←
IndeMed196 posts
IndeMed avatar

IndeMed

@IndeMedAction

IndeMed is a physician-led organization dedicated to protecting the integrity and fair implementation of the No Surprises Act.

◷ Joined November 2025▧ 56 Photos and videos
Adam Bruggeman, MD avatar
⟳ IndeMed retweeted
Adam Bruggeman, MD@DrBruggeman·Nov 12

Well, if plans can treat binding federal arbitration awards as optional when they dislike the process or number, then by the same logic physicians who view the latest PFS conversion factor, wRVU, and budget neutrality cuts as systematically unfair should simply balance bill Medicare patients for the amount they feel is fair. Of course if that happened, we all know how many doctors would be prosecuted vs how many insurers are being prosecuted for not paying arbitration awards. Unfortunately neither law has a “but the number feels wrong” exception.

.@sarahkliff and I reported recently on how insurers and ERISA plans have stopped paying certain arbitration awards they said were invalid or unreasonable. This piece has some new quotes on that point.

Post attachment
IndeMed avatar
IndeMed@IndeMedAction·Nov 12

Health plans keep losing in arbitration, so now they want to change the rules. A No Surprises Act benchmark would let insurers set the price and grade their own homework. ❌Patients pay the price with a benchmark. ✅Keep the referee. Learn more about benchmarks: indemed.org/keep-the-referee…

Post attachment
Adam Bruggeman, MD avatar
⟳ IndeMed retweeted
Adam Bruggeman, MD@DrBruggeman·Nov 4

We should be careful not to assume here. The notice specifically cites 45 CFR 149.510(e). Looking back at the July FAQ, that’s the section on performance standards. Those standards are: 1) Timely determinations 2) Accurate eligibility/payment determinations within statutory guidelines 3) Rationales that meet regulatory requirements 4) Proper fee handling 5) Conflict of Interest Screening Picking one side, whether provider or plan, too often isn’t included in this FAQ. The Department couldn’t decertify due to picking one side or another unless they failed to use statute, which only requires them to consider certain factors but doesn’t dictate the outcome. CMS had already stopped routing new disputes to both IPRO and Network Medical Review before today, which was the same step it took in 2023 for those with backlogged IDREs. This appears to be a throughput issue, not an outcomes issue. We will need to wait until CMS releases the actual basis (if at all). @IndeMedAction

Adam Bruggeman, MD avatar
⟳ IndeMed retweeted
Adam Bruggeman, MD@DrBruggeman·Nov 5

Again, we have the information on why the groups were singled out. See my post previously. Nowhere in the justification does it show that they were done for selecting physicians 96% of the time. The attached graph shows this has nothing to do with selection rate (as does the approval of the other organizations for another 5 years). IDREs are struggling to keep up with volume in some instances. Groups are reporting long delays to fee refunds, which further suggests that some IDREs have not been able to work within statutory guidelines x.com/drbruggeman/status/211…

The Trump administration plans to oust two No Surprises arbitration firms, as the law draws more scrutiny for its high payouts to doctors. We don't know why these two were singled out. We do know one let doctors win 96 percent of the time.

Post attachment
Adam Bruggeman, MD avatar
⟳ IndeMed retweeted
Adam Bruggeman, MD@DrBruggeman·Nov 3

We’ve been saying this for a long time. I am thankful that others are now listening with the @nytimes publishing the data and story today. Insurers are openly breaking the law. They have asked employers to go along with it, and most have. This is an administration that has focused on law and order. Let’s see that same focus applied to the No Surprises Act

One new-to-me detail we learned in the course of our reporting: when Congress wrote the No Surprises Act, it ported over many parts of federal arbitration law. It did not, however, bring over key enforcement provisions. Without an enforcement mechanism, supposedly binding arbitration decisions are being ignored. nytimes.com/2026/11/03/us/in…

IndeMed avatar
IndeMed@IndeMedAction·Oct 24

When Dr. Will Flannery (@DGlaucomflecken) had a cardiac arrest during COVID, he received a $20,000 surprise bill form out-of-network physicians at the in-network hospital where he was taken. On the latest Knock Knock Hi podcast, he explains why the No Surprises Act matters and why insurers are now lobbying to change it. His key points line up with the data: 1. Patients are protected. The law took them out of the middle and arbitration only decides what the insurer owes to the physician 2. Physicians win most disputes because independent arbitrators, choosing between two offers, keep finding that the insurer’s number is too low 3. Insurer benchmarks track Medicare, which has cut physician pay for decades based on budgetary guidelines and is not a neutral yardstick. 4. Winning isn’t only on paper. Federal rules require payment within 30 days of an award, yet insurers routinely drag it out for months and don’t pay on roughly 40% of all claims. His final message: If Congress is going to revisit the NSA, then do it by enforcing prompt payment. Listen in here: youtube.com/watch?v=SoeX15xU…

Post attachment
IndeMed avatar
IndeMed@IndeMedAction·Oct 22

In 2020 insurers backed the No Surprises Act and agreed to let a neutral arbitrator settle payment disputes. Now they’re leaving that seat empty. Federal arbitration data shows insurers offered $1 or less 278,807 times. They offered $0 for CPR, emergency intubation and critical care for newborns. Each of those claims had already been ruled eligible. That isn’t negotiation. It’s a refusal to show up for a process insurers helped create. More from IndeMed: indemed.org/whats-your-care-…

Post attachment
Adam Bruggeman, MD avatar
⟳ IndeMed retweeted
Adam Bruggeman, MD@DrBruggeman·Oct 20

Federal law says an insurer has 30 days to pay a No Surprises Act arbitration award. Anthem is asking self-funded employers to let it violate the law by withholding instead, and told them that no answer to the request by September 14 would count as a yes. Three things employers should know: Every one of these awards was reviewed for eligibility by a federally certified IDR entity before it was issued. If Anthem thinks the IDR entity got it wrong, there is a process to reopen the dispute. The same federal guidance says payment is still due within 30 days "regardless of whether a request to reopen a closed dispute has been filed." Anthem's own letter says the employer carries ultimate responsibility under ERISA. Anthem is not asking employers to share a risk. It is asking them to take one on. What the law actually requires after an IDR decision: indemed.org/what-does-federa…

Federal law says pay in 30 days. Anthem is asking employers to let it withhold. Health insurers are steadily closing off one of the few remaining ways patients can still choose their own physicians and see independent, private practice physicians. Ahead of a September 14, 2026, deadline, Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield sent a notice to the self-funded employers whose plans it administers, asking them to approve Anthem’s practice of withholding payment on No Surprises Act arbitration determinations it has lost. Employers that did not respond by that date were told that their silence would count as authorization to keep withholding. There is no “withhold while we contest” option in the statute. More from IndeMed: indemed.org/what-does-federa…

Post attachment
Anish Koka, MD avatar
⟳ IndeMed retweeted
Anish Koka, MD@anish_koka·Oct 20

The No Surprises Act legislation is opposed by a number of conservative think tanks on the grounds that it is an unacceptable intervention by the government into the market that raises prices for consumers. But this is in the context of massive govt. intervention in the healthcare market that works to suppress prices. Some examples : Medicare prices are non negotiable and when accounting for inflation reimbursement to physicians is down ~30%. There is also no negotiation with commercial insurers if you are a solo hand surgeon or a small group of pediatricians. If you choose to go in-network .. you accept their prices that are massively discounted relative to what they pay larger systems and organizations who can and do negotiate. Independent Physicians can’t organize together to negotiate with insurers unless they clinically or financially integrate because the government has decided that would violate the Sherman act that bars price fixing. And yet Unions are allowed to collectively bargain on behalf of their members and this does raise prices to consumers. )The long term effect of not allowing physicians to bargain collectively is they either join health systems or integrate into a larger group. ) So.. no I don’t find it at all odd that physicians for once got together (thank you Texas) to create a little leverage for negotiating with insurance companies. If you don’t support the NSA then propose a different mechanism for negotiating that isn’t insurances being allowed to price set. The massive latitude given to insurance companies by the way hasn’t worked to curb healthcare inflation anyway. It’s amusing the latest talking point clearly sourced from insurance companies is on arbitrator profits. Here’s a list of large insurers and their profits in the last quarter. If we are going to play the game of what’s an appropriate amount for doctors to be paid and what profit is appropriate for intermediaries given the cost is ultimately borne by the public , why don’t we play the what insurers should make game as well? Since healthcare costs are so important — should we have a hard cap on insurer profits? Should we ask why CVS is passing on costs to consumers at the rate they do given they had $3billion in profit last quarter ?

Post attachment

The government also doesn’t allow me to coordinate with other Philadelphia cardiologists to negotiate with insurance companies unless I’m significantly clinically / financially integrated ( I forget exact working but it essentially requires me/Others to give up operational control ) Labor unions get a pass from collective bargaining precisely because society deemed it ok because of the asymmetry in power between corps and individual employees. That power imbalance is pretty similar between big insurance and independent physician. Want to curb NSA abuses.. go ahead.. but to call out this particular govt. intervention in the market while every other intervention is left in place for all the other players in the health care space is pretty off putting to physicians. That’s partly why there is such a degree of vitriol from physicians on the matter. Would you support a bill to do away with the NSA .. but give independent physicians an exemption from the Sherman act to negotiate together ala unions ?

IndeMed avatar
IndeMed@IndeMedAction·Oct 20

Federal law says pay in 30 days. Anthem is asking employers to let it withhold. Health insurers are steadily closing off one of the few remaining ways patients can still choose their own physicians and see independent, private practice physicians. Ahead of a September 14, 2026, deadline, Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield sent a notice to the self-funded employers whose plans it administers, asking them to approve Anthem’s practice of withholding payment on No Surprises Act arbitration determinations it has lost. Employers that did not respond by that date were told that their silence would count as authorization to keep withholding. There is no “withhold while we contest” option in the statute. More from IndeMed: indemed.org/what-does-federa…

Post attachment
Wendell Potter avatar
⟳ IndeMed retweeted
Wendell Potter@wendellpotter·Oct 16

UnitedHealth Group’s profits just jumped 75% to *$4.1 BILLION* in a single quarter. Earlier this week, I dug into its latest earnings report and what executives said on their call with Wall Street analysts. Here's what stood out: healthcareuncovered.substack…

Post attachment
Congressman Greg Murphy, M.D. avatar
⟳ IndeMed retweeted
Congressman Greg Murphy, M.D.@RepGregMurphy·Oct 16

Health insurance companies should work for patients, not stand in the way of their care. As a physician, I’ve seen how insurance denials can delay treatment and put patients in difficult positions. Our health insurance system needs serious reform that puts patients first and ensures Americans can access the care their doctors recommend.

5:51
Scott Becker avatar
⟳ IndeMed retweeted
Scott Becker@BKRBusinessMin·Oct 17

The insurance companies pushed through the no surprises act on the false premise that it was for patients. It was all about improving negotiating leverage for insurance companies. Now that it’s not going how they want it they are putting on massive pressure to change the way in which pricing disputes are handled. Abhorrent

I love IDR. Apparently, an insurance company having to defend what it pays a physician is a national affordability crisis. Meanwhile, a hospital can buy that physician’s practice and collect more for the same care. Washington built a financial reward for changing the name on the door. Start there. Start with the tax-exempt hospital corporations buying their competitors while taxpayers subsidize the enterprise. Start with Section 6001, which restricts physician-owned hospital entry and expansion. Congress actually wrote a law protecting incumbent hospitals from physicians who want to compete with them. Then everybody sits around wondering why healthcare costs so much. I build healthcare businesses. When you subsidize the incumbent, restrict its competition, and pay it more for owning the building, you have engineered an expensive market. @HHS and @CMSGov: enforce price transparency. Stop paying a premium for hospital ownership. Congress: repeal Section 6001. Let physicians build. Let employers buy directly from them. And keep a process that lets physicians challenge an insurer’s payment without handing the patient a surprise bill. I’m tired of a healthcare affordability debate that keeps arriving at the independent physician’s paycheck while the subsidized hospital buys another ZIP code.

Action for Health avatar
⟳ IndeMed retweeted
Action for Health@A4Horg·Oct 15

In a new op-ed for @CrainsNewYork today, our President Christopher Sheeron explains how health insurance plans are driving healthcare costs. He also argues that Albany’s removal of Medicaid Managed Care disputes from the state's IDR process deserves scrutiny. Undoing this budget failure will keep patients—rather than health insurers’ financial incentives—at the center of Albany’s healthcare policy. crainsnewyork.com/opinion/co…

Adam Bruggeman, MD avatar
⟳ IndeMed retweeted
Adam Bruggeman, MD@DrBruggeman·Oct 14

Insurers caused 9 of every 10 defaults in federal arbitration in 2025. They offered $1 or less 278,807 times. Half the time, they offered their own artificially low number or less. Now Representative Pallone's bill would let them skip the arbitrator altogether. Keep the referee. Read more here: indemed.org/keep-the-referee @IndeMedAction

Post attachment