamic developing economy. There are several reasons why GDP growth changes with PPP comparisons. The basic reason is that GDP is being measured using prices of many countries instead of local prices; the second reason is that different countries do not follow exactly the same methodology to compute their growth rates. For example, US national accounts incorporate much more quality adjustment than Brazilian national accounts, and Chinese national accounts are said to incorporate even more generous quality adjustments than American accounts.

Post attachment

Comparing Brazil with 6 major countries (which are all the countries in the world with a population larger than 140 million people and with an area over 1 million square kilometers, plus Japan): growth in GDP per person aged 15-64 in Brazil has been slower than even Japan's over the 21st century. Given Brazil's level of development, expected growth would have been as fast as Russia's or Indonesia's, roughly 4 times the realized growth. Calling 21st-century Brazil a growth disaster feels like a euphemism. Especially when you consider that Brazil was one of the world's fastest-growing economies from 1900 to 1980.

Post attachment
Rafael R. Guthmann avatar
Rafael R. Guthmann@GuthmannR·Nov 13

Com o ajuste fiscal anemico que estao fazendo, vamos descobrir onde esse ponto está logo logo. 😉😱

Rapaziada não vejo muito essa discussão mas nos temos 80% do PIB em dívida. Praticamente ela inteira tá em BRL. Até que ponto do PIB poderia nosso mercado aguentar rolar os juros dela?

Rafael R. Guthmann avatar
Rafael R. Guthmann@GuthmannR·Nov 9

Adjusting for the cost of living they make about 18k a year in US prices (more if you consider the differential in rent costs is much greater than the PPP converter). I made slightly more than that as a PhD student in Minnesota. Considering Brazil's GDP per capita, they make slightly more in proportion to the average national income than Harvard's PhD students. It is also comparable in magnitude to Chilean stipends for PhD students (about 20k in PPP terms).

A PhD student in Brazil receives approximately US$ 563 per month in scholarship funding ~~~ just US$ 6,751 a year. That’s the tweet.

Rafael R. Guthmann avatar
Rafael R. Guthmann@GuthmannR·Nov 8

The Brazilian political system has proven to be dysfunctional to the point that it systematically yields fiscally populist policies that break the federal budget and cause systemic macroeconomic instability, sabotaging long-term growth. The solution is to change the political system. I would support a system like Switzerland's, where there is not a single all-powerful head of state/government but a federal council with seven members and a strong parliament that elects this council. In addition to systemic popular participation in referendums. Such a system would have stronger checks and balances on any fiscally populist policies that could undermine macroeconomic stability. As shown by Switzerland's disciplined fiscal policies.

What would be a solution shock therapy? Doge to reduce expenditures and fiscally conservative policy?

Rafael R. Guthmann avatar
Rafael R. Guthmann@GuthmannR·Nov 8

Pessoa defende o que se chama de calote via inflacao: para reduzir a divida/PIB, o governo federal infla o PIB. Em outras palavras, se os precos dobram, a divida real cai pela metade. Vai destruir boa parte do patrimonio da classe rentista que vive de CDI, mas vai beneficiar empresas com dividas e a bolsa pode até subir muito en termos reais (como ocorreu na Turquía). Nao é nem um pouco sustentavel porque pode destruir a moeda com aceleracao inflacionaria em direcao a hiperinflacao, alem danificar o sistema bancario e o mercado de titulos da divida pública.

O Samuel Pessôa fala em dominância do setor real. A inflação de 2027 tem cara de 6% e pediria juro mais alto, mas empresa e família já tão no osso, e o aperto viraria onda de recuperação judicial. Aí o BC aceitaria a inflação subindo. A Selic de 13,75% é a de jan/2023.

Post attachment
Rafael R. Guthmann avatar
Rafael R. Guthmann@GuthmannR·Nov 8

The problem is that they are not aware of how other countries, like the aforementioned ones, as well as smaller countries such as Turkey, Poland, Romania, Chile, etc., improved much more over the same period. Brazilians see their incomes improve 30-40% over the past 20 years and think things are actually going well. This impression of improvement is especially pronounced among people who receive welfare or work for the government: federal primary expenditures per capita increased nearly 200% over the past 20 years and sharply diverged from the macroeconomic trajectory. However, we have now reached a point where there is no room for further increases in government expenditures without economic growth, as real interest rates on government bonds are surpassing 10% and the debt/GDP ratio is quickly increasing.

I believe brazilian, even the most educated ones are not aware or prepared to discuss how much their nation has failed over this century so far