←
Janina Dill3,659 posts
Janina Dill avatar✓

Janina Dill ✓

@JaninaDill

Professor @UniofOxford's @BlavatnikSchool, Fellow @TrinityOxford, Co-director @ELAC_Oxford: Law & Ethics of War, Global Security (in pers. capacity)

◷ Joined April 2015▧ 290 Photos and videos
Adil Haque avatar
⟳ Janina Dill retweeted
Adil Haque@AdHaque110·14h

On a technical level, this piece is misleading. The Gambia and Myanmar agree that the Court should apply existing law, not "deviate" from it. If the Court is fully convinced that Myanmar acted with both genocidal intent and military aims then genocide is proven. 1/

Post attachment
Janina Dill avatar
Janina Dill@JaninaDill·16h

Not all Bridges! A bridge is a military objective IF it makes an effective contribution to mil action (like #KerchBridge, a major mil supply route) & attacking it yields a def mil advantage. Today is a good day to reiterate that #IHL demands an-objet-by-object assessment.

Post attachmentPost attachment
Tom Dannenbaum avatar
⟳ Janina Dill retweeted
Tom Dannenbaum@tomdannenbaum·22h

Our assessment that the strike violated precautionary obligations is in line with that of many analysts. I have seen fewer parallels to our assessment that the strike violated distinction, as operationalized through the rule on doubt. Here is why. Image 1: AJIL. Images 2-3: JS.

Post attachmentPost attachmentPost attachmentPost attachment
Janina Dill avatar
Janina Dill@JaninaDill·Nov 15

because it is possible that the findings on intent better resemble CAH, such as extermination and persecution, or war crimes, over which the Court has no jurisdiction.

Janina Dill avatar
Janina Dill@JaninaDill·Nov 15

One clarification: When I say that I am not entirely confident that the ICJ will find that Israel is committing genocide, that is not because Israel’s conduct is legally redeemable, but

Janina Dill avatar
Janina Dill@JaninaDill·Nov 15

whether, at that point, the UK can in theory be found responsible for violating its duty to prevent genocide. Whether the UK was in 2024 or is now violating this duty turns on the objective evidence of a serious risk of genocide then and now.

Post attachment
Janina Dill avatar
Janina Dill@JaninaDill·Nov 15

I was asked about “my own personal prediction” what the ICJ will find & that is what I qualify as “immaterial” for how we assess continued arms transfers in 2024, 2025 & now. Whether the ICJ eventually finds that Israel is committing genocide in Gaza will be relevant for ...

Janina Dill avatar
Janina Dill@JaninaDill·Nov 15

The ICJ has clarified that the duty "arise[s] at the instant that the State learns of, or should normally have learned of, the existence of a serious risk that genocide will be committed." (early 2024) & "extends over the entire period during which the event continues".

Post attachment
Janina Dill avatar
Janina Dill@JaninaDill·Nov 15

My sense is that Labor made real changes that may respond to the requirements of the Arms Trade Treaty but fall short of the duty to prevent genocide, which the previous Labour gov mischaracterized several times as hinging on an ICJ judgment. See: justsecurity.org/121169/uk-m…

Janina Dill avatar
Janina Dill@JaninaDill·Nov 15

The duty to prevent genocide implied a duty for the Conservative gov to “employ all means reasonable available” to the UK to prevent genocide in Gaza, including an arms embargo. We know what discharging the duty looks like i.e. from the 2007 ICJ Judgment in Bosnia v. Serbia 👇

Post attachment
Janina Dill avatar
Janina Dill@JaninaDill·Nov 15

3) The Genocide Convention. The clip focuses on the duty to prevent genocide, triggered in 2024, i.a., by three #ICJ prov. measures orders identifying a “real & imminent risk" of irreparable prejudice to the rights of Palestinians i.a. not to be subject to genocide. 3rd order 👇

Post attachment