←
Jane Darby Menton1,610 posts
Jane Darby Menton avatar

Jane Darby Menton

@JDMenton

Fellow @carnegienpp and director of the Carnegie International Nuclear Policy Conference; prev @BerkeleyRisk PhD @Dept_of_POLIS, @OxfordMEC. Itinerant Floridian

◷ Joined May 2011▧ 79 Photos and videos
Jane Darby Menton avatar
Jane Darby Menton@JDMenton·24 Oct 2024

For @CarnegieEndow I wrote about the perils of nuclear ambiguity, and what Iran (and the world) can learn from the saga of Iraq's nuclear program. TLDR: playing political football with international oversight rarely ends well for anyone: carnegieendowment.org/resear…

Carnegie Endowment avatar
⟳ Jane Darby Menton retweeted
Carnegie Endowment@CarnegieEndow·Sep 28

Please join us in welcoming Avril Haines, who begins her first day today as the 11th President of the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace.

Post attachment
Matt Sheehan avatar
⟳ Jane Darby Menton retweeted
Matt Sheehan@mattsheehan88·Sep 16

Genuine career highlight for me + lots of fun to join @ezraklein for a long conversation on Chinese AI policy & what that means for upcoming 🇺🇸-🇨🇳 talks. We recorded this last Thursday so **if** anything happened after that we might not have covered it... nytimes.com/2026/09/15/opini…

Laura Holgate🌻 avatar
⟳ Jane Darby Menton retweeted
Laura Holgate🌻@LauraSHHolgate·Sep 11

Excellent breakdown by @JDMenton on the US-Saudi nuclear agreement. Congress should make good use of the 90-day review period to satisfy themselves on the significant ambiguities and to attach legislation to shore up weaknesses.

After a dramatic rollout, Saudi Arabia and the U.S. are finally on the verge of a civil nuclear cooperation agreement. But what does the deal entail? And what does it leave behind? @JDMenton explains: carnegieendowment.org/emissa…

Carnegie Endowment avatar
⟳ Jane Darby Menton retweeted
Carnegie Endowment@CarnegieEndow·Sep 9

After a dramatic rollout, Saudi Arabia and the U.S. are finally on the verge of a civil nuclear cooperation agreement. But what does the deal entail? And what does it leave behind? @JDMenton explains: carnegieendowment.org/emissa…

Jane Darby Menton avatar
Jane Darby Menton@JDMenton·Sep 9

As I wrote for @CarnegieEndow the Saudi 123 tries to set its own standard, but the public text is notably vague on some key issues (e.g. alleged exclusivity commitments, the full scope of bilateral safeguards, what exactly was agreed re enrichment).

Jane Darby Menton avatar
Jane Darby Menton@JDMenton·Sep 9

The text of the U.S.-Saudi nuclear cooperation agreement is out... that it doesn't meet the nonpro "gold standard" isn't news. The real question is whether the case for it holds up, or if if this deal is gilded rather than golden.

Carnegie Middle East Program / برنامج الشرق الأوسط avatar
⟳ Jane Darby Menton retweeted
Carnegie Middle East Program / برنامج الشرق الأوسط@CarnegieMEP·Jul 27

As questions swirl around the U.S.-Saudi nuclear agreement, @AndrewMLeber and @JDMenton break down the details and impact of the deal in a new Q&A: carnegieendowment.org/emissa…

Jane Darby Menton avatar
Jane Darby Menton@JDMenton·Jul 23

Some thoughts with @AndrewMLeber about the U.S. Saudi civil nuclear cooperation agreement, which was a long time coming, and now seems to be in flux by the hour.

Andrew Leber@AndrewMLeber Jul 23 ALT Jane Darby Menton: Peaceful nuclear cooperation agreements, known colloquially as 123 agreements (after the relevant section in the U.S. Atomic Energy Act), rarely make headlines, but this one stands out. Although the administration has not yet released the full text, the agreement reportedly will not require Riyadh to categorically forgo fuel cycle activities that would be conducive to a nuclear weapons program (namely enrichment and reprocessing) or to accept the highest standard of International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) safeguards, known as the Additional Protocol, or AP. These were key sticking points in previous nuclear negotiations with Saudi Arabia and other partners ALT I should caveat that there’s a lot of uncertainty swirling around this agreement, not least because President Donald Trump has posted conflicting information on social media, including emphatically denying that it permits enrichment. Still, the deal clearly departs from the United States’ own “gold standard” for nuclear technology–sharing, and this matters, especially in a region that has a long and troubled history of covert nuclear weapons programs. On that point, this announcement comes in the middle of a conflict that was predicated (at least in part) on concerns about Iran’s nuclear program. Saudi leaders have also brought scrutiny on themselves by explicitly saying that the kingdom will pursue nuclear weapons if Iran acquires them. ALT Andrew Leber: The agreement is a big deal given longstanding U.S. concerns about nuclear proliferation in the Middle East. The only previous 123 agreements signed with countries in the region were with Türkiye, a NATO treaty ally, and the UAE, which adopted the so-called gold standard, forgoing the right to enrichment and agreeing to additional IAEA inspection protocols. The United States has had a much more troubled relationship with Saudi Arabia, between the domestic Saudi radicalization that contributed to the 9/11 terrorist attacks and more recent U.S. outrage over a Saudi-led military intervention in Yemen and human rights abuses at home. The U.S.-Saudi relationship has improved in recent years, but—as Jane noted—de facto Saudi ruler Mohammed bin Salman (MBS) has continued to pledge that Saudi Arabia would follow suit should Iran ever develop nuclear weapons. An added irony is that Iran’s own nuclear program began with a U.S.-Iranian agreement under President Dwight D. Eisenhower

Post attachmentPost attachmentPost attachment
Andrew Leber avatar
⟳ Jane Darby Menton retweeted
Andrew Leber@AndrewMLeber·Jul 23

Resounding silence from Saudi media outlets and most commentators since Trump’s latest post about the nuclear deal.

The Wall Street Journal avatar
⟳ Jane Darby Menton retweeted
The Wall Street Journal@WSJ·Jul 22

President Trump has formally approved a landmark agreement with Saudi Arabia that will provide the country with a civilian nuclear program and potentially open the door to uranium enrichment in the kingdom’s territory, according to U.S. officials. on.wsj.com/3RaoTge

Jane Darby Menton avatar
Jane Darby Menton@JDMenton·Jul 16

Would like to bring back this memo style pls

The declassified 1962 memo for the UK prime minister informing him (in shakespearean prose) that the US accidentally fried Britain's Ariel satellite with its Starfish Prime high-altitude nuclear test.

Post attachment
Patrick Kidd avatar
⟳ Jane Darby Menton retweeted
Patrick Kidd@patrick_kidd·Jul 15

And so the World Cup final will be between two teams who couldn’t beat Cape Verde in 90 minutes.