←
Jacob Shell36,858 posts
Jacob Shell avatar

Jacob Shell

@JacobAShell

Geographer. Prof at Temple University. Author of 2 books. Elephants. Maps. Archaeofuturist Transportation.

◷ Joined December 2016▧ 4,690 Photos and videos
Jacob Shell avatar
Jacob Shell@JacobAShell·Apr 11

Can't stop staring at this GIF of the lower mantle's anomalous slow-wave mega-blobs...which might be last remnants of the paleo-planet Theia which collided with proto-Earth 4.5 billion years ago to create "our" Earth and the Moon.

Jacob Shell avatar
Jacob Shell@JacobAShell·11h

Every single Mike Davis "Ecology of Fear" characterization of L.A. taken as hyperbole at the time turning out to be 100% accurate prediction (he had the Palisades burning down too).

Massive Geyser of Rotting Trash Erupted in LA Routine drilling at Chiquita Canyon landfill released a towering geyser of decomposing garbage and methane gas about 500 feet into the air. Just another day in LA 🤣

0:44
Jacob Shell avatar
Jacob Shell@JacobAShell·13h

Remarkable how many little perks of academic lifestyle vanished after 2020.

Jacob Shell avatar
⟳ Jacob Shell retweeted
Jacob Shell@JacobAShell·16h

A lot of the “smart classroom” gear is not only proving to be a waste of money, it’s literally a physical obstacle that makes rooms perform badly as discussion or paper test-taking spaces. And it introduces AI consoles into spaces where AI undermines pedagogy. In many cases the “smart classroom” gear should simply be removed—but that would involve the people who blew so much money on it (money that could have gone into scholarships, research, etc) admitting that it was a mistake.

Jacob Shell avatar
Jacob Shell@JacobAShell·16h

Uni leaders dont want to talk about how attractive & logical the “low-tech strategy” suddenly looks, because it would require admitting that blowing so much of the budget last decade on “smart classrooms” (jampacked full of computer gear on every last square inch) was a bad idea.

Yeah, a lot of these things would be quite easy to enforce if you went deliberately low-tech, which a residential liberal arts college could do relatively easily. Bring back the 24-hour computer lab, ban personal laptops, ban smartphones.

Jacob Shell avatar
Jacob Shell@JacobAShell·22h

I basically agree with this, but "teach like it's permanently the 1990s" is not the way to define it or frame it. It's a losing argument, just like "teach like it's permanently the 1890s" was a losing argument over the course of the 20th century. There's no need to frame this in such a nostalgic way. Instead, optimal instruction needs to be defined as "uses whatever tools and facilities are needed to keep the analytical burden inside of students' brains." Functionally, that means pivoting from digital back to paper, or to real objects (e.g. real spherical globes, which an AI can't auto-analyze, rather than digital maps). It means pivoting to in-class testing and having proper facilities for that. It also means picking reading types where none of the important information about the reading is conveyed from AI-generated summaries. This actually reenshrines many forms of fiction, where an engaged student would certainly prefer to learn what happens next by actually reading the story than reading an AI-generated list of spoilers. Furthermore this reenshrines examples of philosophy and theory where the author's writing style is somehow a core component of the overall argument, and so the "summary" cannot actually convey the argument. Spengler is like this. Many other philosophers are too (though certainly not all). Great film is like this too of course. Imagine not watching 2001: A Space Odyssey and instead only reading an AI-generated list of plot points. That student would have no idea what the movie was like.

Always worth reiterating re higher ed AI policy that the choice is not between extreme anti-AI measures and moderation. There are only two choices, both extreme: teach like it’s the 1990s, or accept the slow but steady collapse of liberal education and mass literacy.

Jacob Shell avatar
Jacob Shell@JacobAShell·23h

I strongly recommend a short PBS documentary from 1988 called "Feynman: The Quest for Tannu Tuva" about physicist Richard Feynman's obsession in childhood, and again towards the end of his life, with the mysterious country of Tuva. His brain was excited by mystical themes.

Post attachment

Between 1921 and 1944 there was a country bigger than England in the middle of Asia. Only two other states ever recognised it, and one of them was its owner. I bet you’ve never heard of it: Tannu Tuva. 1/n

Post attachment
Jacob Shell avatar
Jacob Shell@JacobAShell·Nov 17

I feel this way about an immense portion of the general "verbiage" that was being produced by and for 21st century academia. I've always tried to maintain my "true author" voice in my academic writing, especially my books. But the fact is most academic writing isn't like that, and the system doesn't really incentivize writing which is like that. The system has been promoting and producing writing which is essentially manufactured by committee; writing which is ideologically formulaic, consensus-driven, and in terms of voice quite "authorless." Well...of course AI can do that kind of writing just as well! In fact it's as if most academics have been playing the part of AI before there was AI.

Of course college admissions essays will be replaced by AI. They were slop the whole time, and AI can make slop much better than people can. Clear improvement in efficiency here with no loss in truth value.

Nature Unedited avatar
⟳ Jacob Shell retweeted
Nature Unedited@NatureUnedited·Nov 17

A marine biologist records an octopus changing colors while apparently sleeping

0:20
Matt Strohl avatar
⟳ Jacob Shell retweeted
Matt Strohl@strohltopia·Nov 16

100% correct thread. I haven’t gotten any support from my campus for detecting and dealing with AI cheating, but I have gotten invites to workshops about how to integrate AI into my assignments and then have AI grade them for me.

By focusing on people like this being "bad professors" we're giving a free pass to institutions that incentivize students and faculty to behave this way. The AI crisis in higher ed isn't caused by personal moral failings it's structurally produced by the universities themselves.

Cheese For Everyone! avatar
⟳ Jacob Shell retweeted
Cheese For Everyone!@CheeseForEvery1·Nov 16

Ditto. I have stopped doing out-of-class writing entirely. Colleagues who have not have received next to no support from administration when AI is used on assignments. Gotta “meet the students where they are,” after all

100% correct thread. I haven’t gotten any support from my campus for detecting and dealing with AI cheating, but I have gotten invites to workshops about how to integrate AI into my assignments and then have AI grade them for me.

Jacob Shell avatar
Jacob Shell@JacobAShell·Nov 16

Higher ed has just received a "woke" death blow...and it was the Trump admin that dealt it. Here's how. Trump's Justice Dept is enforcing new compliance guidelines, "Accessibility of Web Information and Services" (ADA, Title II), that make doing pretty much everything a prof would want to do in college impossible. My first inkling of this was when we tried to update our dept website with a Cy Twombly painting. An admin denied our request on the grounds that the scrawling lettering on the painting could not be interpreted by an automated text reader for the visually impaired. In other words, Cy Twombly's painting was not digestible by the "equity and justice" machinery mandated by the Justice Dept. So much the worse for Twombly! He's now exiled from higher ed. This same censoriousness will extend to the materials we make available to students online through email, Google Drive, or course management software. All our teaching materials will have to go thru compliance checking software and then be modified by that software to bring them into compliance, if possible, or nixed like our Twombly painting, if not. The standards dictate fonts, font size, and even prohibit contrast below a certain level, so forget getting creative with your text and images. Technically, you can still hand out or display in class whatever you want...but one request that your classroom materials be made accessible outside the classroom, and just like that, your stuff is subject to gov't surveillance and modification. This is the end of basic academic freedom and a crippling blow to teaching. Thanks Trump!* *Technically, these new rules were passed under Biden, in 2024, but the Trump DoJ is vigorously enforcing them. Destroying higher ed is a bipartisan project.

Post attachment
Jacob Shell avatar
Jacob Shell@JacobAShell·Nov 16

If i upload this map to Canvas, for my college cartography course, it will be "flagged" for being "too visual" and thus "bad for access." This is a new type of bureaucratic oversight / surveillance since 2025. It has to do with federal policy...@anecdotal has discussed this topic (see next post). So, there's oversight to surveil the maps that geography professors show to their students in class...but no oversight to prevent those scandalized adjuncts in the UC system from teaching dozens of online classes simultaneously and scamming thousands of students. There's a thick layer of university bureaucracy for enforcing "compliance" standards which clearly nobody thought through before imposing it as the new law of the land...but nobody in administration asking faculty "hey what do you need for better in-class testing facilities, to deal with the reality of AI?" Higher ed is losing the plot!

Post attachment
Jacob Shell avatar
Jacob Shell@JacobAShell·Nov 16

EG for my cartography class, there's an in-class test question I'd like to offer where every student could be given a globe (real, physical) and some other physical items. But I would need the resources! The room, the desks (hopefully visually divided so there's no cheating), the globes, etc. I would need a level of uni administration dedicated to asking faculty "hey what do YOU NEED for effective, AI-proofed in-class testing?" and actually providing it.

Jacob Shell avatar
Jacob Shell@JacobAShell·Nov 16

EG for my cartography class, there's an in-class test question I'd like to offer where every student could be given a globe (real, physical) and some other physical items. But I would need the resources! The room, the desks (hopefully visually divided so there's no cheating), the globes, etc. I would need a level of uni administration dedicated to asking faculty "hey what do YOU NEED for effective, AI-proofed in-class testing?" and actually providing it.