←
Iain Ballantyne30,449 posts
Iain Ballantyne avatar

Iain Ballantyne

@IBallantyn

Editor @WarshipsIFR Author 'Martin's Eyes' (out now), 'Hunter Killers', 'Killing the Bismarck' & 'The Deadly Trade' + more. Rep @PFDAgents Warships Pod host.

◷ Joined April 2015▧ 3,372 Photos and videos
Iain Ballantyne avatar
Iain Ballantyne@IBallantyn·Nov 14

My thanks to 'CrazyIvan' for a 5 star review for my novel 'Martin's Eyes' @chiselbury 'An outstanding novel, crafted by a masterful storyteller. The plot has a depth not often found in WW2 fiction, with a good balance of psychological tension and action, and I heartily recommend it to anyone interested in thrillers.' amzn.eu/d/0ea5SgMY #Amazon via @AmazonUK

Gabriele Molinelli avatar
⟳ Iain Ballantyne retweeted
Gabriele Molinelli@Gabriel64869839·13h

Using USVs for persistent surveillance of infrastructure and "spying" on traffic in home waters will work very well. Using them as a "replacement" for patrol vessels in actually shadowing passing russian ships might resolve in humiliation. Using uncrewed, unarmed K3s anywhere near a russian ship is inviting them to sink or capture them. And if they do, a strongly worded protest will follow, of course, but ultimately you'll be the idiot and they will laugh at you. Because it is. It is an absolutely laughable proposition and it better not be the great thinking for how to replace RIVER batch 1.

Ancient Mariner avatar
⟳ Iain Ballantyne retweeted
Ancient Mariner@pegge49·14h

Not really sure how the comment that 'several Type 23s have already been retired' and the handover is being 'managed' is credible, when you consider that five T23s have been withdrawn in the past 2.5 years, whilst at best we can hope HMS Glasgow will now start sea trials in 2027. x.com/UKDefJournal/status/21…

John Aitken OBE avatar
⟳ Iain Ballantyne retweeted
John Aitken OBE@johnaitken69·12h

This is a really significant concern. I recently heard Professor Jon Bew argue that industrial capacity and capability was a National Security issue and I agree with him. Shipbuilding and steel making are critical enablers for the defence of the realm.

The British steel industry is in crisis with growing concerns over domestic supply for naval shipbuilding. Liberty Steel’s Dalzell plate mill at Motherwell faces an uncertain future. The plant is supposed to be suppling around 34,000 tonnes of steel plate for the 3 Fleet Solid Support ships. Financial difficulties threaten production. Parent company GFG Alliance remains under severe financial pressure. Delayed wages, unpaid bills and disrupted services. Questions over whether Dalzell can fulfil its commitments. Speciality Steel UK entered compulsory liquidation in 2025. A major producer of specialist steels for defence, aerospace and energy. The government is considering acquisition to preserve strategically important production capacity. Liberty Steel Newport also in liquidation. Production already suspended for several years. Further erosion of domestic steelmaking capacity. British shipbuilders increasingly dependent on imported steel and specialist products. Particular vulnerabilities in high-grade plate, castings and forgings. Some critical materials available from very few domestic suppliers. Government intervention could preserve parts of the industry, but substantial investment needed to modernise ageing facilities and restore competitive production. The @SocMaritimeInd warns that insufficient domestic capacity and unreliable demand threaten the wider maritime supply chain. Steel producers need long-term contracts to justify investment. Shipbuilders need reliable deliveries at competitive prices. The UK has committed billions to naval construction but the steel supply chain is in danger of collapse threatening a foundational sovereign manufacturing capability.

Post attachment
Good Shepherd avatar
⟳ Iain Ballantyne retweeted
Good Shepherd@HoyasFan07·Nov 17

It is unlikely the Kremlin will decide to launch a major kinetic military attack against a NATO member let alone multiple NATO members as long as the Kremlin believes it would need to fight most of the NATO alliance (due to article V). The Kremlin understands that this would not end well for the Russian military and, ultimately, the political elites at the top of the Russian state, since NATO's forces are qualitatively superior to what Russia has. If Russia launches a war of choice against NATO and then suffers catastrophic and humiliating losses - and severe economic pain - it could jeopardize the regime's hold on power. As long as NATO is cohesive, the Russians will likely not attack. NATO cohesion is the key pillar of effective deterrence. This has been true for over 70 years.

The problem with Russians isn't that they can defeat Europe or have any hope of it, but like any terrorist regime they will try to murder as many European civilians as possible before Russia is completely annihilated. Just like in Ukraine, the worse they lose the more they lash out desperately trying to murder as many civilians as possible. Russia can't beat Europe, but if they ever attack they might manage to murder 10s of thousands of European civilians before they are fully stomped into the ground.

Robert Forsyth avatar
⟳ Iain Ballantyne retweeted
Robert Forsyth@RStanleyForsyth·Nov 17

The MoD PR is in overdrive turning the disaster of a 7 month patrol into a ‘glorious defeat’ achieved only through the amazing endurance of crews. Let’s hope no lasting mental damage but it should not be perpetuated

SOFS, DPM, CDS, 1SL 🙌

Robert Forsyth avatar
⟳ Iain Ballantyne retweeted
Robert Forsyth@RStanleyForsyth·Nov 17

And here is a very senior and experienced retired submariner expressing his measured concerns all the more concerning observing his former post.

Post attachment
🇺🇸𝗢𝗹𝗱 𝗦𝘂𝗯𝗺𝗮𝗿𝗶𝗻𝗲𝗿⚓️ avatar
⟳ Iain Ballantyne retweeted
🇺🇸𝗢𝗹𝗱 𝗦𝘂𝗯𝗺𝗮𝗿𝗶𝗻𝗲𝗿⚓️@USN_Submariner·Nov 16

The radical "Advanced Sail" design was originally planned to be introduced in mid-Block II Virginia-class boats, then rumored pushed to Block IV, but ultimately cancelled. We have the acoustic research though. The Advanced Sail was installed & tested in 1999 on the Acoustic Research Detachment's Large Scale Vehicle Kokanee (LSV-I), a quarter scale UUV model of Seawolf.

Post attachment
HMS Stirling Castle avatar
⟳ Iain Ballantyne retweeted
HMS Stirling Castle@HMS_Str_Castle·Nov 16

Sailing off in to the sunset. Hopefully the weather holds out. 🌊☀️ Thanks to our pilot James Gould for the photos.

Post attachmentPost attachment
Ancient Mariner avatar
⟳ Iain Ballantyne retweeted
Ancient Mariner@pegge49·Nov 16

100% this👇 The sort of drones the RN will need for patrolling the North Atlantic, are nothing like the Ukrainian attack drones or the Rattler and Kraken drones the RN has currently in service.

There is nothing magical about uncrewed vehicles. Small, cheap platforms do some things and absolutely cannot do more than that. They can be a great complement, but taking the crew out of a hull does not in any way allow you to somehow magically do in 12 meters what a 140 meters ship does. The question i keep waiting an answer on from the Royal Navy is what is rock bottom to even qualify as an "uncrewed escort". The truth is that we do not even know yet what the level of ambition even is for Type 91, for example. How can we possibly even comment on the feasibility of an Hybrid Fleet vision when said vision isn't even explained? The 1st Sea Lord insists the Navy is not "going too fast". I don't know. It might be going too slow in ways and too fast in others. We don't really know that. The truth is that nobody yet has a real clue what a Type 91 will be able to fire; what kind of organic sensors it might have; nor do we know what a Type 94 sensor load is supposed to be. There's a long, long way to go from putting a GIRAFFE 1X on a 8 meters K3 USV to delivering an "uncrewed escort". USVs are more of a FLOWER corvette than a replacement for higher end escorts. In particular, until someone provides an actual vision of what a CCV-Type 91-Type 94 combination is even supposed to be capable of, ALL doubts remain entirely justified.

Gabriele Molinelli avatar
⟳ Iain Ballantyne retweeted
Gabriele Molinelli@Gabriel64869839·Nov 16

There is nothing magical about uncrewed vehicles. Small, cheap platforms do some things and absolutely cannot do more than that. They can be a great complement, but taking the crew out of a hull does not in any way allow you to somehow magically do in 12 meters what a 140 meters ship does. The question i keep waiting an answer on from the Royal Navy is what is rock bottom to even qualify as an "uncrewed escort". The truth is that we do not even know yet what the level of ambition even is for Type 91, for example. How can we possibly even comment on the feasibility of an Hybrid Fleet vision when said vision isn't even explained? The 1st Sea Lord insists the Navy is not "going too fast". I don't know. It might be going too slow in ways and too fast in others. We don't really know that. The truth is that nobody yet has a real clue what a Type 91 will be able to fire; what kind of organic sensors it might have; nor do we know what a Type 94 sensor load is supposed to be. There's a long, long way to go from putting a GIRAFFE 1X on a 8 meters K3 USV to delivering an "uncrewed escort". USVs are more of a FLOWER corvette than a replacement for higher end escorts. In particular, until someone provides an actual vision of what a CCV-Type 91-Type 94 combination is even supposed to be capable of, ALL doubts remain entirely justified.

Cheap drones will not replace big warships in the North Atlantic, where navies must stay at sea for months and carry heavy striking power, Norway's top operational commander says. ukdefencejournal.org.uk/nort…

Paul Halton avatar
⟳ Iain Ballantyne retweeted
Paul Halton@PVHaltonOBE·Nov 15

Sacrifice. Professionalism. Duty. Commitment.

Today, 140 submariners were reunited with their families. For the past 7 months they have made enormous sacrifices to keep our nation safe. They represent the best of the @RoyalNavy. Today was an opportunity for me to thank them for everything they do on behalf of all of us.

Post attachmentPost attachmentPost attachmentPost attachment
Ancient Mariner avatar
⟳ Iain Ballantyne retweeted
Ancient Mariner@pegge49·Nov 15

A grim read on the completion of a record breaking patrol and one that should be a compulsory read for any politician on the consequences of delays. Hopefully lesson's will be learnt for future programs, but sadly one suspects in this age of spin over substance they won't be...

Latest news commentary: Royal Navy Trident submarine completes record 217-day patrol navylookout.com/royal-navy-t… Photos @MichaelGDeveney @ScotlandDX

Post attachment
Steve Scrase avatar
⟳ Iain Ballantyne retweeted
Steve Scrase@StevenScrase·Nov 15

There is nothing quite as insulting as a Westminster photo op built on the backs of exhausted men. The only reason HMS Vengeance was at sea long enough to break endurance records is because politicians refused to fund the maintenance infrastructure required to bring her home on schedule. The political class forced this crew into a 217 day psychological pressure cooker just to mask their own failure to build dry docks. For a cabinet minister to now use that exact same crew as a prop for social media engagement is beneath contempt. True respect for the military involves funding them properly, not putting on a navy jacket for half an hour to farm likes on the internet.

Throughout the time they have been at sea, no one has done more for the defence of the United Kingdom and our allies than the crew of HMS Vengeance. The privilege of welcoming them home, and spending some time with their families, was a humbling and awe-inspiring experience - one that will stay with me for the rest of my life. They can be so proud of their service to our country. The same is true for their families, who sacrifice so much to support them. We do not take this for granted. The UK's nuclear deterrent is the ultimate National Endeavour and the cornerstone of our national security. Every minute of every day, it deters our adversaries and keeps our country safe. We commit our nuclear deterrent to NATO and that commitment to our allies is unshakeable. We've committed £63.6 billion over the next four years to the Defence Nuclear Enterprise, creating and sustaining good, high-skilled jobs and protecting the whole of the UK for decades to come. The Vanguard class continues to serve our country well - for longer than was intended - and Dreadnought is on its way. BZ Vengeance. Heroes all.

Post attachmentPost attachmentPost attachmentPost attachment
Tom Cotterill avatar
⟳ Iain Ballantyne retweeted
Tom Cotterill@TomCotterillX·Nov 15

I spent the day on HMS Vengeance, one of Britain’s four nuclear-armed submarines, as she arrived back today to Scotland. It was an incredible - and humbling - experience. More to come on that! She has spent more than seven months underwater keeping the UK safe. It’s a record but one that comes with a massive sacrifice for the ship’s company. dailymail.com/news/article-1…