←
PaperImperium12,892 posts
PaperImperium avatar

PaperImperium

@ImperiumPaper
◷ Joined July 2021▧ 1,308 Photos and videos
PaperImperium avatar
PaperImperium@ImperiumPaper·May 23

A major unforced error in crypto is treating technical dashboards as financial dashboards. Nowhere is this as obvious as with TVL of lending protocols. TVL is NOT a substitute for accounting! Let’s look at TVL defined as “Value of all coins held in smart contracts of the protocol”, and how it would treat a bank with the following balance sheet: Deposits (a liability): $100m Loans (an asset): $80m Reserves (an asset): $20m Equity: $10m The TVL of this simplified balance sheet would show up as: $100m deposits - $80m loans + $10m equity = $30m TVL Does that feel accurate to you? It should not, because it structurally undercounts economic activity. In fact, TVL - a technical metric - is treating the bank’s largest asset (its loan book) as a liability and largest liability (its deposits) as an asset! The problem is one of using the wrong tool for the job. TVL counts how many tokens are in a smart contract or group of affiliated smart contracts. That’s it. In its most simple form, TVL is mostly just counting the reserve ratio of the bank (or lending protocol). TVL is not a substitute for actual accounting, and people need to understand this. A deposit on Aave/Morpho/SparkLend/Compound/Euler/Curvance is a liability to that protocol or pool. You could put $1 trillion in deposits onto one of those platforms and TVL would become $1 trillion. But that’s not an indication of economic activity! Now imagine $999.999 billion of that got lent out. TVL has crashed from $1 trillion to $1 million. Looks bad on a chart, right? But now we’re seeing economic activity! There is a reason why TVL is not used outside of crypto - it is a technical metric, not a financial one, and any overlap is coincidental and concentrated in very basic protocols like DEXes.

PaperImperium avatar
PaperImperium@ImperiumPaper·7h

I actually think there’s a lot of room fir DeFi to provide insurance substitutes, and in a way that minimizes counterparty risks and administrative overhead. Financial history also shows how much more innovative DeFi could be if it wanted to do more than DEXs, lending, and perps

PaperImperium avatar
PaperImperium@ImperiumPaper·7h

Unfortunately for the bankers, there was a major risk they couldn’t diversify away - the French Crown. After the Revolution, one of the many things to be haircut were these annuities - mostly by altering the terms so they would be correctly priced for young annuitants.

PaperImperium avatar
PaperImperium@ImperiumPaper·7h

Step 4: Not to be outdone by Swiss bankers, Dutch bankers buy shares in many pools, then wrap THOSE and sell shares. Composability for the win!

PaperImperium avatar
PaperImperium@ImperiumPaper·7h

Step 3: Leverage. The annuities typically paid 10%, but with the pooling to diversify exposure, you could borrow against the shares at 5% or so in France. I’m sure you can see how the looping occurs; DeFi would love this product.

PaperImperium avatar
PaperImperium@ImperiumPaper·7h

Step 2: Securitize the income from the pool. Sell shares in it. Shareholders got the income, minus administrative expenses (like proving to the Crown these girls in Switzerland were alive every year)

PaperImperium avatar
PaperImperium@ImperiumPaper·7h

Here’s how the bankers’ process worked: Step 1: Buy annuities on girls 5-10y. Girls live longer. All must have survived smallpox or been inoculated. Do this for a large group at once. 30 girls was typical. This means any death reduces income by only 1/30th.

PaperImperium avatar
PaperImperium@ImperiumPaper·7h

Some bankers in Geneva took a simple life annuity and simultaneously arbitraged it and securitized it. You could take out the annuity on a 3rd party, but most didn’t up until that point. You had to prove they were alive annually which incurred expenses, even if they were willing

PaperImperium avatar
PaperImperium@ImperiumPaper·7h

As the Seven Years’ War ran up military expenses and strained the Crown’s ability to raise money (and do it quickly), annuities from the Crown shifted from being age-graded to a single flat rate. For a while, this was ok as adults bought them. But then bankers got involved.

PaperImperium avatar
PaperImperium@ImperiumPaper·7h

Early modern France had some remarkable experiments in finance, mostly to finance wars. Tontines and assignats were a few. Selling life annuities was another. The first few years, they did a good job - tontines had provided actuarial data on life expectancy. But it didn’t last

PaperImperium avatar
PaperImperium@ImperiumPaper·23h

Don’t forget the 4% 476-year bond from a railroad that doesn’t exist anymore (West Shore RR). Issued 1885 and matures 2361.

Obscure bond content? Count me in. Here's my list: Canadian Pacific Railway 4 PERPs. Perpetual railway debt dating to 1889! Still trades (sometimes)! JC Penney 7.625 2097s. A 100-year loan to a mall retailer, issued in 1997. It made it 23 years. Las Vegas Monorail 5.375 2040s. Las Vegas Monorail. Guess how this played out? Tesla 5.3 2025s. First and only HY issue by Tesla. Traded down to the low 80s at one point. Called in 2021.

PaperImperium avatar
PaperImperium@ImperiumPaper·Nov 17

Probably didn’t hurt that Pope Leo X’s original name was d’Medici

“Lending is meritorious” This was a big shift in Catholic views on interest when uttered by Pope Leo X. Usury was a sin, and being a usurer often meant exclusion from social, religious, or civic positions. So why did the pope sound like a fintech (it was 1515)?

Post attachment
PaperImperium avatar
PaperImperium@ImperiumPaper·Nov 17

The western tradition of slowly embracing loans and banking rather than having a prohibition on interest owes a lot to some monks’ writing that convinced the pope a pawn shop should stay open. (Don’t forget to include opp cost & risk in your own opinion of a just interest rate!)

PaperImperium avatar
PaperImperium@ImperiumPaper·Nov 17

Fast forward and we have a happy world today where even DeFi lending is “meritorious and should be praised”. Interestingly, Pope Leo’s moral justification largely came from the poverty-sworn Franciscans, whose early work on opportunity cost and risk premium helped him get there.

PaperImperium avatar
PaperImperium@ImperiumPaper·Nov 17

This was a big breakthrough. Interest itself was still usury unless used to offset the cost of running the fund - profits then needed to be disposed of through charity. Over time, things like risk premium and opportunity cost were included beyond covering facilities & salaries

PaperImperium avatar
PaperImperium@ImperiumPaper·Nov 17

It’s worth keeping in mind that these pawn shops were nonprofit - the interest paid for the administration of the fund, which used donated funds to provide pawn services to the poor. Pope Leo X took the position that the *act* of lending was itself a good activity.