←
Harry Surden8,532 posts
Harry Surden avatar

Harry Surden

@HarrySurden

Professor, University of Colorado Law School • Associate Director Stanford CodeX Center for Legal Informatics. Research: Artificial Intelligence and Law

◷ Joined April 2014▧ 452 Photos and videos
Harry Surden avatar
Harry Surden@HarrySurden·Nov 15

Despite impressive benchmark results, the new @Google Gemini 4 models remain a distant third for programming and knowledge work in my personal testing, Behind @Anthropic Claude Fable 5.2 and Opus 5.5 models (the clear leaders), followed by @OpenAI GPT-6 Astra.

UChicago Law School avatar
⟳ Harry Surden retweeted
UChicago Law School@UChicagoLaw·Nov 11

We mourn the loss of Senior Lecturer Richard Allen Posner, a longtime #UChicagoLaw scholar, former federal appellate judge, and pioneer in the field of law and economics, who died on November 10. Read more about his legacy: buff.ly/e3c3WdL

Post attachment
Ebby Amir avatar
⟳ Harry Surden retweeted
Ebby Amir@ebbyamir·Nov 10

I turned Van Gogh riding through his Starry Night into a game with Fable 5.2 Play it here: starrynightrider.com

0:53
Phil Weiser avatar
⟳ Harry Surden retweeted
Phil Weiser@pweiser·Nov 4

So overwhelmed with gratitude and excited for the work ahead. I appreciate the hundreds of people who leaned in and I am honored to have the opportunity to serve and take on the important work ahead, as I shared in my speech last night. youtu.be/64MRA5UB3Ac?si=q16O…

Post attachmentPost attachmentPost attachment
9NEWS Denver avatar
⟳ Harry Surden retweeted
9NEWS Denver@9NEWS·Nov 4

Democrat Phil Weiser will be Colorado's next governor, the Associated Press projects.

Post attachment
Erik Brynjolfsson avatar
⟳ Harry Surden retweeted
Erik Brynjolfsson@erikbryn·Nov 3

Don’t take democracy for granted. Please vote and remind your friends and family to vote.

Post attachment
Alex Krentsel avatar
⟳ Harry Surden retweeted
Alex Krentsel@AlexKrentsel·Nov 2

i've reproduced the results from the MIT blog post today on weight-space programming. but one additional result i have to add: this is a new, step-change emerging capability that's appeared in just the latest set of models.

Post attachment
Alex Tamkin avatar
⟳ Harry Surden retweeted
Alex Tamkin@AlexTamkin·Oct 27

New Anthropic research: How AI agents shape experts' judgment calls When experts delegate work to an agent, do they still make the key decisions? We tested this in a randomized trial with 50 professional data analysts.

0:15
Jason Furman avatar
⟳ Harry Surden retweeted
Jason Furman@jasonfurman·Oct 24

I asked Claude how much it would have taken to develop Econvitals pre-coding agents. It's answer: a team of about 50 people working for three years with a budget of $20 million. Is this correct or too high? I'm not sure. econvitals.org/about/before-…

Jason Furman avatar
⟳ Harry Surden retweeted
Jason Furman@jasonfurman·Oct 23

The website & email sign-up list. Emails on anything from analysis of major data releases minutes after they're released to daily roundups of economic news to weekly analyses of the U.S., European & Chinese economies. econvitals.org/subscribe/ econvitals.org/

Jason Wei avatar
⟳ Harry Surden retweeted
Jason Wei@_jasonwei·Oct 19

AI will not automate radiologists like you think We have been talking for years now about AI automating jobs. Radiology has been a prime target, with Geoff Hinton once claiming, “people should stop training radiologists now, it’s just completely obvious that within five years, deep learning is going to do better than radiologists”, which is funny since he said that in 2016. There is now more demand for radiologists than ever, so clearly things did not turn out the way many thought. Here I will make a prediction that while radiology will change in the coming decade, radiologists will not be automated away any time soon. I will use radiology as an example but I think these principles will broadly apply to any field where demand can be elastic and quality can scale with increased intelligence. First of all, we have seen in the short history of language models that there is a “jagged edge of intelligence”, where AI excels at verifiable tasks with a lot of data but is underwhelming on less common tasks. One thing most AI researchers underestimate about radiology is that it is actually extremely multi-task. There are at least a hundred conditions that can be diagnosed from x-rays alone, and thousands using CT and MRI. AI will first master common and easy-to-see conditions and it will not be as good as experts at less-common diseases just because there is less data for that. This jagged edge will certainly improve over time but this means that AI will certainly be used as a triage tool at first, rather than full automation in one go. I would guess that this process from solid triage tool to full automation would take 3-5 years in the best case scenario, because training AI to get all the edge cases right will be bottlenecked by data collection of rare diseases, and also because radiology isn’t currently a focus for frontier labs. Second, there will be elastic demand for radiology as it gets cheaper per unit. I think elastic demand (“Jevons paradox”) is the most underrated phenomenon when people think about AI automation. In software, it is obvious that I have way more demand than before because Claude Code makes it so easy. These days I ask Claude Code to build a custom three-thousand line html viewer to help me visualize every little RL run that I do. The same thing will happen in radiology. If there is essentially no cost or latency of interpreting an MRI, a physician can order many scans preemptively to better diagnose a case. So with AI tools, a radiologist might have to read only 20% of inbound scans, but there might be 5x more scans inbound. Many developing countries have fewer than one radiologist per million people and they will also want to send a lot of radiology to be interpreted. Longer term, cheap and fast radiology interpretation will also drive incentives to build cheaper radiology scanners. If an MRI had essentially no latency for interpretation, medical devices companies will want to build much cheaper MRI machines that can be used more frequently, perhaps even in the middle of a surgery. AI will accelerate the development of scanning technology, too. If a full body MRI was only $100 dollars I would totally want to get one every month instead of every two years. I can imagine a world where people get 10 or 100x the number of scans they do today, largely for preventative care, if radiology were 10-100x cheaper. Third, even if we did have a model that could outperform the world’s best radiologists today, that would not be the end of all work on radiology. Medicine is a field of change. We may develop new treatment protocols that require reading radiology images in a way that radiologists currently aren’t used to. New scanners may reveal diseases that we cannot currently diagnose today with radiology alone. Some radiologists will change their work from reading scans to doing frontier research to advance our understanding of radiology and translate new knowledge into updated models. Moreover, I am sure that we will ask for more out of our AI models than ever before. With a good flywheel, we may one day train AI models that can use radiology images to predict disease probabilities far into the future. With good prediction algorithms, cancer may be detected months earlier than we can detect it now. Society will invest a lot into this research and this will contribute even more to increased demand for radiology and the best AI around it. On top of all of this, the medical system is typically slower to adopt new technology and has more regulation compared to technology companies. There is legacy infrastructure and medical centers need to constantly support patients which makes it hard to integrate new technology. This is even more true in developing countries. Moreover data access tends to be limited due to HIPAA, deidentification, IRBs, etc. So I think radiologists will be in demand for a while. While some worry about radiology being totally automated, I think there is a more exciting future for radiology than ever before—one where there is more demand and we ask for more predictive power from our intelligence. This is similar to how many of us feel that programming will thrive more than ever before despite drastic change in the field. More generally, any domain where demand can be elastic and quality can scale with increased intelligence will, like radiology, similarly flourish with the development of AI. This is certainly a more exciting and nuanced future than what Hinton described in 2016! (Finally, to be fair to Hinton, he did acknowledge in a recent podcast that he was wrong and also agrees with the elastic demand argument.) Thanks @JayRothschild and @engyziedan for feedback on this post.

Ryan Sael avatar
⟳ Harry Surden retweeted
Ryan Sael@RyanSael·Oct 19

IKEA manuals, but they come to life. I built the real BILLY instructions in 3D, so you can watch every step happen exactly as drawn. try it: sael.net/flatpack

0:32
Cheng Lou avatar
⟳ Harry Surden retweeted
Cheng Lou@_chenglou·Oct 15

My dear friends, I’d like to show you my latest toy project Introducing Handwired: turn your regular JavaScript code into a neural net! - no training - exact outputs vs the JS program - fully differentiable All runnable in a browser, without GPU

0:08
Peter McCrory avatar
⟳ Harry Surden retweeted
Peter McCrory@PeterMcCrory·Sep 24

I've learned a lot from @jasonfurman over the years. So, it was a real privilege to join him on stage for a great conversation discussing the economic implications of AI. I appreciated the audience's patience with us as it got a bit wonky at points. Fortunately, Jason told me afterward that I only used the phrase "infinitely elastic" once. While Jason's questions were great, I was particularly impressed by and thankful for the questions that the students asked during and after the event. Ensuring that the benefits of AI are broad-based and risks are appropriately mitigated requires that we ask hard questions — with AI, there are many.

What happens to jobs, productivity, inequality, and economic policy as AI transforms the way we work? Anthropic Chief Economist @PeterMcCrory and economist @JasonFurman took to the JFK Jr. Forum stage to explore these questions and more. ken.sc/forum0923-live

Post attachmentPost attachmentPost attachmentPost attachment